boxrec p4p rankings

Cut the crap. 2 of the top 4 might be in my 7 to 10 range. QUOTE=hungryherbert;3632876]these are possibly the worst rankings i have ever seen what are your thoughts on these? Joe Calzaghe light heavyweight 2 Kelly Pavlik middleweight 3 Bernard Hopkins light heavyweight 4 Manny Pacquiao super featherweight 5 Juan Manuel Marquez super featherweight 6 Ronald Wright middleweight 7 Israel Vazquez super bantamweight 8 Wladimir Klitschko heavyweight 9 Ricky Hatton light welterweight 10 Cristian Mijares super flyweight 11 David Haye cruiserweight 12 Chris John featherweight 13 Rafael Marquez super bantamweight 14 Arthur Abraham middleweight 15 Miguel Angel Cotto welterweight 16 Nonito Donaire flyweight 17 Nate Campbell lightweight 18 Ulises Solis light flyweight 19 Samuel Peter heavyweight 20 Joan Guzman super featherweight 21 Juan Diaz lightweight 22 Ruslan Chagaev heavyweight 23 Raul Garcia minimumweight 24 Jermain Taylor middleweight 25 Hozumi Hasegawa bantamweight

Is there anyother site that's just like boxrec? with reliable info??? not for checking records and stuff like that, they are excellent site besides their p4p rankings

Is there anyother site that's just like boxrec? with reliable info???

Boxrec's rankings are based on a computer matrix. It takes into account wins, losses, stoppages and the records of each fighters' opponents. It's flawed because there are things to bear in mind that are not reflected in simple numbers (Such as fighter A gets the shit knocked out of him for ten rounds but lands a lucky punch and wins over fighter B or maybe Fighter C gets a decision that he really didn't deserve over fighter D). Having said that all p4p rankings are flawed, for example a guy who dislikes non-American fighter is unlikely to rank many non-American fighters highly while a guy who hates flashy defensive boxers and really likes full-steam-ahead knockout artists is going to have this bias reflected in his p4p lists. So there you have it. Well somebody needs to go Neo on that Computer Matrix's ass. Cause that list is hot basura...

Boxrec's rankings are based on a computer matrix. It takes into account wins, losses, stoppages and the records of each fighters' opponents. It's flawed because there are things to bear in mind that are not reflected in simple numbers (Such as fighter A gets the shit knocked out of him for ten rounds but lands a lucky punch and wins over fighter B or maybe Fighter C gets a decision that he really didn't deserve over fighter D). Having said that all p4p rankings are flawed, for example a guy who dislikes non-American fighter is unlikely to rank many non-American fighters highly while a guy who hates flashy defensive boxers and really likes full-steam-ahead knockout artists is going to have this bias reflected in his p4p lists. So there you have it. fair point squeel but these are completely and utterly crazy. they are getting a bad name for their p4p rankings, its a great site though for looking up fighters

Boxrec's rankings are based on a computer matrix. It takes into account wins, losses, stoppages and the records of each fighters' opponents. It's flawed because there are things to bear in mind that are not reflected in simple numbers (Such as fighter A gets the shit knocked out of him for ten rounds but lands a lucky punch and wins over fighter B or maybe Fighter C gets a decision that he really didn't deserve over fighter D). Having said that all p4p rankings are flawed, for example a guy who dislikes non-American fighter is unlikely to rank many non-American fighters highly while a guy who hates flashy defensive boxers and really likes full-steam-ahead knockout artists is going to have this bias reflected in his p4p lists. So there you have it.

My Top five is... (1)Manny Pacquiao super featherweight, (2) Kelly Pavlik middleweight, (3)Joe Calzaghe light heavyweight (Joe should dropped behind Pavlik for skipping him to fight R.R.J.), (4) Israel Vazquez super bantamweight and (5) Wladimir Klitschko heavyweight.

Hatton over Cotto?!? WTF?!?!

cotto at 15?:ugh::ugh:

winky at 6? he hasnt fought in over a year and still then it was a loss

these are possibly the worst rankings i have ever seen what are your thoughts on these? Joe Calzaghe light heavyweight 2 Kelly Pavlik middleweight 3 Bernard Hopkins light heavyweight 4 Manny Pacquiao super featherweight 5 Juan Manuel Marquez super featherweight 6 Ronald Wright middleweight 7 Israel Vazquez super bantamweight 8 Wladimir Klitschko heavyweight 9 Ricky Hatton light welterweight 10 Cristian Mijares super flyweight 11 David Haye cruiserweight 12 Chris John featherweight 13 Rafael Marquez super bantamweight 14 Arthur Abraham middleweight 15 Miguel Angel Cotto welterweight 16 Nonito Donaire flyweight 17 Nate Campbell lightweight 18 Ulises Solis light flyweight 19 Samuel Peter heavyweight 20 Joan Guzman super featherweight 21 Juan Diaz lightweight 22 Ruslan Chagaev heavyweight 23 Raul Garcia minimumweight 24 Jermain Taylor middleweight 25 Hozumi Hasegawa bantamweight Yeah they are horrible. How Bernard is that high is beyond me. Also, Joe C should not be ahead of Manny. Personally I would have it like Manny, Pavlik then maybe Joe. But Cotto probably goes up to 2 maybe if he beats Margarito.

They have always been retarded