Malignaggi vs Ngoudjo - WHO WON?

Oh how the tables have turned! So how come nobody talked shit about Paulie and "New Jersey" for this hometown decision?Why I ask, why?It's pretty much the same situation but Paulie is on the winning end.So what do you guys have to say about this?I mean the poll says it all.

I had it a draw. 117-111 is total shit. I already had a thread on this and hardly anyone responded! Damn the jokes.

"The irony of this lol. Ngoudjo got a win in a close fight that a lot thought Bailey won, and that fight was in Canada." that fight in Canada vs Randall Bailey was an IBF Eliminator and Herman's W set up last night's fight vs Malignaggi. but it is very ironic that vs Malignaggi, Herman loses a disputed decision. I dunno about you Antonio but I would rather see a Randall Bailey rematch .. then one with Paulie. im not going to call Herman over rated, but his last 3 fight have been very strange the close SD loss to Castillo. followed by the close SD W to Bailey followed by a close UD loss to Paulie.

i just cheked poll results.. did yall not watch the fight? ***SPOILER*** Malignaggi won. :bottle: :bottle: :bottle: :bottle:

I scored it 116-112 for ngoudjo after watching it for a second time, and i was looking for rounds to give to malignaggi.

Ngoudjo wonthat fight this guy Malignaggi is a joke ... is like an Hector Camacho wanna be this fight should be on espn not showtime, Paulie he landed the cleaner punches "cleaner JABS" the real cleaner punches were landed by Ngoudjo +++++ 3 american judges what a waist of air time The irony of this lol. Ngoudjo got a win in a close fight that a lot thought Bailey won, and that fight was in Canada. It was a close fight that either guy could have won. Malignaggi was very unimpressive, yet Ngoudjo didnt completely take advantage of that. He could have been busier, to the body especially. I feel bad for Ngoudjo though. You can argue he beat both Castillo and Malignaggi. It's the difference between 100k pay days and million dollar pay days.

mallinaggi by a round ...so was casillo really shot when he fought herman ? ..herman is a 140lb contender w/o a doubt

Ngoudjo wonthat fight this guy Malignaggi is a joke ... is like an Hector Camacho wanna be this fight should be on espn not showtime, Paulie he landed the cleaner punches "cleaner JABS" the real cleaner punches were landed by Ngoudjo +++++ 3 american judges what a waist of air time

If you ask me Ngoudjo didnt do enough to take it and it was definitely up for the taking. Malignaggi didnt show up last night. He only won on my card because Ngoudjo didnt throw enough punches. So no I dont feel sorry for Ngoudjo. I think both guys could have done more to win it, and Paulie got lucky with the win. If he would have lost I wouldnt have been shocked. I cant believe he even gave the 12th away even when Buddy was pleading with him. Both guys were tired in the 12th too after a not to grueling fight. At least Ngoudjo went out in the 12th and tried to win it.

Malignaggi by 115-113. Ngoudjo certainly was the more threatening fighter but he was too wild with his punches. Even in the 7th when Paulie was rocked, he wasted too much effort, whilst making little ground.

Watch the fight again with no commentary :)

Mind you, the guys that voted for Paulie are either complete idiots or just biased Americans, or some of them could be Floyd's nuthuggers and since Malignaggi tries to imitate him... It was a close fight that I scored a draw, but calling anyone that had Malignaggi ahead a "complete idiot" is childish. You're the one here with the agenda.

by the looks of the poll it looks like it was a close fight. I only saw 7 rounds but it looked like Paulie was getting hit very hard. it definetly was a close fight.. but you gota watch it again and youll see what I mean.. ngoudjo landed some big shots that stand out more.. but in the end paulie landed alot more...

That's some BS and this shit is hurting boxing. Malignaggi is the more marketable guy which is why they gave it to him. Such bullshit. Makes me sick to my stomach. I have to agree with this. I am not saying he definitely lost, but when you have a judge scoring the fight 117-111, its just completely bogus. THey wanted paulie to win because he is the cash cow. Paulie is a pretty good fighter, but he doesn't hit with enough power, and he gets hit too much, his d is suspect. But hes quick and a good counter puncher and has a good jab. He keeps his left too low, and his right is down by his waist. I do not understand why so many boxers box this way nowadays. It was obvious early, even as Paulie was popping that jab consistantly, that he was in with a much stronger fighter. He never hurt or cut the guy. The same thing that happened tonight, is more or less similar to what happened in the Cotto Corley fight. Certain fighters are groomed for big fights down the line and when they hit bumps here and there, the judges or refs help them along.

Paulie won on landing cleaner shots. by the looks of the poll it looks like it was a close fight. I only saw 7 rounds but it looked like Paulie was getting hit very hard.

Paulie won on landing cleaner shots.

theres a three way tie on the poll.. lol I only watched from rounds 4-7 and then 9-12 so I can't form a complete opinion on who won until I watch it completely. from what I saw Paulie had a bad night though.

I suggest you change your username my friend. Paulie won the fight I just finished watching it and I have him winning 7 rounds. How can I change my username I tried b4 but cant? well I think he should of lost by 2-3 rounds but it was close to score some of the rounds and theres noway he won by 6 rounds dont no what was wrong with that judge..

i think ngoudjo was most effective when he countered with the right obviously, he was doing the right thing, pressure but dont swarm, just stay outside but near, make the slickster lead and counter him.....maliggnagi jabs and circles to the left, so the right counter was agreat choice for herman, he won the last 30 secs of the 3rd, the 4th round and the 7th with that plan...........but then malignaggi adjusted by circling to the right instead and herman was only effective when malignaggi kinda ran out of gas in the 11th and 12th..... but i got lots of respects for herman, he fought a good fight, but he didnt win.... herman won rounds 4-7-11-12 i could have given him the 3rd discuss.......

Ah theres no way paulie should of won that I thought that Ngoudjo should of at least had a draw and thought he won by 2-3 rounds.. Malignaggi got let off big time there!! I suggest you change your username my friend. Paulie won the fight I just finished watching it and I have him winning 7 rounds.