Question for the Calzaghe haters...

i don't hate calzaghe at all, but i do rank bhop a shade ahead of him. i think the pavlik win was bigger than any win on joe's resume. plus winky and tarver. joe's resume just doesn't do it for me. he had a string of relatively weak title defenses, his hands are weak and his punches are just sheer volume. i give him props for beating bhop, lacy and kessler though. especially the lacy win, he tore him up. but really you can make a case for any of the top p4p guys, which in my opinion are pacquiao bhop calzaghe

i am a big calzaghe hater! i have him at #1 pound for pound. i don't see how people rate manny over him to be honest.i think bernard should be #2.or maybe if they could share the #1 spot. Hahaha I'm one of those that put Manny ahead of Joe. One: Manny has fought in the States, away from his home, a lot longer. Points. Two: Manny has moved up several weight divisions and Won titles. Points. Three: Manny has kicked the crap out of some very good Mexican fighters. HOF fighters. Points. Four: Manny is a Pimp outside of the ring. POINTS. Five: Nike sponsers Manny. Points. Six: Manny is God in his home country. Points. Seven: Manny is Chinese...and I love Kung Fu movies ;) Eight: Manny is somehow able to run in L.A. Nine: Manny took his team to the NL Championship this year. Ten: Manny is exciting to watch.

Just wondering... Where do you put Calzaghe on the P4P list, where do you put Bhop? I have Calzaghe at #2. Not a hater. I think he is a very good fighter and has a decent resume. He will go to the HOF.

lmao. I guess he thinks the OP was your alt? Nice avi...the angry black guy :D More like the DEAD black guy

i am a big calzaghe hater! i have him at #1 pound for pound. i don't see how people rate manny over him to be honest.i think bernard should be #2.or maybe if they could share the #1 spot.

As my good mate R!ZO once said; ''At the end of the day, **** Calzaghe!''

hopkins should be much higher than windmill limbs. hopkins beat tarver, winky, pavlik and should have a win over calzaghe. windmill limbs has a SD against hopkins and he beat kessler who has faded into bolivian. how can calzaghe possibly be higher? he can't. Let me explain how this works. If the guy at number 3 beats the guy at number 4, he stays ahead of him in the rankings, regardless of who number 4 beat in the past or future. If he couldn't beat number 3, he doesn't deserve to skip him. It is very simple.

hopkins should be much higher than windmill limbs. hopkins beat tarver, winky, pavlik and should have a win over calzaghe. windmill limbs has a SD against hopkins and he beat kessler who has faded into bolivian. how can calzaghe possibly be higher? he can't. Calzaghe beat Bernard. That could potentially be a reason.

hopkins should be much higher than windmill limbs. hopkins beat tarver, winky, pavlik and should have a win over calzaghe. windmill limbs has a SD against hopkins and he beat kessler who has faded into bolivian. how can calzaghe possibly be higher? he can't.

???????????????????????? lmao. I guess he thinks the OP was your alt? Nice avi...the angry black guy :D

How is goin Tuggers? ????????????????????????

Ring Magazine POUND-FOR-POUND Rankings 1 MANNY PACQUIAO 2 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ 3 JOE CALZAGHE 4 BERNARD HOPKINS 5 ISRAEL VAZQUEZ 6 ANTONIO MARGARITO 7 CRISTIAN MIJARES 8 RAFAEL MARQUEZ 9 MIGUEL COTTO 10 IVAN CALDERON

*bump* hello??? It's funny how all my threads get ducked by all the Calz haters.

todays p4p list please

all time or just todays p4p list? ________ My webcams hookup

B-Hop #1. Calzaghe #98. Ricky Hatton #30,108 .... jk. I guess this doesn't really apply to me, since I am not a 'hater' although I do think joe lost to Hopkins last time out, and am rooting for Roy this time out. I have it calzaghe #2, BHOP #4 based on what the records say (JC SD12 BHOP). I was exaggerating perhaps with Ricky, but he's still nowhere near the top 10....