Calzaghe V David Haye, who wins?

Calzaghe is more than able to drop Enzo Macc in sparring, he just doesn't punch with that kind of power very often to protect his fragile hands. Could he earn haye's respect, yes. Could he command enough respect to limit Haye's workrate and squeeze out the decision, no. same thing that paulie malignaggi says.

kind of stupid thread. i know its only one weight class, but we are talking joe calzaghe here... the guy doesnt even lift weights, hes not going to put on 25 pounds of muscle anytime soon. IF the fight happened, obviously haye would most likely win, but calzaghe is and will always be superior to haye. cant wait to see haye stop running his mouth once he eats his first right hand from wladimir which sends him not only to the canvas and into a very deep trance like sleep, but into retirement.

haye would beat calzaghe. calzaghe doesn't have the power to hurt haye.... i think. Calzaghe is more than able to drop Enzo Macc in sparring, he just doesn't punch with that kind of power very often to protect his fragile hands. Could he earn haye's respect, yes. Could he command enough respect to limit Haye's workrate and squeeze out the decision, no.

Haye fails to make weight...

Calzaghe V David Haye, at cruiser - who wins? haye would beat calzaghe. calzaghe doesn't have the power to hurt haye.... i think.

Haye...he's too big.

Haye. Joe wouldn't be able to handle that kind of power and yes, he would catch him at least once which should be all it takes.

If Haye catches him, it's no contest. But could he? Over 12 rounds, you'd have to say yes, but if he didn't, who knows?

LOL. Haye early KO.

Haye because of the size difference