These 2 fighters have met a total of 2 times.
The first fight ended in a Quintana victory, the second ended in a Williams victory.
Quintana vs. Williams I
In their first meeting, Williams was completely dominated by Quintana, a 6-to-1 underdog, for 12 rounds. Carlos out thought, out skilled, out boxed the much bigger and stronger Williams. Quintana showed what true boxing ability can over come that night.
Quintana vs. Williams II
In their second meeting, Quintana was completely dominated by Williams as Paul used his physical advantages such as his strength and size to pressure Carlos landing big combinations taking Quintana out in the first round. Williams showed what true pressure coupled with power and strength can do that night.
Now, both fighters are 1 and 1 against each other. Why not a 3rd? According to this poll I created, a fighter winning on skill, intelligence and boxing ability is more impressive than a fight who's physical advantages serve him more.
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/poll.php?do=showresults&pollid=16241
So if Quintana's victory was more impressive? Shouldn't that indicate that a rubber match is needed? Assuming Williams gets past Wright?
Paul claims no one wants to fight him, yet the guy who, according to this forum, beat him more impressively than PWill did to him wants to fight and Willy aint even lookin his way.
im still amazed when i see that first fight though, man quintana was nailing him perfect. i rememeber being bored that saturday and i was like "oh shit todays the quintana williams fight let's see in how many rounds williams destroys him...my dad was sleeping..and after 4 rounds i was like HOLY SHIT QUINTANA CAN WIN THIS i woke him up and we were both screaming like little girls cuz i was just so amazed at quintana beating him on every round...
Bro... same here. First time was a pleasant shock. I enjoyed losing money. I thought he was going to gat robbed agaisnt the favorite Paul Williams. When Quintana was announced the winner, I lost my voice for the rest of the night screaming excited as Quintana became the 3rd Puertorrican WelterWeight Champion during that period of time. I never heard of that before. Cotto, Cintron and Quintana were reignning champs at the same time. Too bad they all lost afterwards.
Anyway... for the second fight, I prepared a complex scoring system for 12 rounds cheet of paper. My wife was excited about the fight because she saw all the time I dedicated designning my scoring paper. Imagine a loud boricua women laughing her ass off and making fun of you as you stand in silence and in shock... Quintana did not make it to the 2nd round. The paper was still laying around the familyroom for the last Cotto fight.
I finally got this thread. There isn’t a Mexican boxer than can beat Williams now, so you nuthug a fighter who is closer to Mexicans now
It all makes senseyou realised!!!!!!!!!!it all makes sense????//
oh! i get it
you sound like hitler, when hitler stated a colored guy or anyone cant beat anyone from the aryan race, you are the black fuhrer, you are the modern day hitler,
you now realize huh, you got some ideas huh, now go write your new version of your black mein kemph of how superior the black man is to whites, mexicans, asians, jews,
all hail malcolm hitler, nyahahaha
He should hes fighting in a weight class 15 pounds heavier.
Thought Williams could go all the way to at least Super Middle? Wasn't he calling out Hopkins?
Thinking about it, I actually think Williams could hold his own against Chad. I know Williams can move and use the ring if needed and I bet thats what he would do against someone bigger and stronger than him.
I finally got this thread. There isn’t a Mexican boxer than can beat Williams now, so you nuthug a fighter who is closer to Mexicans now
It all makes sense
I've never nuthug'd Chad Dawson, but he would destroy Williams. I don't know what you're talking about.
When will they be fair right Flawless?
malcolm isnt even allowed to go inside a public bathroom to take a shit, malcolm is dealing with injustice everday, hes the modern day rosa parks, i said rosa parks cause malcolm is half woman
This forum is dominated by whites and Hispanics. I would not be surprised if most of you guys scored JCC-Pernell fight for JCC.
When will they be fair right Flawless?
Lol @ Your Clown ass...
Hey, You should post that video of you getting your ass beat for talking shit.
You lucky I leaving work right now or I will search For that thread and post that Video of you getting your ass beat.!
But dont worry you will be famous soon...LOL
Just wait until I get home.
THAT VIEDO is getting POSTED TONIGHT...
OR I WILL GIVE ANYBODY
30K If they can find and post the video of this dude getting his ass beat.
Real talk.
yeah, That video is on right now, its on HBO, its on you tube, i got my ass kicked, LOL, then i resurected and took a shit on that video,
nyahahahaha, i will find that video for you horse, as soon as oj finds anna nicles real murderers, you will get that video, thank you horse
Are you literally that stupid?? Or are you fucking around with us.
You actually think Carlos did enough to win 12 whole rounds. When did I claim robbery you stupid midget. I agree Carlos Q won the fight but it was a lot closer than people think
dont shoot me man, i swear, i didnt steal your bike ,nyahahaha
whats up horse, still debating over floyds yacht business,
what happened to the girly fancy threads filled with facts, neatnes, indenting, happy embellished facts and floyd praise on every other line.
its is interesting you stopped using that feminen style of posting as soon as i....................................
nyahahahaha
nice to see your back , take care, horse
Lol @ Your Clown ass...
Hey, You should post that video of you getting your ass beat for talking shit.
You lucky I leaving work right now or I will search For that thread and post that Video of you getting your ass beat.!
But dont worry you will be famous soon...LOL
Just wait until I get home.
THAT VIEDO is getting POSTED TONIGHT...
OR I WILL GIVE ANYBODY
30K If they can find and post the video of this dude getting his ass beat.
Real talk.
Are you literally that stupid?? Or are you fucking around with us.
You actually think Carlos did enough to win 12 whole rounds. When did I claim robbery you stupid midget. I agree Carlos Q won the fight but it was a lot closer than people think
when you say people, you mean the majority of people who saw that fight? because the majority of the people who saw that fight are not giving Williams more than 4 rounds in that fight. But then again, everyone is a racist right? Bunch of mexicans and white people hating on Williams right?
You still havent answered my question, why do you have to resort to making up shiit when debating with me?
Carlos Q won 12 rounds. You know someone has a real agenda when they think that
the black panthers do, you should stand up up for the robbery from williams, paul won that fight huh malcolm, malcolm , go and fight injustice so paul can get that robbery reversed vs quintana, paul fought like a champion in the first quintana fight, huh
He could not make it to the 3rd Round
Hell
He could not make it 3rd Minute of the 1st Round!
So how can he ask for a 3rd fight?
If there is any circumstance in which a their should not be a trilogy, the circumstances would be somebody getting KTFO before the 3 minute mark in the 1st round.
This is funny because the same people asking for Paul Williams to Rematch Carlos.
Are the same people who do not want to see Floyd give hatton a rematch.
I wonder why is that so?
Now this should be interesting...!!
whats up horse, still debating over floyds yacht business,
what happened to the girly fancy threads filled with facts, neatnes, indenting, happy embellished facts and floyd praise on every other line.
its is interesting you stopped using that feminen style of posting as soon as i....................................
nyahahahaha
nice to see your back , take care, horse
Why are you after the Williams-Carlos 3?
You were the one defending Margarito from not fighting Williams in a rematch
Really?
Sorry to say that it will look like a bitch move on part of Margo. I understand that he now has the possibility to get the fights he wants, but avenging his loss to Williams should be the next thing on his mind besides big money fights. We cant keep calling him the most feared man in boxing if he doesnt want to fight the last guy that beat him and is also at the top of the WW division. Its only fair.
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=199325&highlight=Margarito
I will ask you again and hopefully you will man up. Why do you resort to lying? Are you insecure about your capacity to debate? There has not been ONE time when you have not made up a lie or a post regarding me in order to get a point across. Why?
He could not make it to the 3rd Round
Hell
He could not make it 3rd Minute of the 1st Round!
So how can he ask for a 3rd fight?
If there is any circumstance in which a their should not be a trilogy, the circumstances would be somebody getting KTFO before the 3 minute mark in the 1st round.
This is funny because the same people asking for Paul Williams to Rematch Carlos.
Are the same people who do not want to see Floyd give hatton a rematch.
I wonder why is that so?
Now this should be interesting...!!
Who is talking about Floyd my friend?
He could not make it to the 3rd Round
Hell
He could not make it 3rd Minute of the 1st Round!
So how can he ask for a 3rd fight?
If there is any circumstance in which a their should not be a trilogy, the circumstances would be somebody getting KTFO before the 3 minute mark in the 1st round.
This is funny because the same people asking for Paul Williams to Rematch Carlos.
Are the same people who do not want to see Floyd give hatton a rematch.
I wonder why is that so?
Now this should be interesting...!!
112-116 | judge: Tony Crebs 112-116 | judge: Jose Cobian 113-115 ~
YEA, THATS REAL DOMINATION!!! WINNING 7-5 AND 8-4 ISNT DOMINATION IN MY BOOK...
DOMINATION IS HOPKINS VS PAVLIK - WINKY VS TRINIDAD
Quintanas win was nearly as dominating as those. Please
even though this dominant performance was misjudged, like i stated, quintana arguably won 12 rounds, great fight, carlos was a master on this ****** ass unwarriorlike boxing performance, he looked like mayweather against a bum
Andy Koelle was a stay busy at a new weight.
Phillips was a 154 pound titlist.
Like I said Paul is AFTER big fights...
When the fukk did he call out Phillips and Koelle...dont get it in here and act like Paul doesnt want the big boys...
everyone wants the big boys that doesnt make him special