How can Margarito now be in the P4P list??

Yes, but theres one guy at the exact same weight, that holds a win over him recently. How can he be P4P when someone at his same WEIGHT beat him. This is why the P4P list doesn't really make sense sometimes. Yeah the P4P label is really an American thing which is mostly BS but I"m sure they (whoever they are) factored in the loss. IF williams had blow Margarito away the way Margarito blew away Cotto, I doubt he would have cracked the list but it was a competitive fight that went the distance.

The same people that say Cotto is overrated are putting Margarito on their lists. Makes no sense

Getting back to Williams. Yes he did beat Margarito, but only barely. I still get where you're coming from with your argument though. P.S. I think the loss to Quintana has alot to do with shit too. Credit to him for KOing the fucker in the rematch, though.

The thread maker makes a very good point, but it's often how you beat an opponent that gets you recognition in the p4p lists. For example, guys like Floyd and Roy used to make fights so one-sided when they were the P4P #1s. Then you have Kostya Tszyu, who I think was ranked #3 at the peak of his career. He didn't fight many good fighters (in their primes), but it was how he beat the fighters he did beat at his weight. He KO'd most of his opponents, unified his division, and dominated it for years. Some believe other P4P fighters avoided him (Shane Mosley).

He just KO'd one of the top 5 P4Pers.. if emmanuel augustus fights mayweather and beats him (which it would never happen) guess what would happen, where would you rank him after beating the very best in the world He took down two champs in his division including one of the top ranked fighters Yes, but theres one guy at the exact same weight, that holds a win over him recently. How can he be P4P when someone at his same WEIGHT beat him. This is why the P4P list doesn't really make sense sometimes.

He took down two champs in his division including one of the top ranked fighters

if emmanuel augustus fights mayweather and beats him (which it would never happen) guess what would happen, where would you rank him after beating the very best in the world

He just KO'd one of the top 5 P4Pers..