Latest Ring Mag P4P (as of 3/1/2009): Pac still #1, JMM #2

Whas up with Caballero? He gets on but Cotto dont!? Pffft!

if Chad Dawson is not on that list, then Sugar Shane Mosley is too high. Yes, Shane is high. Look at his eyes. It's obvious! 100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

if Chad Dawson is not on that list, then Sugar Shane Mosley is too high.

Why? because he beat jennings? Cotto exited the list when he lost to Margarito and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on. Hatton dominated the #1 rated guy at his weight and deserves to be on the list. Maybe Cotto losing shouldnt have taken him off the list in the first place? The "number one guy" at Hatton's weight was already beaten by Cotto. And he wasn't that good.

hatton shouldnt be on the list... he wasnt last issue right? He was,i think he's been on since Malignaggi fight.

hatton shouldnt be on the list... he wasnt last issue right?

rafael marque needs to get the **** out of that list. seriously the ring is getting phony. hatton would be fine at 9 or 10 but caballero?

Other than my usual objections to Calderon (I've gone over this before, and his fans & I will never agree), and a slight objection to Caballero (but I can see the argument for him). I think the list is fine.

it's fair!!!

Cotto was beaten By Marga Cheato. I Pick Cheato to beat Cotto but This is about ratings. Cheato's gone. I Give Cotto the benefit of the doubt. He still got Mosley, Quintana & a lot of Good former undefeated guys in his resume. I don't think Cotto should have been taken off the list, but he was and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on IMO

We should remeber Hatton was p4p top 5 was he not, before losing to the p4p #1. Usually folk losing go down a few places, he got totally thrown out, and losing to the best fighter in the world. So you can see it as a correction long term if you like. As for Cotto, I don't know how he's suddenly not even in the top 10. He remained in there after a loss, yet he gets a win and is out, wtf? Shane is too high for one win too, way too high.

Cotto exited the list when he lost to Margarito and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on. Hatton dominated the #1 rated guy at his weight and deserves to be on the list. Cotto was beaten By Marga Cheato. I Pick Cheato to beat Cotto but This is about ratings. Cheato's gone. I Give Cotto the benefit of the doubt. He still got Mosley, Quintana & a lot of Good former undefeated guys in his resume.

Cotto exited the list when he lost to Margarito and a win over Jennings isn't good enough to put him back on. Hatton dominated the #1 rated guy at his weight and deserves to be on the list.

Latest Ring Magazine P4P Ratings (as of Sunday, 3/1/2009) http://www.ringtv.com/ratings/ 1. Pac 2. JMM 3. Bhop 4. Izzy 5. Shane 6. Rafa 7. Calderon 8. Hatton 9. Caballero 10. Darchinyan I don't know why RAfa, Calderon, Izzy, Caballero & hatton were all there & Cotto's name is missing. Cotto's more accomplished than any of those guys. Here's mine! 1. Pac -No question! 2. JMM -Showing he's worthy! 3. Bhop -Age less warrior! 4. Shane- Another ageless warrior. 5. Pavlik- Still a Unified 160 title holder. 6. Cotto- He's Back, Just lost to a cheato. 7. Donaire- By just beating Dachinyan by Domination-KO. He deserves to be here. 8. Dachinyan- Now he deserves to be here but not above his daddy. 9. Izzy- He's good but can't rate him Higher coz he got beat up all the time, even if he's winning. 10. Hatton- For coming back & regaining back his respect. Sorry for those who didn't make the cut: Rafa- You have to win some fight 1st, might as well get a fight first. Calderon- If only I can see you fight on TV. Sorry I can't rate you. Caballero, Sorry ... There's just better fighter ahead of you. I'll give you #11. BTW I voted NO. I don't agree in the Ring's overall ratings. Too Much Golden boy influence.

i agree with 1-6 but not 7-10

cotto should be in there....

Every other list I see inclding boxingscene, yahoo, and espn, all of whom dont have a conflict of interest, hold Cotto on the list and Hatton off. I'm not going to argue though, everyone has their own opinion. The only fact of the matter is Hatton is affiliated with Golden Boy, Cotto is not. COSIGN..:boxing:

lmao at every one hating on hatton He's bringing on the hate himself by refusing to ****ing shut up about "the pound for pound title". 100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

Every other list I see inclding boxingscene, yahoo, and espn, all of whom dont have a conflict of interest, hold Cotto on the list and Hatton off. I'm not going to argue though, everyone has their own opinion. The only fact of the matter is Hatton is affiliated with Golden Boy, Cotto is not.

lmao at every one hating on hatton