Which test was harder for Mayweather-- Castillo 1 or Zab???

I never saw the first fight between PBF and Castillo, but have heard many times that Castillo should of got the D-- I saw the Zab fight and I was surprised with how many times Floyd got tagged with solid shots, he even almost went down-- Who do y'all think gave PBF a tougher match-up???? castillo by far. that was a close fight. the judah fight was total domination by floyd after the 4th round

Good looking out with the link-- Here is a link for that fight-- Castillo won that fight. remember that 2 judges gave Mayweather the 12th round!!! :eek: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IgmyzgNNIk&search=boxing

so you scored it 116-114 before point deductions? wha? have you even seen that fight? Here is a link for that fight-- Castillo won that fight. remember that 2 judges gave Mayweather the 12th round!!! :eek: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IgmyzgNNIk&search=boxing

Castillo straight roughed PBF more so than any other.... Floyd has been hurt numerous times in a few fights bit overcame them....The 1st Castillo fight was pretty close and could have went either way by 1 round or settled in nicely at a draw...But the 2nd was a completely different story...Mayweather didnt take Castillo seriously in the 1st fight and Castillo didnt bring his A game to the second fight...Thats his fault, Floyd didnt have to give him another opportunity.... Zab was a walk in the park, the only thing that hurt Floyd was the weight it deterred his speed....It was vintage Mayweather in their...Gave away a few rounds to feel the opponent out and then utter domination (which it was)...But Zab also didnt impress, where was the combinations and the power? Corley stunned Mayweather in their fight and Zab wasnt even hurt...He looked as bad as Gatti when he wasnt winning.

castillo was defenitely a tougher fight for pbf. zab had 2 good rds. and one o.k. rd. and that's it, pbf did whatever he wanted after the 4th. castillo could step up right now and knock zab's punk ass out.

I think the Zab fight was a bigger test because I've never gotten to see Floyds nuts tested like that, looks like they passed lol

Castillo did, he should have won the fight 115-113. so you scored it 116-114 before point deductions? wha? have you even seen that fight?

Castillo did, he should have won the fight 115-113.

I thought Floyd won them both by more or less the same margin. I guess equally tough but since Zab is mentally weak whereas Castillo never stops fighting or gives in, Castillo was probably the tougher fight.