Shane-In : Marga-Cheato-Out P4P Rankings

who the hell would ever have Margarito in their top 10????

What in the name of Jesus Christ have Dawson and Williams done????? Just my opinion, Paul Williams is on top of his game right now he beat Margarito, he destroyed and avenged his only loss like a man, has gone up in weight and brutally demolished his opponents, only person to ever KO Verno Phillips, and has been trying for a Pavlik fight all the way up at 160. Chad Dawson is definitely questionable especially since he lost to Glen Johnson or a draw at best in my eyes but hey he got the W on paper and with that he beat Johnson, Tarver, Tomasz Adamek and is trying to lure a fight with Calzaghe. And if we are gonna question each others list in my opinion Hatton has looked like shit since his first welterweight fight, I thought he loss to Collazo, didn't really look great against Lazcano or Urango either, not to mention he clearly beat Malginaggi but damn it was ugly IMO and think everyone is hyping that win up b/c Floyd Sr. was in his corner shit wasn't that impressive, it kinda made me sick to watch!!!!

Here is my top ten: 1)Manny Pacquiao 2)Joe Calzaghe 3)Isreal Vazquez 4)Juan Manuel Marquez 5)Miguel Cotto 6)Rafeal Marquez 7)Ivan Calderon 8)Bernard Hopkins 9)Paul Williams 10)Chad Dawson Honorable mentions: Shane Mosley, Vic Darchinyan, Kelly Pavlik, Arthur Abraham, Tony Margarito, Mikkel Kessler, any of them could be #10 IMO

Margarito was never a p4p fighter .. his boxing skills are average at best

Marg was never a p4p quality fighter anyways. Gotta rank Mosley over Cotto as they fought to a close decision that should have been a draw and Mosley just stopped the man who bloodied Cotto and knocked him out.

This is My new top ten list 1.Pacquaio 2.Calzaghe 3.Juan Manuel Marquez 4.B-Hop 5.Calderon 6.Vazquez 7.Cotto 8.Darchinyan 9.Mosley 10.Hatton I can't argue with your list. Looks good.

This is My new top ten list 1.Pacquaio 2.Calzaghe 3.Juan Manuel Marquez 4.B-Hop 5.Calderon 6.Vazquez 7.Cotto 8.Darchinyan 9.Mosley 10.Hatton Good list, but i would have to swap spots for Cotto and Mosley.

Oh what and Shane "Roid Abuser" Mosley isn't a cheater?

1. Pacquaio 2. Calzaghe 3. Marquez 4. Hopkins 5. Vasquez 6. Hatton 7. Cotto 8. Calderon 9. Mosely 10. Pavlik

This is My new top ten list 1.Pacquaio 2.Calzaghe 3.Juan Manuel Marquez 4.B-Hop 5.Calderon 6.Vazquez 7.Cotto 8.Darchinyan 9.Mosley 10.Hatton Good list. Spot-on IMO.