is ali and joe louis over rated?

Joe Louis has never beaten another top 10 heavywieght of all times, whether they were in thier primes or not. His resume doesnt read any top 10 heavyweight. Walcott and schmeling are top 15-20, anyone that knows boxing wouldnt place any of those guys near the top 10. Ali has beat foreman, frazier twice and liston twice. So his resume pretty much owns joe's. I dont see why there is a debate here.

"is they overrated?" who taught you to talk? a homeless man your mom fucked in the south bronx?

O........k!

i was just tryin to be nice and un bias ...i'm a big Ali fan to and have a hard time seeing him lose to Louis or any fighter at all....prime Ali that is

i'm not sayin he would just that he could :) Their is noway on this earth that he would of but i do get your point he might have had a chance against ali MIGHT!

there's no way. i'm not sayin he would just that he could :)

i'd say Ali was the best champ ever... but Louis may have beaten Ali if they fought there's no way.

i'd say Ali was the best champ ever... but Louis may have beaten Ali if they fought

I don't think 68-3 record is overrated. I also don't think beating the best heavyweights in what is considered the best heavyweight era is overrated.

Hah how is Ali underrated? People say hes the best there is. Maybe people didn't see him at his best but hes not underrated. because most only recognizes him for beating foreman and fighting frazier, both he fought after his prime. 1967-1970 would have really been ali's prime, cause he would have been as strong as he was in 1971, and as fast as he was in 1967. so you combine that and you've got a physical freak of nature! so ali had the physical gifts to be even better than people think. nobody would beat him. it would have been a carbon copy of louis' title reign, maybe even longer! that is pretty scary! :eek:

Hah how is Ali underrated? People say hes the best there is. Maybe people didn't see him at his best but hes not underrated.

i dont think either are overrated. they both had major impacts on boxing and society at large. they were great boxers and very influential men.

maybe louis was a little. ali is probably a little underrated 'cause he could have done better if he had fought from 1967-1970.

Muhammad Ali is ofcourse over-rated. Joe Louis is under-rated. I agree, I think Ali was heavily overated and Louis was slighty underated.

Joe Louis overrated? Worst post ever. if u would of read my post like a big boy u would have noticed i didnt say there over rated(i said they could be not they r) i just wanted to know some opinions.u shouldnt jump on someone unless u clearly understand the post. ;) and by the way i dont think the overrated i just wanted to know what ppl think.

Muhammad Ali is ofcourse over-rated. Joe Louis is under-rated. ali is no way over rated. i wouldn't say louis is under rated, but hes jus rated lol

Your freaking grammer and posting ideas are overrated. Ali and Louis are not.

Heavyweights are always rated above the lighterweights.

Joe Louis overrated? Worst post ever.

so who else thing there overrated