Calzaghe P4P?

If Joe can beat Kesller convincinly then JC will be P4p no1. For his 10 years service and for being underated by people. People having the cheek to make Lacy favourite alone should pay for their ignorance in compensating JC for their behaviour. So JC deserves no1 status. ALso JT being abouve JC in the p4p ratings, and then losing to Pavlik. All these so called great fighters losing there unbeaten records but JC still plodding along with his intact at 35. JC deserves karma points for being deliberately underated and people accusing him of not fighting anyone good. When he does fight someone good, they say that is the only good person on his resume. Excuses excuses.

cal yeah cause when you say someone is bigger than someone else in Boxing terms the first thing that springs too mind is there HEIGHT AND REACH not weight ,LOL physically bigger is something you have invented

Cal Well why did'nt you just say he is taller ,physically bigger LOL

Pavlik I'm not talking about weight, I'm talking about physically bigger. Pavlik is definitely bigger than Calzaghe. He's huge for a Middleweight and would even be considered quite tall at Supermiddle. why are you talking about height now ,and WTF does physically bigger mean Calzaghe fights at 12 stone ,Pavlik fights at 11 stone 6 ,im sure Joe looks bigger as a super ,middleweight than Pavlik does at middleweight

Calzaghe walks around at cruiserweight. In fact Maccarinelli stated that he would make a world class cruiser and he hit just as hard then. Just goes to show how much he boils down for SMW. He should have moved up weight years ago .... would still have the power he had 5 years ago. As for Calzaghe, in the top 3 but then him, Mayweather and Pacman are way ahead of the rest at the moment. If Calzaghe puts on a show and Hatton turns over Mayweather then you could easily make a case for Calzaghe #1. It won't happen though as Hatton has little chance.

naa b-hop should be 1 if floyd loses

Joe Joe walks around at 14 stone so i suggest he is bigger than Pavlik,if Joe fought Pavlik they would have to scrape Pavlik off the canvas after Joe had finished with him he would get destroyed just like Lacy who all of a sudden is overated cause he got whipped good style by a british fighter

Sure he is. Pavlik is a big middleweight, Zaghe is a big supermiddle. Pavlik has some crunching power but does he have more than Lacy? Really? Taylor's record flatters him, that's why he wasn't p4p and why Pavlik isn't p4p for beating him. On top of that Calzaghe is more mobile and is difficult to hit with straight shots. That's why I'm picking Joe over Kessler.

Cal will be between 3 and 5 the others haven't lost. Lol this fuck's p4p list are all british fighters, biased much?

Calzaghe should beat Pavlik with ease. He's bigger, he's a better boxer, and he's hard to hit with straight punches. He's been in with bigger more dangerous punchers and survived to tell the tale.

As of right now? #1 Joe Calzaghe #2 Floyd Mayweather #3 Manny Paquiao #4 Bernard Hopkins #5 Kelly Pavlik Pavlik? No chance mate, not even close to the top 5 just yet.

1 Joe Calzghe 2 Ricky Hatton 3 David Haye 4 Junior Witter 5 Amir Khan

Would be interested to hear your current top 5 please? :) Mayweather pacquiao j.m. marquez bernard hopkins israel vazquez

It'd definately put him between 3 and 5, if he beats pavlik or hopkins after kessler then i doubt many would argue with him being number 1. Would be interested to hear your current top 5 please? :)

If Maywether loses come Dec the 8th, and Calzaghe beats Kessler convincingly, would you agree that JC becomes P4P? It'd definately put him between 3 and 5, if he beats pavlik or hopkins after kessler then i doubt many would argue with him being number 1.

he already is