So where does Margarito fall in the to 10 p4p listings?...ahead of cotto?

not on the list thats crazy, to me he falls in at #3, with cotto at # 4 and jmm at #5, and jmm beats casamayor then hell be #4...p4p does not mean you can fight at any division it means it doesnt matter how small or big you are, its about who is the overall better boxer. One more fight like Saturday & he'll be #1 or #2 P4P. He just joined my list of favorite fighters. Cotto is still in top 10! Both top notchers! 1. Pavlik 2. Magarito 3. Calzaghe 4. Valero

anywhere from 8-10, ill have to double check a list. Putting him in the top 3 is ludicrious.

He's not on the list and never will be. P4P means you should be able to take your skills to a higher weight & prosper. Something Margarito obviously cant do. Hatton doesnt cut it and niether does Cotto, seeing as tho they can't even go up one weight class with out getting KO'd. not on the list thats crazy, to me he falls in at #3, with cotto at # 4 and jmm at #5, and jmm beats casamayor then hell be #4...p4p does not mean you can fight at any division it means it doesnt matter how small or big you are, its about who is the overall better boxer.

Ahead of Cotto but Cotto really has to drop down a long way on that list now, like close to out of the top 10. Margarito probably just makes the top 10. You don't just have one really good win then all of a sudden be the number 2 p4p. He has to be behind the likes of Pac, Calzaghe, Mijares, Vasquez, probably JMM, and Pavlik IMO.

where does he land now after beating cotto?...behind calzaghe or ahead af him at #2, he beat cotto but does he deserve to be ahead of him?..is he even ahead of jmm ? lol not in front of cal i think williams marg and cotto are all in the top 10 in that order

He needs to avenge his loss to Paul Williams before you start putting him anywhere near that high

Either number 2 or number 3.