How would you define All-Time P4P List?

Both. But leaning more towards accomplishment And yes All-Time P4P and All-Time Great lists would be the same

In order of importance 1. Resume 2. Accomplishments 3. Skills 4. Longevity 5. Intangables - impact on the sport, charisma outside the ring, highlight reel.

lbs 4 lbs is a short term thing ATG is for all eternity

Based on his resume. WHo he fought?, when he fought him?, under what circumstances?, and what was the result!!!!!!!! so all-time p4p is the same as ATG?

it doesnt matter because it's all subjective