Advertisement
Advertisement
Boxingscene.com

Carl Frampton Gains Upper Hand in Legal Battle With McGuigan

Former world champion Carl Frampton has gained the upper hand in his ongoing legal battle with ex-manager and promoter Barry McGuigan.

The two sides are battling it out at the North Ireland High Court.

The Belfast fighter claims that he wasn't paid properly under an arrangement which "unjustly enriched" McGuigan and his company, Cyclone Promotions.

frampton-santa-cruz-fight (39)_2

The legal action is Frampton's counter-claim to a separate legal proceeding brought against him by Cyclone Promotions at the High Court in London. When that case was filed, Frampton's lawyers promised that a counter-claim would be filed.

McGuigan went after Frampton for breach of contract. Last summer, Frampton cut ties with McGuigan and is now promoted by Frank Warren.

The boxer also cut ties with head trainer, Shane McGuigan, who is Barry's son. Frampton is now trained by Jamie Moore.

The lawyers for McGuigan argued that the case should be heard at the High Court in London - where his case is being heard.

After some legal wrangling, the judge issued an order on Tuesday - which was music to Frampton's ears - stating that the legal battle should be heard in Belfast.

The court judgement said: "It will now be for the English court to determine whether it considers it should hear a claim brought in London by Cyclone Promotions Limited and Blain McGuigan against Frampton and whether London is the more appropriate forum to hear all the disputes."

Frampton's lawyer John Finucane issued the following statement: "On behalf of my client Carl Frampton, we welcome Mr Justice Horner’s judgment today that his cases against Cyclone Promotions Ltd, Cyclone Promotions (UK) Limited, Barry & Sandra McGuigan will be heard before the High Court in Belfast.

"The Court agreed with our argument that Mr Frampton had a right to have his cases heard here in Belfast, and importantly was first to correctly issue and serve proceedings before a court. Whilst the evidence remains to be tested, and we acknowledge that this will happen expeditiously, we note the questions and comments of the court in today’s judgment.

"As the Court referred to today, we were surprised that, during the course of the jurisdictional dispute, Mr Barry McGuigan chose not to give any evidence. We will now prepare and look forward to the fact that Mr Barry McGuigan, and other members of the McGuigan family, will be required to come to Belfast and give evidence in court under oath.

"One of the many questions which require detailed explanation, and truly at the heart of this case is referred to at para. 18 of today’s judgment which states;

'It has to be recognised that it is exceptionally difficult to follow or understand what has happened or is alleged to have happened because many of the legal entities have used or use the same or similar names. Companies within the Cyclone Connection use the same names as companies that have been dissolved. One of the many issues, which this litigation will have to resolve, is whether this was a deliberate decision on the part of the Cyclone Connection in an effort to sow the seeds of confusion and make it much more difficult and complicated for Frampton to enforce his legal rights.'

"In the context of my client’s contractual claim the court went on to highlight that Mr McGuigan would be live to the obvious conflict of interest if one person acted as both manager and promoter. In fact, Barry McGuigan said the following, which was taken from “Barry McGuigan: The Untold Story”;

“There should never be any financial connection whatsoever, either directly or indirectly, between any manager and any promoter. Even a blind man can see that when you have the one person wearing the two hats – or somebody else wear one for him – then that is an obvious conflict of interest.”

"My client Carl Frampton has always sought a fair, reasonable and successful outcome to this dispute, and whilst he continues to enjoy a highly successful career we will now focus on bringing all outstanding matters before the court at the earliest opportunity."

McGuigan became Frampton's manager after coming to Belfast to sign him in 2009. The judge was told that Frampton would have decided differently if he'd known McGuigan and his wife had been banned from being company directors for five years after a previous venture had debts of £80,000 back in 1996.

In an affidavit obtained by the Belfast Telegraph, Frampton stated: "I do not believe I would have signed an agreement with Barry McGuigan if he had told me about his disqualification as a director."

The boxer's parents were said to have sold a large number of tickets to their son's fights after the management arrangement was signed.

Referring to Frampton's father, the boxer's lawyer said: "He paid large amounts of ticket money in cash into Barry McGuigan's bank account in Belfast. There's a dispute between him (Mr Frampton Sr) and Mrs McGuigan - he thought possibly up to £1m in cash over that period, she says £220,000. But it's a lot of cash being collected from fights from people in Belfast."

It is further claimed that Frampton's former management company had a conflict of interests and "withheld money due to him" after McGuigan started acting as promoter.

Tags: Carl Frampton image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by lefthooklead on 06-06-2018

[QUOTE=Shadoww702;18833303]No clue why is dad gave him the money?? And I think it was from him even selling tickets or some sht?? Who knows? Either way they were conned and I hope they get their $$ and then some. Boxers…

Comment by lefthooklead on 06-06-2018

[QUOTE=Shadoww702;18832859]WOW!!! At first I was blaming Frampton but not now. Manager, promotor, and son as trainer??? They were taking him to the cleaners.[/QUOTE] I remember hearing that Quigg got paid a lot more than Frampton into their fight even though…

Comment by jglvz256 on 06-06-2018

Barry Mcguigan got sued by his own manager as well back in the day. He spends a lot of time being taken to court.

Comment by yammy25 on 06-06-2018

I can't be the only one here to know that barry got done in like 1995 for dodgy business dealings and wasn't allowed to direct a company? The guys a ****ing crook..

Comment by super-x on 06-06-2018

No loyalty what so ever. Frampton was Mcguigans lottery ticket and they milked him... Hope Frampton takes them for Millions and leaves them broke.

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (22)
Top Headlines Hidenori Otake Vows To KO Isaac Dogboe in Glendale Jay Harris: Me vs. Andrew Selby is a Good Fight For Welsh Fans! Wilder: Joshua Got His Name By Beating an Inactive, Beaten Guy! Wilder: Fury is Ready, He's in Perfect Shape, No Excuses Andrew Moloney Ready For Concepcion, Wants Kal Yafai Video: Lamon Brewster Talks Wilder-Fury, Wilder-Joshua Fights Video: Jose Benavidez Talks Crawford Title Shot, Porter-Garcia Deontay Wilder-Tyson Fury: The Heist Wilder: Hearn, Joshua Are Envious - Said Fury Wouldn't Happen Boxing figures to band together to raise cash for Chris Edwards Jaime Munguia vs. Brandon Cook on Canelo-Golovkin Card Fury: If I Didn't Believe I Could Beat Wilder - I'd Pack Up & Retire Deontay Wilder vs. Tyson Fury is a 50-50 Deal, Says Frank Warren Video: Brandon Rios Talks Ring Return, Garcia-Porter, More Video: Tom Loeffler Talks Golovkin-Canelo Rematch, More Video: Shane Mosley Talks Canelo vs. Golovkin, Porter-Garcia Saunders: I Shook Hands With Wilder; Squashed Chicken Beef Araneta Blasts Out Tomogdan Cold, Wins WBC Asia Belt in Cebu Wilder: When I Beat The Man Who Beat The Man - I'm The Man! Video: Caleb Plant Talks Hand Injury, Uzcategui Fight, Ramirez Video: Badou Jack Talks Kovalev-Alvarez, Stevenson-Gvozdyk Video: Terence Crawford Talks Garcia-Porter, Benavidez Fight Video: Bob Arum Talks Wilder-Fury, Manny Pacquiao, More Carlos Cuadras Gets Technical Decision Over Ricardo Nunez Khan: Fight With Pacquiao Could Sell Out Stadium in the UK Shavkat Rakhimov Destroys Robinson Castellanos in Two Evgeny Tishchenko Makes Pro Debut With TKO Win in Five Photos: Jesse Hart, Shakur Stevenson, Jason Sosa, Cornflake Win Fury: Wilder Called, I Answered - Not Like Sh*thouse Joshua! Photos: Jennings Dropped, Comes Back To Stop Dimitrenko Deontay Wilder: I Promise - Fury Will Be a Knockout Victim! Photos: Tyson Fury Boxes Past Pianeta, Secures Deontay Wilder Photos: Carl Frampton Stops Jackson, Looks To Warrington Shot Photos: Cristofer Rosales Takes Out Paddy Barnes With KO Frampton: Warrington Fight is Easiest To Make - Let's Do It Atchariya Claims Decision, Chanoi Scores KO in Bangkok Fury: Wilder Congratulated Me, Said it Was Great Performance Subriel Matias Crushes Breidis Prescott, Jantony Ortiz is KO'd Tyson Fury vs. Francesco Pianeta - CompuBox Punch Stats Haye Cautions Fury That Wilder Has 'Real Dynamite' in Hands
Advertisement

Latest Active Forum Threads
Advertisement
Advertisement