Top 50 GOAT | BoxingScene Community

Top 50 GOAT

What do you think of the list? What would you change? Who was left off? Who doesn't belong? 1. Sugar Ray Robinson 2. Muhammad Ali 3. Henry Armstrong 4. Joe Louis 5. Willie Pep 6. Roberto Duran 7. Benny Leonard 8. Jack Johnson 9. Jack Dempsey 10. Sam Langford 11. Joe Gans 12. Sugar Ray Leonard 13. Harry Greb 14. Rocky Marciano 15. Jimmy Wilde 16. Gene Tunney 17. Mickey Walker 19. Stanley Ketchel 20. George Foreman 21. Tony Canzoneri 22. Barney Ross 23. Jimmy McLarnin 24. Julio Cesar Chavez 25. Marcel Cerdan 26. Joe Frazier 27. Ezzard Charles 18. Archie Moore 28. Jake LaMotta 29. Sandy Saddler 30. Terry McGovern 31. Billy Conn 32. Jose Napoles 33. Ruben Olivares 34. Emile Griffith 35. Marvin Hagler 36. Eder Jofre 37. Thomas Hearns 38. Larry Holmes 39. Oscar De La Hoya 40. Evander Holyfield 41. Ted "Kid" Lewis 42. Alexis Arguello 43. Marco Antonio Barrera 44. Pernell Whitaker 45. Carlos Monzon 46. Roy Jones Jr. 47. Bernard Hopkins 48. Floyd Mayweather Jr. 49. Erik Morales 50. Joe Calzaghe

Comments (20)

FUC_U_PAYME

I have Henry at 3. I just don't see anybody but SRR above Ali. i got Herny at # 2 but can see why some would put Ali at 2

17y ago

THE_REED

I have Henry at 3. I just don't see anybody but SRR above Ali. i think holding 3 weight class titles all at the same time, and losing a controversial fourth weightclass is PRETTY hard to beat

17y ago

blackink

henry armstrong........ I have Henry at 3. I just don't see anybody but SRR above Ali.

17y ago

THE_REED

Apart from SRR, who else would you put above Ali? henry armstrong........

17y ago

blackink

Ali Top 3 at least Apart from SRR, who else would you put above Ali?

17y ago

FUC_U_PAYME

we shall get a drink if u go then! cool i let you know

17y ago

ICEMAN_JOHN_SCULLY

Any way you slice it... Robinson, Ali, Pep and Louis are all in the top 10 somewhere.

17y ago

MWMerlino

lol @ Reed inviting folks to his empty house... Too bad this thread got sidetracked, I'm writing down names on the ESPN list and going to do homework and find out why these guys deserve to be up there. I have a feeling they were just great fighters from an era that old boxing historians are sentimental about. Having Joe at 50 really discredited the list...

17y ago

THE_REED

we shall get a drink if u go then!

17y ago

FUC_U_PAYME

come on overrrrr!!!!! only one problem... ill be at madison square garden! although.. like i did with roy and tito... the fight will still be playing and recorded at my house, and my friends who arent going will be at my house watching, while im there. i might be at that fight not sure yet

17y ago

THE_REED

yo reed you should let us come over for the Roy vs Joe fight i'll bring the beer come on overrrrr!!!!! only one problem... ill be at madison square garden! although.. like i did with roy and tito... the fight will still be playing and recorded at my house, and my friends who arent going will be at my house watching, while im there.

17y ago

WESS

yo reed you should let us come over for the Roy vs Joe fight i'll bring the beer ill bring the bitches!!!!!!

17y ago

FUC_U_PAYME

its a show car... which i have about... ohhhhh 35 trophies from car shows... and why would u assume i dont have a good job? i dont know about whiz kid... but OBVIOUSLY i know my shit. and when it came time to buck up, who FROZE UP?! yo reed you should let us come over for the Roy vs Joe fight i'll bring the beer

17y ago

FUC_U_PAYME

Thats fair.. I bet a lot of poeple wouldnt even rank him that high... thats true

17y ago

WESS

I have him in the late 30's He was one the best could have been a ATG Thats fair.. I bet a lot of poeple wouldnt even rank him that high...

17y ago

THE_REED

well it doesnt matter... obviously you know i work here... and so does diego, hence he completely stopped posting after truth hit him directly in the face

17y ago

FUC_U_PAYME

cool, what about you? I have him in the late 30's He was one of the best could have been a top 15 ATG HW

17y ago

Live_Dog

whats the big deal about that mines frankie... nice to meet you you could of said it was TED from acme designs :rofl: Nice to meet you Frankie, I'm.....*click*

17y ago

THE_REED

if I wanted you to know my name, then yes it would...... whats the big deal about that mines frankie... nice to meet you you could of said it was TED from acme designs :rofl:

17y ago

Live_Dog

your name is always a good start... lol. if I wanted you to know my name, then yes it would......

17y ago