Who wins now: PBF vs Punisher

williams would give mayweather trouble but mayweather would win a UD

Williams cant hit a moving target so....Floyd is a nightmare for him

if the unification fight happened today whoops! looks like wiliams needs to get a belt to unify with floyd eh? i think errrm, floyd

obviously pw cant handle movement. floyd will kill him and make him look amaturish!

floyd defeats paul in a great fight and floyd goes to paul's body very well i guarantee it. i'm not basing paul's lost tonight on how he fights floyd, but mayweather is way more elusive than quitana and more accurate and has better stamina. paul lost tonight, okay, so what. he would give floyd competition in a losing effort, and i see floyd possibly stopping paul going to the body. floyd goes to the body very well.

even after william's loss i'd pick him over floyd, he is use fighting righthanded fighters liek floyd please, floyd will beat him easily. its clear he cant fight against a moving target

even after william's loss i'd pick him over floyd, he is use fighting righthanded fighters liek floyd

Don't vote now!!! This is just a bump. It was 30-28.

floyd by SD

In this one I caught hell for saying Williams would be an easier fight for Floyd than Hatton was. OK mods, no more threadbumping from me, I promise!

All I have to say is the proof is in pbftxrs316's sig. Hahaha I was thinking the exact same thing when reading his post. It's cute that he named himself after his fantasy lover boy.

All I have to say is the proof is in pbftxrs316's sig.

Nobody at 147 is beating Williams any time soon. Sorry to say, Floyd fans, but this guy would work Mayweather into an early retirement.you keep telling yourself that junior. floyd mayweather beats every fighter from 154 down and a few at 160. shane mosley loses cotto loses hatton is going to lose paul williams loses cintron loses quartey loses berto loses clottey loses it doesn't matter who they are, they all lose.

Mayweather all the way. Williams is far too green and Floyd would just mess him up with lateral movement. Ya but hows he gonna hit him...hes like 5'6". It would look something like this: http://img298.echo.cx/img298/9008/yourheight67dw.jpg

it would be a competitive matchup no doubt, but floyd mayweather is too elusive for paul williams and his stamina is better than paul's also. williams has a high punch output but he is still green and he's never faced a fighter like a mayweather and no amount of preperation he does would do him any good because he'd have to put on a performance of a lifetime against floyd and i don't believe he could do that against a fighter like floyd mayweather who is just too good of a fighter overall for williams, who would not be tougher than when castillo fought floyd. paul williams has great stamina seeing how he throws many punches each round but fighting a floyd mayweather who has arguably the best stamina in boxing today and who moderates his punch output and is great with his footspeed and ring movement, paul would be outclassed by floyd in a great fighter imo.

He's got lightweight power and he's 6'2"

Paul Williams has a sweet right hook and a mean left uppercut. Saying he has nothing to keep constant attackers off of him is, for lack of a better word, retarded.

Nobody at 147 is beating Williams any time soon. Sorry to say, Floyd fans, but this guy would work Mayweather into an early retirement.

He's got bad balance and no snap on his wrist/back-of-hand punches. He's got nothing to keep a motivated attacker off him. Someone like Cotto should have no trouble getting around or through his right hand to land shot at his long torso. He's off balance when he moves back, a few good body shots would put him down. margarito is not a motivated attacker? not questioning your logic, but isnt margarito one of those pressure fighters? Cotto is the only worry I have for Paul in the WW division but he is 5'6. how the hell could he reach the body with Pun's movement? at least margarito is 5'10. Cotto is relentless and works every minute of every round and Pun works every minute of every round too. thats my dream match up in the division. I think in the end Cotto is too short for Pun. Now, how does Pun have bad balance? He can move around. can you have good movement yet still have bad balance? and the power thing is debatable all day. mad people here think Paul is kinda feather fisted, he has racked up some knock outs. he wears you down with the volume and put you out. not a one hitter quitter. I think margarito is too bull headed to get knocked out by anyone in the division. Marg just might have the best chin in the Welters now. You cant fairly judge his power until 1 or 2 more fights from now. I aint trying to belittle you or anything, but was that the first time you saw Flako Grande fight?

.................... At this point in time im going with Mayweather because of the following... willaims as impressive as he looked versus margarito still took some shots ...now mayweather is on another level than margarito so he would catch williams alot more and make him miss alot more... williams still needs to imporve his skills... i personally dont think this fight will happen but if it does..i dont think mayweathers all out defense would work,,he would defintely need to be active in this fight...but i think mayweather is smart enough to figure that out on his own.....