Boxing over the years has seen some great natural talent, for whom the game appeared so easy, yet despite this they never achieved their full potential in the game for whatever reasons. As a brit the best example I can think of is Kirkland Laing, this guy could have been so much better, if only he trained properly and put the effort in, but because he was so naturally gifted he felt he was gonna beat anyone and didn't need to train. Regarding american fighters, one of the best natural talents I can remember in recent years was Michael 'second to' Nunn, and although winning titles at 2 weights, he never achieved his full potential, the Toney defeat had a big impact on him as well. He should never have lost that fight, but he believed he was unbeatable and was cocky and lazy. Toney as good as a fighter as he was, wasn't in the same class as Nunn. He should have ruled the middleweights for years. He had the talent to beat Toney,RJJ,Hopkins,Benn,Eubank and all the others.
I don't understand the Tyson and Jones Jr. being mentioned. Both achieved HOF careers and dominated their divisions for a number of years! What else could Jones have done?!? The guy is arguably the greatest Lt. Heavy since Ezzard or Tunney.
IMO talent gone to waste applies to the likes of Ike Ibeabuchi, Harry Simon, Terry Marsh or Audley Harrison. People who were gifted athletes/boxers who messed up for whatever reason. You could make an argument for someone like Zab Judah, but the reason he lost to the likes of Tszyu and Cotto was because he just wasn't good enough. Not only that - but he HAS had success in his career. In two divisions as well.
It has to be Sonny Liston, without a doubt, and that is really saying something as he was #1 contender and champ for 5 years in total (a top 10 ring contender for almost 10, I believe).
He should've had the title for 10 years, and had he been born 10 years later in a less-mafia run fight game he would have, and that would've put him in against Foreman, Frazier, Quarry, Ali, Norton, etc..
shane mosley is another case of wasted potential, even if he did accopmplish a lot, if he hadnt accepted to move up to welterweight, he woulda made a greater legacy beating the likes of freitas, casamyor, mayweather jr, corrales, tszyu.....
moving up and fighting de la hoya was better for his pocket, marketabilty and image though, so i dont blame him...
I change my mind I have to say David Tua, How can you combine one of the greatest chins in history, with one of the greatest punching power in history and not be a champion at least once.
God I knew everyone was going to say Judah. I'm so tired of this...
Why does everyone believe the same sad excuse when it comes to Judah? Its always the same thing, he doesn't train for 12 rounds, he isn't focused blah blah.
Naw I call bullshit on that. Baldomir aside (that one seems legit, and I had Judah up by a point anyway), Judah has lost because he's plain not good enough. Zab admitted himself that he was running 8 miles a day, and sparring three minute rounds with thirty second rest in between. I made sure I remembered that because I knew people would bring up the same weak excuse that Judah didn't prepare.
Talent isn't just physical ability, its mental ability too. When to slip punches, when to move out of the pocket after punching, when to set traps etc. Its not called the sweet science for anything. You have to be smart in the ring too. Some people can prepare their whole life for that and still not be good at the mental aspect of boxing, and Zab just isn't good enough in that department.
I feel Toney could have been an ATG if he didn't let his weight get the best of him. I wouldn't say it went to waste though.