IF ANY OF THESE FIGHTERS RETIRED TODAY, which would make the HOF?!?!?!? (check all)

well duran went the distance with benitez and they both beat pepino. w/e

Hearns is a 7 time champ, I wouldn't say Duran accomplished more! Both are all time greats, either you like them or not! i would agree with you, but its agruable that duran beat the better guys. He did beat SRL in there first fight, and Hearns did not. If you want to compare titles, then yea, hearns take the cake. but its all in how u see the fighters. I guess i worded it wrong, cuase i said which fighter accomplished more. I meant more of a better fight. And THATS arguable. id go with hearns though

they're both rated very highly Duran arguably accomplished more though... so it deosnt mean duran isnt better

Hearns crushed Duran... they're both rated very highly

Manny Pac for sure... Even a BIG plus if he knocks out Morales AGAIN!

ok someone tell me how gatti would make it in?.....i like the guy but in no way is he HOF material....a warrior yes but no FAMER.....

All of these fighters WOULD make it into the HOF if they retired today.

you just revealed how incredibly fucking stupid you are. Mayweather crushed Castillo and Corrales, yet you think they have accomplished more than him? do you realize how ridiculous that is? Hearns crushed Duran...

I know it hurts you that he has great talent. nah it dont hurt me....on second thought it did hurt to watch him dismantle my boy chico but other than that he has my respect.....

i say pac, pbf, corrales, castillo, and taylor....oh and winky.....just for the fact that corrales and castillo were in the GREATEST fight of ALL time merits them since when they fought they were at the top of their game and was for the undisputed lightweight title....and yes i know jackass pretty boy dominated both..... I know it hurts you that he has great talent.

I really can't see how people can have Pacquiao in over such a wide margin compared to Jose Luis Castillo.. Don't get me wrong i think Pac is in but people are showing so much hate to JLC. Lets see who has Castillo beat... Stevie Johnston, Joel Casamayor, Diego Corrales, Juan Lazcano, Julio Diaz.. Not to mention that he (in many peoples eyes) beat the #1 P4P Floyd Mayweather Jr.. Once he beats Hatton though it will assured. i agree with you on that one....i think castillo beat mayweather the 1st fight....clearly.......

i say pac, pbf, corrales, castillo, and taylor....oh and winky.....just for the fact that corrales and castillo were in the GREATEST fight of ALL time merits them since when they fought they were at the top of their game and was for the undisputed lightweight title....and yes i know jackass pretty boy dominated both.....

thats weird because i dont think any of them deserve to go yet. maybe pac and winky but thats it, followed by castillo and corrales, but the guys on there like floyd and hatton with their bullshit undefeated records no way, i want to see how they do after a loss and if they can come back from defeat then sure. Actually your just a hater. How the fuck could you put those others ahead of Mayweather?

I really can't see how people can have Pacquiao in over such a wide margin compared to Jose Luis Castillo.. Don't get me wrong i think Pac is in but people are showing so much hate to JLC. Lets see who has Castillo beat... Stevie Johnston, Joel Casamayor, Diego Corrales, Juan Lazcano, Julio Diaz.. Not to mention that he (in many peoples eyes) beat the #1 P4P Floyd Mayweather Jr.. Once he beats Hatton though it will assured.

Mayweather and Pacquiao are definites if they retire right now. I think Wright and Taylor will also eventually get in. Not sure about the rest of the list. if you think taylor is worthy of the hall of fame you should probably be more polite with your retorts because that is just plain retarded. the guy is an obvious paper champ.

so basically to go to the hall of fame, you have to be a loser. that's what you're saying. if you haven't lost, you can't make it. what a fucking joke. rematches are for people that need two fights to adapt to a fighter. Floyd Mayweather doesn't need fucking rematches because he's the best on the planet and makes his adjustment in the ring, not in a dark room watching the fight. not a very good response. boxing today is like big time wrestling, floyds fights are setups now its rediculous. i wouldnt vote any one of them into the hof right now because i think thier careers have many more hurdles to pass. the hall of fame is supposed to be for exceptional fighters and all of them have the opportunity to be just that but i would rather see how the rest of thier careers play out. i never said i wouldnt ever vote them in. i wouldnt vote them in as of now though.

You wouldn't put Rocky Marciano in the HoF? if he were fighting today and i was watching? not a chance in hell.

Mayweather and Pacquiao are definites if they retire right now. I think Wright and Taylor will also eventually get in. Not sure about the rest of the list.

where is De La Hoya, Holyfield, Barera, Jones Jr, Toney, maybe even Calzaghe on your list? those are gimme's. i wanted to pick ones that would cause a discussion. and i only had 10 spots

As of right now,Winky Wright,Manny Pacquiao,and Floyd Mayweather.