After Margarito Beats Cotto where will he be on the P4P List?

I think he is now

Marg might not be in the pound for pound top 10 but how much did he drop Cotto back?

Lets re open this discussion

we all know that the first fight he couldnt continue cos he couldnt breathe....and with the two performances he had afterwards, i dont think that the loss hurt him, or at least it shouldnt. Really though... it was split 1-1 going into the third fight, and that fight was as razor thin as it could be. Anyway, just as Vazquez only couldn't continue because of breating difficulties, Marquez lost the second fight by TKO when he was throwing punches back. Neither were particularly decisive.

silly mexicans :boxing:

It was the same guy coming up from the division below, and he lost once to him as well. I think Vazquez is very, very good, but losing to Marquez hurt him. we all know that the first fight he couldnt continue cos he couldnt breathe....and with the two performances he had afterwards, i dont think that the loss hurt him, or at least it shouldnt.

when cotto wins he should enter the top 5....marquez should drop to sixth and vasquez go up to the 4th.

I dont think he will be in the P4P The hate will continue and so will Floyds fear.

Margarito should'nt be fighting at 147 ayway he should be fighting at 154lbs IMO

Vazquez just beat a fellow p4p fighter twice while Cotto, two damn good fighters who weren't even top 15 on the lists. It was the same guy coming up from the division below, and he lost once to him as well. I think Vazquez is very, very good, but losing to Marquez hurt him.

Hell, I think #4 would be warranted. Both #4 Marquez and #5 Hopkins are coming off a loss, and I would think beating Mosley and Margarito back to back is enough to vault Cotto over Vazquez. Vazquez just beat a fellow p4p fighter twice while Cotto, two damn good fighters who weren't even top 15 on the lists.

ok i was joking but in all seriousness i would put him at 8 and no lower. Cotto is there on the ring if i am correct. Another question would be if Cotto wins where does that put him? 5? Hell, I think #4 would be warranted. Both #4 Marquez and #5 Hopkins are coming off a loss, and I would think beating Mosley and Margarito back to back is enough to vault Cotto over Vazquez.

An unranked fighter beating #7 (who has never beat a ranked fighter himself) would bump him up to #4? You will have to explain that one to me. 8-10 is what I would think. You are probably correct Skills, mostly because the Williams fight will still be somewhat in the back of peoples' minds. ok i was joking but in all seriousness i would put him at 8 and no lower. Cotto is there on the ring if i am correct. Another question would be if Cotto wins where does that put him? 5?

Margarito really does look like a Mexican Road sweeper

I'd put him at 4. Mayweather Pacquiao Calzaghe Margarito What do you all think An unranked fighter beating #7 (who has never beat a ranked fighter himself) would bump him up to #4? You will have to explain that one to me. He would be at 10 if he were to beat Cotto..........which he won't. 8-10 is what I would think. You are probably correct Skills, mostly because the Williams fight will still be somewhat in the back of peoples' minds.

maybe i should have put If

He would be at 10 if he were to beat Cotto..........which he won't.

*Takes a Peak* *walks out*