jose luis castillo vs. ricardo mayorga at welterweight [who wins?]

First instinct is to say JLC, because simply he's a better fighter. But man, Mayorga is a strong 147 that was able to impose himself on Forrest, who is far more skilled IMHO than Castillo. And Mayorga has an incredible chin. I don't know, but if I had to bet then I'd probably bet on Mayorga. It's a tough one to call.

First off, your girlfriend kicks serious ass for watching boxing, but Castillo would overwhelm Mayorga. What he said, especially about ur girl. ;)

JLC just has to go to the body early and stop Mayorga the same way tito did. Hes not gonna knock him out or down with a head shot.... so i say Castillo body attack takes him down in the 10th.

skill has its limimt when put against such overwhlemin physical obstacles its not like mayo is a drained welter hes a big strong welter castillo is a big strong 135 maybe 140 but hes a blown up 147 no question chico stunned and KOd castillo that a no doubt hard hittin 135 pounder!!!!! now ur talkin about a hard hittin 147 pounder who took 8rds of punishment from one of the hardest hittin 147 maybe 154 pounders srry just to much stacked against JLC mayo by KO

First off, your girlfriend kicks serious ass for watching boxing, but Castillo would overwhelm Mayorga. she said thank you ,i thank you too!

I argue with my girlfriend about this one almost every other day, i say castillo,she says mayorga, but then i'll recall just how much of a savage mayorga really was at welterweight and to tell you truth,I really can't call this one,how would try to ya'll call it? First off, your girlfriend kicks serious ass for watching boxing, but Castillo would overwhelm Mayorga.