BoxingScene Pound for Pound Update: November 2019

Give it time and the results can pile up and make something as fanciful as pound-for-pound ratings hard to think through.

What matters most?

Is it recent form, career resume and accomplishments, or the pure hypothetical guess work of what would happen if everyone was the same size? Seemingly everyone has a different answer and that’s as it should be. It would be cool if there was a magic machine to, say, pit the punching power of Naoya Inoue against Deontay Wilder in a relatively equal fight.

It would be cool to win the lottery too.

The latter is at least statistically possible.


Since the last update, we’ve seen a modern great add another feather to his cap, the completion of two World Boxing Super Series, a new lineal king at light heavyweight, and the sports biggest prime star jump two weight classes to knock out a stalwart of the last decade.

For this list, it meant the exit of Mikey Garcia and Srisaket Sor Rungvisai from the top ten for now as Manny Pacquiao returns and Josh Taylor cracks the top ten. It also meant a shake-up at the top.

Terence Crawford, the previous number one who is stuck in an unfortunate limbo without a serious fight on the immediate horizon, slips as the men now ahead of him find new challenges easier to come by. For this scribe, the top two came down to Canelo Alvarez, previously fourth, and Naoya Inoue, previously second.

Others might still have Crawford up top, or rest their argument with a Vasyl Lomachenko or Oleksandr Usyk. They’re all right answers in as interesting a debate for the top spot as there has been in some time.   

Enjoy the debate.

For the full update: 

Last Update: July 1, 2019

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by The D3vil on 11-19-2019

Yeah, you guys are right. It's getting harder & harder for me to justify having Crawford at #1 with his lack of challenges, but it's just that I feel weird putting guys with under 20 fights as P4P #1s with…

Comment by Legends456 on 11-19-2019

[QUOTE=j.razor;20196240]1. Nelo 2. Bud 3. Keith 4. Errol 5. D.Wilder 6. Devin 7. l0m0 8. Fury 9. Plant 10. Bivol[/QUOTE] It’s a decent list, but I’d put Bud at number one. I also wouldn’t have Fury in the top ten…

Comment by UNBANNED on 11-19-2019

[QUOTE=aboutfkntime;20195878]P4P is subjective... and highly over-rated imo... Inoue leapfrogged Lomachenko, Crawford, and Canelo... after being exposed a little, by an old Donaire who dropped [B]TWO [/B]divisions in the last year-or-so? ... :thinking: I have him a solid #4 Usyk, I…

Comment by JOITATS on 11-18-2019

good list agree crawford should go down, based on his lack of challenge, and his best win being amir khan

Comment by Santa_ on 11-18-2019

[QUOTE=djbiancafrost;20196035]A WBA Super 130 belt that was supposed to be for ANDREW CANCIO. Cancio should be in line for that belt (well you know how the history of Machado's original belt was taken away by Gervonta).[/QUOTE] King Santa was the…

Top Headlines
Navarrete: It Was A Very Productive Year, 2020 Will Be Even Better Hearn: Joshua Has Been Chasing Wilder and Fury For Years! Joshua Ready For Usyk: Let's Rock and Roll Then, No Problem! Chris Eubank Jr: I've Landed in America, Time For Active 2020 Jermall Charlo Takes Down Dennis Hogan in Seven Hearn: They Wrote Joshua Off - Now He's The Division's Governor! Andy Ruiz: 3 Months of Partying, Celebrating Got Best of Me! Anthony Joshua Avenges Andy Ruiz Loss - HUGE Gallery Dillian Whyte Returns, Overcomes Tough Mariusz Wach Alexander Povetkin, Michael Hunter Battle To a Draw Hrgovic: I Want To Box in UK - Give Me Chisora or Whyte! Andy Ruiz's Trainer Reacts To Loss To Anthony Joshua Tony Bellew Reacts To Joshua's Win Over Ruiz Joshua: When Wilder, Fury, Usyk Are Really Ready - They Will Call Davison: Not Being Nasty, Joshua Was Like a Poor Man's Fury Anthony Joshua Reacts To Getting Revenge On Ruiz Andy Ruiz Reacts To His Loss To Anthony Joshua Lemieux Dropped Twice, Decks Bursak, Wins Split Decision Wilder: Joshua Was On His Bike, His Mentality Was To Survive! Emanuel Navarrete Blasts Out Horta in Four To Retain Title Jermall Charlo Drops Dennis Hogan Twice, Stops Him in Seven Jerwin Ancajas Takes Out Miguel Gonzalez in Six To Retain Jermall Charlo, Dennis Hogan - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Chris Eubank Jr. Wins in Two By TKO, Korobov Suffers Injury Chris Eubank Jr. vs. Matt Korobov - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Miguel Marriaga Stops Alfredo Mejia in Sixth Round Ryosuke Iwasa Drops, Stops Marlon Tapales in Eleventh Ellis Out-Works Aleem, Wins Majority Decision Hogan: Munguia Fight Is Behind Me, It's In The Past Hawton Edges Villalobos In Women's Rematch, Retains Title Joshua vs. Usyk Must Happen Within 180 Days, Says WBO Prez Anthony Joshua: I Knew I Would Correct My Wrongs! Charlo: Eubank Jr. Has To Talk Himself Into A Fight With Me Hogan: I Thought Munguia Would Give Me A Rematch Korobov: DeGale Didn't Take Eubank Seriously; Expected Easy Fight Charlo-Hogan - LIVE Results From Barclays Center Anthony Joshua vs. Andy Ruiz Rematch - CompuBox Punch Stats Charlo: Canelo Will Try 160 Again; I Want That Fight To Happen Anthony Joshua Boxes Past Andy Ruiz To Reclaim World Titles Diego Pacheco With Brutal Knockout of Selemani Saidi in One
Latest Forum Threads