RJJ or PBF?

My personal vote is RJJ. But it goes like this: RJJ athletic skill, power, and talent, and raw speed. FMJ: boxing skill, ring smarts, chin, a hundred times more adaptable in adjustement and types of style that he can employ. Roy only needs one style of fighting. His problems have been his refusal to let his hands go recently. Thats nothing to do with style, just a mental thing.

Roy dominated some of the greatest fighters ever in Hopkins and Toney. Even up at Heavyweight Toney hasn't been dominated like what Roy done to him.

At this present time its Roy. As good as Floyd is right now Roy was better he was untouchable there wasn't a trainer that could come up with a strategy to even win a round against him. Where as Floyd was almost knocked on his ass by Chop-Chop. Although Zab didn't get credit for it he, technically he knocked him down in there fight and, also knocked him across the ring. Regardless of what people say about James Toney condition when they fought, at that time James was what Roy became. The best pound for pound fighter on the planet and he got his handed to him. I don't Floyd has faced an opponent that can be considered on his level. With that being said, when its all said and done I think you may have to rank Floyd higher than Roy because he has the one thing Roy did not have, big name opposition surrounding him in his weight class. Floyd has the chance to beat Cotto, Hatton, Oscar, Mosely, Williams, and thats on top of the other big names he's already defeated. So prime for prime I'd give it to Roy all day but, career stats and legacy if Floyd stays hungry and true to his word about making the biggest fights he will end up ahead of Roy. Look at his feet. He's standing straight over his feet and they're about 4 feet apart because he was lunging in to the body. He had no lateral balance, and Zab hit him falling away from Mayweather. Knocking him across the ring hardly. That's like saying if I pushed you from wall to wall from behind I knocked you across the room. Very weak. Was it a KD, yes, was it anything mroe than balance, no. Roy he the deck vs Del Valle, who is no one compared to Judah. And that was a legit KD after getting caught flush on the chin. You can't note one and not the other.

At this present time its Roy. As good as Floyd is right now Roy was better he was untouchable there wasn't a trainer that could come up with a strategy to even win a round against him. Where as Floyd was almost knocked on his ass by Chop-Chop. Although Zab didn't get credit for it he, technically he knocked him down in there fight and, also knocked him across the ring. Damn, great point referring to Zab knocking down Floyd to the point where he had to balance himself on the canvas with his glove -- I think there are definitely a good number of people out there who forgot about that minor stat, well said. If this were Around the Horn (with Max Kellerman of course, not Tony Reali's wack ass), you'd get a solid three points, easy.

At this present time its Roy. As good as Floyd is right now Roy was better he was untouchable there wasn't a trainer that could come up with a strategy to even win a round against him. Where as Floyd was almost knocked on his ass by Chop-Chop. Although Zab didn't get credit for it he, technically he knocked him down in there fight and, also knocked him across the ring. Regardless of what people say about James Toney condition when they fought, at that time James was what Roy became. The best pound for pound fighter on the planet and he got his handed to him. I don't Floyd has faced an opponent that can be considered on his level. With that being said, when its all said and done I think you may have to rank Floyd higher than Roy because he has the one thing Roy did not have, big name opposition surrounding him in his weight class. Floyd has the chance to beat Cotto, Hatton, Oscar, Mosely, Williams, and thats on top of the other big names he's already defeated. So prime for prime I'd give it to Roy all day but, career stats and legacy if Floyd stays hungry and true to his word about making the biggest fights he will end up ahead of Roy.

His last trip outside the US resulted in him getting utterly shafted out of a Gold Medal. Can't blame him for never wanting to leave. Benn, Nunn and Liles would of taken place in the US. And Eubank was the biggest payday out there for him by miles, which is why he wanted to come here for it before Eubank lost ;) I don't blame him for not wanting the Eubank fight when Eubank made his comeback though and was calling for it, even though it was still the biggest payday out there, because it was a dodgy one and Eubank had two losses already (and wasn't a big name in the US).

Yeah, and he didn't fight Benn, Eubank or Collins, or Nunn or Liles. He did though look stupid at that weight. His last trip outside the US resulted in him getting utterly shafted out of a Gold Medal. Can't blame him for never wanting to leave.

Roy Jones Jr. all the way. He was untouchable in his prime and had great power. The man fought two legends and slaughtered them.

Roy Jones at 168 is one of the best boxers of all time....however, he only stayed there for like 6 fights. Yeah, and he didn't fight Benn, Eubank or Collins, or Nunn or Liles. He did though look stupid at that weight.

Roy Jones at 168 is one of the best boxers of all time....however, he only stayed there for like 6 fights.

Actual quote in regards to R.J.: "Of course I'm better than Roy Jones Jr. Why would you even ask that?" - Pretty Boy Floyd Mayweather Jr. - :boxing:

Got i something wrong or hasn't Jones fought Reggie Johnson Johnson used to be good, back in the day.

I realise Mayweather hasn't fought many good guys, but Jones just fucking tormented me because there were so many quality fights to be made that people like me could masturbate over.. I really wanted to see him fight Lamar Parks or Reggie Johnson, Parks was an excellent little fighter (better than Hopkins IMO) and punch for punch had Very heavy hands, and Johnson was slick as a greaseball back then. Jones turned down a fight with Julian Jackson early in '93, too. Then there was Calzaghe, Nunn, Jirov. Got i something wrong or hasn't Jones fought Reggie Johnson

I realise Mayweather hasn't fought many good guys, but Jones just fucking tormented me because there were so many quality fights to be made that people like me could masturbate over.. I really wanted to see him fight Lamar Parks or Reggie Johnson, Parks was an excellent little fighter (better than Hopkins IMO) and punch for punch had Very heavy hands, and Johnson was slick as a greaseball back then. Jones turned down a fight with Julian Jackson early in '93, too. Then there was Calzaghe, Nunn, Jirov.

boxing talent? floyd mayweather....physical talent and athletic ability? roy jones. Well said. At this point, Roy's career sets him apart. Floyds still got a lot left in him, so the question is premature.

Just watch the Corrales and Gatti fights and tell me who was more skilled and talented than Floyd Mayweather, EVER?

RJJ by far

RJJ for me

ROY JONES JR. was practically invincible before the Tarver fight. it is sad that Eubank and Benn are around during his prime and wasnt able to fight them. regardless he was awesome in his prime

boxing talent? floyd mayweather....physical talent and athletic ability? roy jones.