Who got lucky? Quintana or Williams?

So your whole criteria to why Q doesn't deserve a rubbermatch is because he got caught with a punch in the first round? pretty weak. no its not weak The round where a fighter can come out cold...or not properly warmed up or could have been distracted or many other things? yeah, but a fighter should know that and at that level of championship boxing, quitnana should never get KTFO in the first round. Seems to me if Pwill would have wooped his ass for 3 rounds and then knocked him out and showed some kind of boxing supremacy I would look at it as a much more devastating win...and not just Q had an off night...or his head wasn't in the fight. you're welcome to your opinion, but a 1st round KtFO means no rubbermatch to most poeople Lucky punches happen all the time.... just because it was at 1st round KTFO doesn't make it a lucky punch. Embarrassing 12 round ass woopin/boxing lessons seldom ever happen. yeah, but at 1st round KTFO erases all that

So to you getting caught by a punch in the first round(can happen to anyone as the saying goes) is a more impressive way to victory then 12 rounds of a boxing lesson where a fighter wins just about every exchange of punches and busts up the fighters face without getting so much as staggerd by anything the other fighter throws at him??? yes You look at the world through very different eyes as most people I know. of course, i'm not puerto rican. See to me the long sustained beating over 12 rounds is a much more impressive way to win a fight...as opposed to just getting caught by a punch and being "ktfo" as you put it. at quitnana's and pwill's level, getting KTFO in the 1st round should never happen, when it does happen then asking for a rubbermatch doesn't make sense I don't really understand while Pwil gets the benefit of having a bad night or over looking a guy...but Q gets caught with a lucky punch(I only call it lucky because they already went 12 rounds and Pwill couldn't hurt him with anything) and isn't deserving of the same benefit. neither had a bad night, quitnana won the 1st fight, congrats to him, but getting KTFO in the 1st round of the rematch eliminates the possibility of a rubbermatch. I wonder why that is? HMMMMMM...somebody please help me with this conundrum. getting KTFO in the first round means the other guy doesn't have to fight you again.

lol well, I say Quintana really underestimated PW on the Rematch. A third fight is a most I'm not suprise that U do not know about boxing and speak out of your ass; George Foreman vs Joe Frazier before my time can't comment on this Roy Jones vs Atonio Tarver wasn't a 1st round KTfO you and I know this fight should've never happened Erik Morales vs Manny Pacquiao wasn't a 1st round KTfO Israel Vazquez vs. Rafael Marquez the traded KOs, not a decision for a KO wasn't a 1st round KTfO Julio Cesar Chavez vs Oscar De La Hoya that was a rermatch not a rubbermatch wasn't a 1st round KTfO Jermain Taylor vs Kelly Pavlik that was a rermatch not a rubbermatch wasn't a 1st round KTfO Diego Corrales vs Jose Luis Castilo the traded KOs, not a decision for a KO wasn't a 1st round KTfO Fernando Vargas vs Shane Mosley that was a rermatch not a rubbermatch wasn't a 1st round KTfO Vernon Forrest vs Ricardo Mayorga that was a rermatch not a rubbermatch wasn't a 1st round KTfO Kermit Cintron vs Margarito that was a rermatch not a rubbermatch wasn't a 1st round KTfO And this is just the ones I could think of for right now!!! epic fail for each one. no one gets a rematch/rubbermatch for a 1st round KTFO

lol well, I say Quintana really underestimated PW on the Rematch. A third fight is a most its not necessary, i"ve never heard of a KTFO getting a rubbermatch ever. I'm not suprise that U do not know about boxing and speak out of your ass; George Foreman vs Joe Frazier Roy Jones vs Atonio Tarver Erik Morales vs Manny Pacquiao Israel Vazquez vs. Rafael Marquez Julio Cesar Chavez vs Oscar De La Hoya Jermain Taylor vs Kelly Pavlik Diego Corrales vs Jose Luis Castilo Fernando Vargas vs Shane Mosley Vernon Forrest vs Ricardo Mayorga Kermit Cintron vs Margarito And this is just the ones I could think of for right now!!!!

lol well, I say Quintana really underestimated PW on the Rematch. A third fight is a most its not necessary, i"ve never heard of a KTFO getting a rubbermatch ever. I'm not convince by a first round knockout. then nothing can convince you because a 1st round KTFO is as convincing as it gets in boxing. Paul Williams could of come in with loaded gloves and we would never know just because he won in the first round. proof? So a guy beats you in a big fight and you can get lucky in the 2nd. Quintana was disturbed by Paul Williams team. He wasn't sure he would fight him untill the last month. They were playing games and that could've distract his training. I think a rubbermatch can be made if quitnana unfies 154 or atleast grabs 2 belts

Lets say the first fight was a learner and PW comes out a winner.. He was an impressive avenger.. In fact, Williams is a born winner in many respects as his popularity seems to be multiplying.. Good luck to him..

I'm not convince by a first round knockout. Paul Williams could of come in with loaded gloves and we would never know just because he won in the first round. So a guy beats you in a big fight and you can get lucky in the 2nd. Quintana was disturbed by Paul Williams team. He wasn't sure he would fight him untill the last month. They were playing games and that could've distract his training.

pwill wasnt even suppose to fight quintana you idiots he had a fight wit kermit cintron for a unification but cintron had some mystery injury and backed out so they change opponents at the last minute. you can tell williams took him lightly probally cause cotto knock him out but he fought him and lost a close sd. who cares? shit it happens he ko in one round in the rematch. if they fought 10x pwill would win 9!

neither was lucky. pwill underestimated quitnana, but KTFO quitnana in the rematch... there is no reason for the rubbermatch lol well, I say Quintana really underestimated PW on the Rematch. A third fight is a most

quitnana got KTFO in one round... there's no need for a rubbermatch unless quitnana grabs a few belts

neither was lucky. pwill underestimated quitnana, but KTFO quitnana in the rematch... there is no reason for the rubbermatch

Since Carlos Quintana has called out Paul Williams and Paul hasn't answered back, does this mean that Quintana is the "most avoided" boxer on the planet? I mean even the "most avoided" boxer is avoiding him.

I wouldn't say either guy got lucky. I would love to see a 3rd fight. If I had to pick one guy I would say Williams got lucky though. You can depend on luck when you try to land a lucky punch, you can not just outbox a guy in every way shape and form from just being lucky.

Carlos Quintana Vs Paul Williams 3 would be worth watching.....:boxing: Yeah but PW do not want anything with Quintana and I think it would be hard for PW to make weight at 147 again!

Carlos Quintana Vs Paul Williams 3 would be worth watching.....:boxing:

how bout they fight again to settle it?

lol most ppl admits Williams was lucky to beat Quintana on the 2nd fight lol

u rather watch paul williams and some espn fighter fight than watch a floyd fight? boy whats wrong with u? Quintana has never fought on ESPN

after paul is done with winky he should go down to 147 just to shut the critics up Williams will NEVER make 147 again.

none got lucky.quintana just got stupid.