Will Joe retire undefeated???

Woulda, coulda, shoulda.... You are talking nonsense, you cannot criticise a fighter for theoretical failures in imaginary fights in parallel universes. You can only look at what they do do. Calzaghe is now the Ring LHW and SMW Champion and undefeated as a pro and champ. Give it up and give him respect. You'll feel better afterwards. I am giving him full respect, i'm just stating a fact, he coulda woulda shoulda moved up to light heavy years ago but he didn't. All im saying is he's dominated a week division, albeit for ten years. He's a great fighter. I think he could be the best to come from britain ever but i'm just puttin it out there that he could still prove himself beyond all doubt with a couple of good fights.

lol, why who has joe fought, a second rate eubank who was never the same after michael watson. and dont say lacy, he's a phoney. he would have never stayed undefeated for that long at light heavy. Woulda, coulda, shoulda.... You are talking nonsense, you cannot criticise a fighter for theoretical failures in imaginary fights in parallel universes. You can only look at what they do do. Calzaghe is now the Ring LHW and SMW Champion and undefeated as a pro and champ. Give it up and give him respect. You'll feel better afterwards. ________ Chrysler Phoenix Engine Specifications

I think he should fight RJJ and then see where he should go from there

If he continues to fight in America, then no.

Glen Johnson would give Calzaghe a good fight and an exciting fight at that ..

it all depends on who he fights next and if he continues to fight.

Mate, do me a favour and fuck off. lol, why who has joe fought, a second rate eubank who was never the same after michael watson. and dont say lacy, he's a phoney. he would have never stayed undefeated for that long at light heavy.

I really want Calzaghe to make some noise at middleweight ... he would be insane at that weight.. good competition too.

Yes, I think Joe will retire undefeated. There really isn't anyone left out there to beat him now, but he'd better be quick. At 36 he is at the upper age limit for a truly elite boxer IMO and if he waits too long he will start to slide. RJJ is a shell of his former self and he is not much older than Joe. What Joe has going for him is that most of the fighters he could fight are even older than he is, like RJJ and Tarver, or simply not as good, like Dawson and Pavlik. All things being well, he should do it, yes. ________ **** XXX

I think joe is great although he hasn't really fought anyone up until yesterday. Just wondered what people think??????????? Mate, do me a favour and fuck off.

if he fights and defeats roy jones jr than he should retire. there would nothing else left for him to do. that is unless he chooses to fight the other light heavyweight champions.