Would Margarito be great if he fought 100 years ago?

plain and basic common sense. Maybe you should take philosophy or read a book before you begin to talk about "plain and basic common sense" because though many people seem to agree and understand what it is without taking a course on matter of fact and matter of factual value, you seem to be lost as to what it's meaning is.

Margarito is pretty good. I don't see how he's great. Marg has some of the most enthusiastic and delusional fans going. Half the time their praise sounds borderline tongue in cheek.

he would be better than mayweather because he could actually knock people out Is Edwin Valero better than Mayweather?

I can't really factor how he would do in a 25 round fight. Boxing was just so much different then. One thing I do know is that Margarito would be a legitimate contender during any period that I have watched boxing over many years. Watching too many posts from Viva Mexico. Marg is a fringe contender AT BEST.

Tony can't even make it past Daniel Santos..much less fight the guys from the past. what makes guys better from the past?? considering how great of athletes we have today, Margarito would probably be considered the best ever had he fought 100 yrs ago. Im not even a die hard Margarito fan, but with his size how could you not expect him to walk through fighters from 100 yrs ago. Boxing like technolgy has advanced.

His ass isn't great now so the answer is clear. Margarito can be TKOed. Once his head explodes from swelling they'll have to stop it.

I can't really factor how he would do in a 25 round fight. Boxing was just so much different then. One thing I do know is that Margarito would be a legitimate contender during any period that I have watched boxing over many years.

He isn't great in this era, so no he wouldn't. I like Tony, but some really overrate him..

He could possibly be ok boxing technique was very crude back then so he may have looked like a man among boys. The same goes for any boxer moving back in time though IMO.

nope....not at all