Arum: What Was Judge Who Had Linares Ahead of Loma Watching?

By Keith Idec

NEW YORK – Bob Arum couldn’t believe what he heard.

When Vasiliy Lomachenko’s promoter learned his fighter was behind by two points on one scorecard entering that fateful 10th round Saturday night, Arum wondered how that was possible. Judge Robin Taylor had Linares ahead, 86-84, in what had been a very competitive, tactical lightweight title bout before Lomachenko stopped Linares with a body shot in the 10th round at Madison Square Garden.

Another judge, Steve Weisfeld, scored the fight for Lomachenko through nine rounds, 86-84. The third judge, Julie Lederman, had it even after nine rounds (85-85).

Lederman scored five rounds for Lomachenko and four rounds for Linares. She had it even entering the 10th round because Linares knocked down Lomachenko with a perfect straight right hand with 31 seconds remaining in the sixth round.

lomachenko-linares-fight (10)

Arum seemed to agree with Weisfeld’s scorecard. Weisfeld scored six rounds for Ukraine’s Lomachenko (11-1, 9 KOs) and three rounds for Venezuela’s Linares (44-4, 27 KOs).

“I gave Linares maybe three rounds – maybe,” Arum said. “That’s all I could find for him. But again, I’m prejudiced. I mean, the scorecard that had Linares ahead, what fight was the guy watching?”

New York’s Taylor actually is a woman who has worked numerous championship fights during her 16½-year career as a judge. She scored five rounds for Linares and four rounds for Lomachenko.

Not surprisingly, Lomachenko was much more diplomatic than Arum regarding the scoring of his fight.

“It’s not my job,” Lomachenko said during the post-fight press conference. “It’s not my work. I can’t comment [on] their job.”

The three-division champion also applauded Linares for giving him such a difficult fight.

According to unofficial CompuBox numbers, Lomachenko out-landed Linares by a very slim margin overall (213-of-627 to 207-of-739). CompuBox credited Linares for connecting on more power punches (139-of-359 to 101-of-237) and Lomachenko for landing more jabs (112-of-390 to 68-of-380). 

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Hot Shyt on 05-14-2018

I had it even after 9 and can definitely see the judges giving a close round I gave to Loma to Linares. No conspiracy here

Comment by Idunnoshet on 05-14-2018

I had the fight 5 (Loma) rounds to 4 (Linares) . IMO it Was a close fight . Was watching it with some Casual friends and remember telling them that Loma took a Couple of Hard punches. Then Bam !…

Comment by P4Pdunny on 05-14-2018

I had it even, it wasn't outlandish to suggest he may have been up at that time

Comment by Bronx2245 on 05-14-2018

I had it the same way Julie had it! Brilliant performance by both fighters!

Comment by Fightfitmk on 05-14-2018

It was definitely a close fight. Lots of punches blocked but could easily see how judges could have either fighter slightly ahead. Didn’t see anything controversial with the score cards. This was a great close fight with some excellent technical…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (63)
Top Headlines Pacquiao Wants Next Fight In U.S.; Arum Says Tax Debt Not $20M Horn's Promoter: Pacquiao's Win Proves He's Not Past It! Pacquiao: If Mayweather Comes Back - Let's Do a Second One! Pacquiao's Win Over Matthysse A Blessing And A Curse Atlas: Pacquiao Beat a Heavy Bag; Diminished Matthysse Quit! Pacquiao: Matthysse Was Hurt From The Punches, Looked Scared Pacquiao Says Buboy Warned Him To Avoid 'Marquez' Mistakes Jose Pedraza Expects a Very Tough Outing With Ray Beltran Manny Pacquiao: Do I Look Old? I'm Back! Lucas Matthysse is Not Sure About The Future of His Career Usyk: I Have No Fear of Fighting Murat Gassiev in Russia Jeff Horn Calls Out Manny Pacquiao For a Rematch Pacquiao: From Round 1, I Knew He Couldn't Handle My Power! Brandon Cook: Brook Fight is Off, Brook Has Ankle Injury Pacquiao Gives High Praise To Buboy as New Head Trainer RBF Exec: We Secured QF/SF Fights For The WBSS Season 2 Pacquiao: Like I Said - I'm Not Gone From Boxing, I'm Still Here! Photos: Pacquiao Crushes Matthysse For First KO Win Since 09 Photos: Regis Prograis Breaks Down Velasco For TKO, WBSS Slot Photos: Teofimo Lopez Beats Down, Stops William Silva Rocky Fielding: I'd Love An ECHO Arena Defense of WBA Title Philippines Prez Wants Pacquiao To Retire on Back of Big Win Matthysse: My Head is Raised, I Lost To a Legend in Pacquiao Manny Pacquiao: It Was a Long Time Ago Since I've Done That! Manny Pacquiao vs. Lucas Matthysse - CompuBox Punch Stats Pacquiao Knocks Matthysse Out in Seventh For WBA Belt Pacquiao vs. Matthysse - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Jhack Tepora Drops, Stops Edivaldo Ortega in Ninth Round Canizales KOs Bin in 12th Round, Retains Light Flyweight Title Mthalane Gets Off The Floor To Edge Waseem For IBF Title Regis Prograis Stops Juan Jose Velasco, Secures WBSS Spot Regis Prograis vs. Juan Jose Velasco - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Teofimo Lopez Drops Silva Three Times, Knocks Him Out In Sixth Manny Pacquiao-Lucas Matthysse: Stats & Stakes Velasco: Pressure's On Prograis; I'll Prove the Experts Wrong Rocky Fielding Blasts Out Tyron Zeuge in Five, Wins WBA Title Prograis-Velasco Undercard Results From New Orleans Zach Parker Gets Points Triumph In Germany, Moves To 16-0 Pacquiao's Last 6 Fights vs. Previous 10 - CompuBox Review RBF Exec Slams Usyk's Manager Over WBSS Event Comments

Latest Active Forum Threads