Is Margarito the most overrated boxer in history?

With 5 career losses Margarito has managed to hold alphabet titles in 1 division his entire career. He has no real amateur accomplishments. He has already been defeated by 1 of the other titleholders in the division. He is already 30 years old. But some would have us believe that he has had a greater career than future Hall of Famers like Oscar, Floyd, or even Joe Calzaghe & Roy Jones. Is he the most overrated boxer in history. Guys like David Reid, Edison Miranda, Tommy Morrison were overrated but I think Margarito just might take 1st place. If it wasn't for that chin of his, we wouldn't be talking about him right now :bigeyes:

No fan it doesn't. Cotto leans forward so he has always been susceptible to the uppercut. The angles that were created in the fight came from cotto's movement effective and ineffective. Both of these fighters are overrated, dangerous for any ww but definitely overrated. Cotto a frontrunner would be effective for mentally weak and equally stamina deprived opponents., Margie a brawler effective against stamina deprived and mentally weak opponents. Elite fighters don't exhibit those attributes. But Both of those weaknesses would be exploited by an elite boxer so I can understand your confusion. So neither is or should have ever been considered elite regardless of what any fanboy would try to convince you to believe. You say this as if Cotto is the only opponent to have tasted a Tony uppercut. I'm not saying he is the most skilled, but to say he doesn't have any skill or is mediocre at best is hating. You don't become a top welterweight for the last 3 or 4 years with no skills.

Margarito is gaining quite a decent resume these days but i still cant help but think he is Overrated i believe he will lose again very soon probably to Clottey Clottey Cotto Cintron

So says the guy who said Cotto has a fragile chin. Keep it up dude. But I've already told you before... the difference between the 2 of us. Is that I have been brought up to admire dignified champs... while you have been brought up to admire cowards. So the difference in opinion will stick. keep it up tool. Corley, Torres, Judah and now Margarito showed that your mom's cunt can take more beating than Cotto's chin. When do her stiches come out anyway? Says the guy who said Pac is nearing Ali status. LOL. Make that Robinson. This guy is absolutely fucking retarded.

Showing particular interest in blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. Still can't show me where I hated. Man just admit you are a fan. Go research some of my writings again. If me calling you out for stalking Margarito makes me a fan, I can only imagine what it makes you in context to Margarito. His boxer briefs?

How did Tony land so many uppercuts? It would take a great amount of skill to land that many damaging uppercuts wouldn't it? No fan it doesn't. Cotto leans forward so he has always been susceptible to the uppercut. The angles that were created in the fight came from cotto's movement effective and ineffective. Both of these fighters are overrated, dangerous for any ww but definitely overrated. Cotto a frontrunner would be effective for mentally weak and equally stamina deprived opponents., Margie a brawler effective against stamina deprived and mentally weak opponents. Elite fighters don't exhibit those attributes. But Both of those weaknesses would be exploited by an elite boxer so I can understand your confusion. So neither is or should have ever been considered elite regardless of what any fanboy would try to convince you to believe.

And he is... beating legends like Morales, Barrera and top elites like Lehdwaba and Marquez.. Being the only guy from Fly to win titles at 135 and is planning on fighting Hatton. Sorry but in my country we have stern standards of boxing excellence. I know your country has low standards so there's no reason to compare. You can admire cowards like gayweather. I can admire dignified champs like Pacquiao. So let's take it as it is. You said it after he beat Diaz, LOL. As if he's a great boxer. LOL.

So says the guy who sucks on gayweather's dick. Lols. You gayweather fans are funny. Only now in my life have I seen guys admiring cowards. Only in America. Not in my country. You sound like someone who is mentally disturbed. Seriously, shut the fuck up already.

No one thinks Margarito is great besides Mexicans. What do you expect from a population of people without any concept of education? Dats bullshit! You need to be ashamed of that statement! Whats your education level? I attend school with some very intelligent mexicans and mexican americans! You gotta be bigger than that! I totally agree with your frustration from some of the nationalistic fanboys but you can intelligently express it without idiotic statements as such! Calzaghe comes to mind for me but margie wont get there after a few defenses against those that can buzz him!!

So says the guy who said Cotto has a fragile chin. Keep it up dude. But I've already told you before... the difference between the 2 of us. Is that I have been brought up to admire dignified champs... while you have been brought up to admire cowards. So the difference in opinion will stick. keep it up tool. Says the guy who said Pac is nearing Ali status. LOL.

JoartCC post checklist: Gayweather? Check. Coward? Check. Avoiding anything to do with the topic at hand? Check. Good job you small-dicked cunt, you've done it again! :rofl::rofl::rofl:My homie Dwiens telling him like it is!:rofl:

JoartCC post checklist: Gayweather? Check. Coward? Check. Avoiding anything to do with the topic at hand? Check. Good job you small-dicked cunt, you've done it again! lol.....:fest30:

Gayweather is the most overrated fighter in boxing history. If gayweather was my countrymen, we wouldn't hesitate to spit him out with the lack of class and dignity that he conducts himself. Only in America are cowards hailed as greats. Only in America are cowards voted as presidents. No wonder a few Americans love gayweather. JoartCC post checklist: Gayweather? Check. Coward? Check. Avoiding anything to do with the topic at hand? Check. Good job you small-dicked cunt, you've done it again!

DAMN JR YOU FUNNY AS HELL! LOOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:rofl::rofl::rofl: haterfree is one of the funniest posters in boxing scene history, hes also the biggest hater too

I like that "my writings". It's like your Charles Dickens or Shakespeare or some shit. LOL. DAMN JR YOU FUNNY AS HELL! LOOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:rofl::rofl::rofl:

How bout we just post the threads you've created? "Floyd will be in the Hall of Fame. Margarito might never be in the Hall of Fame." http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=204048 "Margarito is not thw REAL WW champ." http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=201538 "Why are the Margarito fans so scared of Paul Williams?" http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=199961 "Who is better Oscar or Margarito?" http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=159843 "Why does margarito depend on Floyd for his career so much?" http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=154926 "Is Margarito the most overrated boxer in history?" http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=204247 "Haterfree" appears to have some kind of obsession with Antonio Margarito. Out of his 17 threads made, 6 of them are about Margarito and the rest comprise of threads explaining how elite Black boxers are compared to other races. What I find ironic is that here are 2 threads where is attempting to criticize boxing fans for discussing Floyd so much, yet this guy who is "free of hate" for some reason can't bring himself to talk about another fighter other than Antonio Margarito. "Why are people so concerned with Floyds career?" http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=163587 "Why cant people keep Mayweathers name out of their mouth?" http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=179047 :rofl::owned2::owned:

Showing particular interest in blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. Still can't show me where I hated. Man just admit you are a fan. Go research some of my writings again. Margaritos got ways to go and many fights to win before hes worthy of hall of fame status, but haterfree is a hater, by the way ,nobody wants to research your writings because you are so full of crap,

I think the Cotto fight showed Margarito's good points best. He's just a very determined, strong guy that comes to fight in great shape and gives 110% until the other guy falls down or the last bell rings. I don't think he's an ATG but a great fighter nonetheless and exciting to watch when he has an opponent that doesn't run like Williams did.

Showing particular interests in ONE fighter without having anything POSITIVE to say about that fighter multiple times is a clear cut sign of hatred/content/dislike for that fighter. Either you are incredibly retarded or you know you've been exposed for a witless imbecile. Either one you chose would suffice. Showing particular interest in blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. Still can't show me where I hated. Man just admit you are a fan. Go research some of my writings again.

Mothafucka I am the OP of this thread. Boofdatruth has 1 of the best avatars in boxingscene history. I asked a question in this post. And a lot of people gave great opinions, with solid facts. All you did is ride my dick & study my writings. Still yet to show me where I hated. Showing particular interests in ONE fighter without having anything POSITIVE to say about that fighter multiple times is a clear cut sign of hatred/content/dislike for that fighter. Either you are incredibly retarded or you know you've been exposed for a witless imbecile. Either one you chose would suffice.