Who's the most overated boxer of all time?

Felix Trinidad ,Jermaine Taylor,Oscar Delahoya Oscar De La Hoya

Tyson without a doubt. Some of the answers on here are plain silly. Holyfield?? OMG! He's one of the best. I mean in his prime.

Keith McKnight, Joe Mesi, and Tye Fields. McKnight because of his (bloated) record 43-4 28ko's. Mesi because he is a sissy bitch, and Fields because well he sucks more d_@k than a pornstar. Samuel Peter will be ktfo by Kevin Johnson.

I kinda have to admit to Tyson even though he is one of my favorites of all time. He is in a similar boat as mayweather in that your eyes tell you that these guys HAVE To be ATG's just by how amazing they look in the ring, but they just dont have the PROOF that a record can bring to back it up. Comparing HW's records compared to multi-divisional champs isn't the same thing. It's ridiculous to even try to. Heavyweights are basically expected to fight the best because they wont be dropping or gaining weight to win other belts.

I kinda have to admit to Tyson even though he is one of my favorites of all time. He is in a similar boat as mayweather in that your eyes tell you that these guys HAVE To be ATG's just by how amazing they look in the ring, but they just dont have the PROOF that a record can bring to back it up.

i have to say tyson and today of course mayweather

Lennox Lewis, Floyd Mayweather, Evander Holyfield

LOL Trinidad wtf!! .... i think Ricky Hatton but maybe not all time

Mike Tyson, period. SRR as well I mean he is the best but to say his level of greatness is unreachable is asinine, he is human isn't he? Not really. In today's era of boxing it's rare to see a fighter pass 60 professional career fights, let alone retire with a record of 175-19 with 108 KO's. Ray Robinson will always hold that title, because he never took 6 months off between fights and he fought everybody who he came across and always won impressively.

to say felix trinidad is overrated is silly.dude isn't even ranked by most people in the top 25 all time.i nominate harry greb,i like him but have seen just training videos of 'em.

Mike Tyson, period. SRR as well I mean he is the best but to say his level of greatness is unreachable is asinine, he is human isn't he?

Mike Tyson Another one I agree with, even more so than Duran. He only ever beat one serious opponet in Spinks. Other than that he has more tin cans on his record than Roy Jones Jr. (And I know I'll catch flack for that comment as well.)

Mike Tyson

Ali. . . .

I'd have to concur on Felix Trinidad and Jarmain Taylor. But since we're talking all time greats here, I'd have to nominate Roberto Duran. Might catch me some flack here, and I do love "hands of stone" but his record against the best competition in his era is horrible.

all time greats

rocky graziano jack dempsey quitali quitschko

Are you talking overrated as in looking back on it now? Or someone people regard as an "All-Time-Great" who never really deserved the accolade?