Floyd will beat Oscar...IMO

i dont think oscar is too big, but it does give him an advantage(height/reach)

Floyd probably will win but its going to be booring thanks to Mayweather! This fight wont live up to the hype, I really hope that the P4P best atleast trys to make this an exciting fight for us boxing fans!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That "too big" excuse never works against good boxers. I might use it if Taylor or Hearns was fighting Floyd but thats about it.

Who poses a bigger challenge that DLH?? Hatton. The only reason to fight DLH is the money and exposure, and the only difficulty will be the weight (assuming Floyd wont just show up at like 150 or something and still wuup up on Oscar.

I would have to pick Floyd in this one to.Oscar has had endurance problems for years now and he cant chase Floyd down at this age. Oscar should take advantage of his size and power. If he fails, Floyd will win.

I would have to pick Floyd in this one to.Oscar has had endurance problems for years now and he cant chase Floyd down at this age.

Pernell, at 5'6, is shorter than Floyd by two inches and he gave Oscar big trouble--even floored the Golden Boy. But Pernell had been at 147 for quite a while before facing Oscar at that weight. It was not as if Oscar was all that big for Whitaker. Oscar has fought five times at 154, Floyd never. Not even in a tune up. He can work with the view of carrying the extra weight sparring in the gym, do more flex and agility exercises with the objective of retaining his usual speed but it's never the same as in a competitive fight over 12 rouinds. The proof of the pudding is in the eating, and I don't believe it is wise for Floyd to test the 154 waters by facing a De La Hoya who has had five fights at that weight, winning four and losing one-- to Shane. He should have a tune-up if only to find out for sure if he can carry that much weight into the later rounds without becoming vulnerable. But, of course a bad performance in a tune-up can jeopardize the big money. So... Speaking of De La Hoya's loss to Sugar Shane, it may be that which is encouraging Floyd's camp. They may have seen something there as well as in the De La Hoya-Whitaker fight. But Shane had two tune-ups before facing De La Hoya. Oh well... The fight is reportedly on. I can hardly wait, just the same.

Has mayweather ever faced a good jabber? I'm not to sure I've only been a floyd fan for 4 years and have not seen all his fights.

My pick might of been diffrent if this was a prime oscar.But I have trouble visualizing a de la hoya win.That shouldnt really be a surprise to anybody though.

for floyd. oscar is too big to beat.

Who poses a bigger challenge that DLH??