Can someone explain how Floyd dominated ALL the divisions he fought in?

every fighter has fighters they didn't fight but floyd really hurt his resume a lot with all the tuneups he took. if you look at other fighters for example there were fights that should have been made that didn't but it's not as bad. kostya for example doesn't have as good a resume as floyd but you can't say there was many fights that he didn't make. phillips rematch is about it. even pacquiao , someone who has been in as many divisions as floyd one can't really say he missed out on a lot of opportunities to enhance his career except maybe at 122 where he could've gotten a fight with say a bones adams or paulie ayala. problem with floyd's resume is he has great wins but he could've done so much more. instead of gatti , beating kostya would have been better for the resume. instead of zab , beating marg or cotto would have been better. instead of chavez , beating casamayor would have been better. id say pacquiao took a glorified name tour combined with tune up tour at 130........not as bad as say floyds 140 tour......but comparable to floyds 147 campaign...... pacquiao at 130-morales loss(good fight)-tune up-morales rematch(as justified as cotto-margo 2)-tune up-morales 3(really?...)-tune up-barrera 2(really?.....)-jmm 2(good fight).......thats 2 good fights in a 7 fight span..............and hilariously, the 6 fight run before jmm had him earning "respect" solely based on names..... floyd at 147 fought #2(judah-though he shoulda been #5ish), the champ and a 140 champ(who had had a close win against a top welter)(and i hate hatton, think collazo beat berto, and i ithink hatton beat collazo).... imo thats at least comparable seeing as floyd didnt fight 7 fights at this weight.... this got me thinking... you can compare pacquiao's and floyd's career further.... 126 campaign for pacquiao pretty much only 2 fights worth mentioning.......but a hell of a two fights to have.....a great win against a top 3 p4pguy-a controversial draw against a guy hoovering the top 10 p4p.... mayweather's 130 campaign-very dominant wins over 4 of the top 6 guys in the weightclass......one a top 5 p4p and a guy hoovering the top 10....plus a solid prospect career...... pacquiao's lightweight run was one title and done...........much like mayweather's 140 run.......though at least pac didnt waste time in worthless tune ups...... mayweathers 135 campaign 2 wins against the top guy of the division(one good one controversial) also very comparable to pac's 126...but since thats taken, ill compare it with pacs one win over the top guy of the 122 division...and some solid career building fights..... floyd has his one win over an old title holder oscar... manny has his one win over an old drained-fixed(whichever one you'll chose) non title holder oscar......id say on paper, a very even win considering the circumstances for each man..... and manny has of course his 2 early loss prospect career with a one respectable win(even more so because of the lineal reign) but not much else at flyweight.......... ii find em very even in terms of resume honestly.........the good thing for manny is officially he can still build upon his already good legacy.......... but this has got me thinking that floyd would be as respected as manny if his public image was as likeable as manny's(even though manny's good image is somewhat fake....)...............................so yeah basically, everyone who thinks their resumes are not even comparable and shit on floyd and praise manny are full of shit..... and im not even a floydboy.....

The awnser is he didn’t in all the participating divisions. And certainly not at 147.

i asked the same thing earlier. larryx had a cow. i wasn't even trolling , some guy on a p4p thread said floyd "owned" and "dominated" every division he was in. i was arguing with him and the threadstarter got upset we were hijacking his thread so i just made a new thread to discuss it. then everyone started getting prissy. i think floyd beat the best guy (or next best guy in this case) at 130 and 135. he never dominated either division though he was clearly the best fighter in his division. his resume at 140 above is even more lacking than at 130 and 135. i know someone is gonna say they avoided floyd or whatever but even so we're talking resume here. fact is there was never a division where floyd fought 2-3 of the top guys in his division. think about it he beat genaro in '98 who was top ranked then he the only other top guys i can think off at the top of my head is diego and maybe manfredy. i don't remember how highly angel was ranked though. Hernandez Corrales, Manfredy and Jesus Chavez were all top fighters at 130. Castillo was the top guy at 135. Corrales was a monster at 130 and many picked him to beat Mayweather.Who else was he supposed to fight?

yea, that foo actually thinks apollo would beat clubber lang...what a turd prime apollo beats clubber lang and the russian. Rocky would have lost the 2nd fight if he didn't switch stances.

what consensus? this is your one BILLION dollars post about about floyd. get a grip. or did the margie loss really break your brain that bad easy there flawless/brandish/horus. do i need to bring up you're threads?

Manfredy was highly thought of at the time. He did miss Casamoyer and Freitas though. I was an Angel Manfredy fan. True Story. :D

The only divsion Floyd dominated was 130. Wins over Genaro Hernandez(which lost and quit against Oscar 3 yrs prior to Floyd)Corrales,Chavez , Carlos Hernandez and Manfredy established his claim as the dominant fighter in that division.

it was bad man...wallace was rollin around like DLH from the hopkins punch...except his pain was real good. heard he has broken ribs and lost like 40% of his breathing capability. teaches mofo's to stay out of the paint. :) remember when drew fouled lebron like 2-3 times going into the hole. the king didn't go in much after that......not when no. 17 is in the paint anyway.

ur just pissed cuz clubber is another version of tyson, who couldnt hold on to longevity

drew's probably gonna get suspended...they jus reported that gerald wallace has a collapsed lung did andrew knock him down? good. andrew has been using his fouls lately. no more ticky tack. he makes you earn those 2 free throws.

yea, that foo actually thinks apollo would beat clubber lang...what a turd Apollo would crush Lang!

clubber had no stamina, and he didnt like getting hit... apollo would ali his ass

that's laughable... :rofl: calzaghe would have schooled toney if james hadn't ducked him.

-never lost in 46 bouts -champion in 2 weight classes -15 yers in the sport, 11 years as a champion. notable wins , hopkins , jones , eubank , reid , mitchell , brewer , lacy , kessler. this is the stuff real legends are made of. calzaghe > mayweather that's laughable... :rofl:

-never lost in 46 bouts -champion in 2 weight classes -15 yers in the sport, 11 years as a champion. notable wins , hopkins , jones , eubank , reid , mitchell , brewer , lacy , kessler. this is the stuff real legends are made of. calzaghe > mayweather :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

I love how people question Floyd's resume... Look at it, it speaks for itself. -Never lost in 39 bouts -Champion in 5 weight classes -11 years in the sport, 9 years as a champion. Notable wins, JLC (2x), Hatton, DLH, Corrales, Hernadez, Chavez, Judah, Baldomir, Gatti, NDou... Imean this is the stuff legends are made of. -never lost in 46 bouts -champion in 2 weight classes -15 years in the sport, 11 years as a champion. notable wins , hopkins , jones , eubank , reid , mitchell , brewer , lacy , kessler. this is the stuff real legends are made of. calzaghe > mayweather

who's alt are you.... Im new to this board. I got tired of Maxboxing because of all the Margarito love... lol

boris diaw is a fagg0t you know i missed last night's game? i thought it was gonna be an easy W so i just went out. good thing. i would have been pissed off last night. i heard kobe fouled out.

I love how people question Floyd's resume... Look at it, it speaks for itself. -Never lost in 39 bouts -Champion in 5 weight classes -11 years in the sport, 9 years as a champion. Notable wins, JLC (2x), Hatton, DLH, Corrales, Hernadez, Chavez, Judah, Baldomir, Gatti, NDou... Imean this is the stuff legends are made of.

"EVander KO... EASY" :) not if they had fought in 2003...... (roy should never have gone back to 175...... :nonono: fuck milk dud.) is this boxingscene's fukk larryx day????????????? yes. didn't you get the memo?