Andre Berto .VS. Top 10 Welterweights

berto has good power, although he's defense is bad, he fights similiar to shane mosley actually with the pawing jab then exploding into the opponent, i think he can beat collazo and urkal but would lose to clottey, but styles make fights i also think cotto would lose to clottey

Berto wouldn't even beat the top ten light-welterweights.

His defense is dreadful but I'm pick him to beat Urkal. Clottey and Collazo would tee off on him for 12 rounds.

i know that he and luis collazo sparred a lot, he was a partner to help collazo against the mosely fight, they went at it pretty good. his defense does need improvement

Berto is to green for any of them, his d needs some serious work which will improve in time. I give him one more year and either at the end of 08 or the start of 09 it will be his time. Yeah I see him getting a huge win and being at least a titlest by the end of 08......he needs to be careful and beat some solid opp to boost his confidence before he takes on a major cat.I see that happening in early 09 hopefully.

Berto is to green for any of them, his d needs some serious work which will improve in time. I give him one more year and either at the end of 08 or the start of 09 it will be his time.

How About Berto VS Cintron......... lol

even as a fan and supporter of Bertos rise......I will say he is not ready for most top 10 guys.he has great potential but just had a good solid learning session fight which he showed great adversity in......I think he needs another 3=5 fights depending on how he looks in them against solid frimge comtenders or former title challengers to hone his skill.He is very youg and there is no need to rush. Given what I said above.....I think he would give the top 5-10 fighters in the division a good fight.....he is at least a year away from fighting for a signifigant title and thats only gonna happen as long as he is impressive in his wins over solid contenders.

He could beat Urkal. Maybe...

I'd pick him over Collazo and Urkal I don't know if he's ready for Clottey yet.

I dunno,his defense is piss poor.