Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Arum: Judge Who Had Hart Over Smith Should Be Banned

ATLANTIC CITY – Bob Arum has a close relationship with Jesse Hart, who has been promoted by Arum’s company throughout his pro career.

Even Arum couldn’t believe one of the judges scored Hart the winner of his 10-round fight against Joe Smith Jr. on Saturday night. Arum tore into judge James Kinney after Kinney strangely scored Hart a 95-94 victor over Smith in a main event ESPN televised from Hard Rock Hotel & Casino’s Etess Arena.

“That judge should be banned from ever scoring a fight,” Arum said. “He should be investigated and banned. And I promote Hart! I mean, sh-t, how can you ever score that fight for Jesse Hart? I mean, it’s not even an argument.”

joe-smith-hart-fight (2)

Kinney scored six of the 10 rounds for Hart, but he was overruled by judges Eugene Grant and Joe Pasquale. Grant (97-92) and Pasquale (98-91) scored seven and eight rounds, respectively, for Smith, who dropped Hart in the seventh round and was the aggressor throughout their bout.

Philadelphia’s Hart (26-3, 21 KOs) spent much of a fight Smith clearly won moving away from the hard-hitting Smith and holding him. Hart showed toughness by making it to the final bell and avoiding the first knockout defeat of his career, but he even acknowledged afterward that Smith (25-3, 20 KOs) deserved to win.

“It was a terrific fight, a real good fight,” said Arum, whose company, Top Rank, now co-promotes Smith. “A fight like that is good for boxing because it’s an action fight. And then you have a god-damn judge who screws it all up. I mean, that’s horrible. I mean, one guy scores it [98-91], the other [97-92]. That’s what it was.”

CompuBox credited Smith for landing 36 more punches overall than Hart in its unofficial report (135-of-501 to 99-of-465). Smith landed more than twice as many power punches, according to CompuBox (115-of-350 to 54-of-186).

Smith knew he had beaten Hart, but the Mastic, New York, native admitted he got nervous when ring announcer Jimmy Lennon Jr. stated before revealing the scores that the result was a split decision.

“I was a little worried there,” Smith said. “I was very confident I was gonna get the decision. But the one judge made me a little nervous in there. But you know, just with the knockdown and the hard shots that I landed, I deserved it.”

The 63-year-old Kinney, of Woodbridge, New Jersey, began judging professional boxing in January 2015. He has worked fights in New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania over the past five years.

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Corelone on 01-13-2020

You boys don't know what you're looking at. That there is the new AJ school of boxing. Hart just didn't have a 20 foot ring to work with.

Comment by Tatabanya on 01-13-2020

[QUOTE=Deontay Wilder;20321084]Hart had the worst night of [B]his entire career[/B].[/QUOTE] Which doesn't amount to much to begin with.

Comment by Squ□redCircle34 on 01-13-2020

[QUOTE=The D3vil;20320714]Best sport in the world Worst judges, worst sanctioning bodies, worst promoters[/QUOTE] If I could green k you i absolutely would! Fantastic and agreeable post!

Comment by PunchyPotorff on 01-13-2020

Not an Arum fan, but he's right. Lame judge who needs to be banned from boxing permanently. No excuse for that ignorant b.s.

Comment by YoungManRumble on 01-12-2020

[QUOTE=ShoulderRoll;20320598]Hart is a Top Rank fighter. Arum probably had that judge on the payroll and is now trying to deflect any suspicion. :lol1:[/QUOTE] This. I don't agree with a lot of things you say but this certainly seems like Bob…

Top Headlines
Santana On Huge Hurd: Size Isn't Always Everything Whyte: We Made Ruiz an Offer, But Chocolate is More Important To Him Redkach: I'm Gonna Surprise A Lot Of People In Garcia Fight Hurd Thought Williams Would 'Walk Through' Rosario Garcia: Redkach Fought Well, But Alexander Can't Take Punch Anymore Unimpressed Stephen Fulton: I'm A Huge Step Up For Khegai Redkach: Garcia's Counting On Tune-Up; I'll Knock Him Out! Hurd: Former Trainer Was Family; His Decision To Walk Away Danny Garcia: I Can't Overlook Redkach; I Know He’s Hungry Tyson Fury: I Never Had Energy To Finish Wilder In First Fight Daily Bread Mailbag: Josh Taylor, Tyson vs. Ruddock, More Jono Carroll Confident Of Toppling Scott Quigg Blane Hyland Back, March 7 In Manchester Hearn: I Think Fury is The Favorite in Wilder Rematch Joshua: If Up To Me - I'd Fight Usyk, Wilder-Fury Winner in 2020 McKenna: Angelo Dundee Couldn't Help Ohara Davies Beat Me As Hurd Returns, Lubin Wants To Restore Order To Crazy Division Joshua: For Legacy and History, The Wilder Fight Will Definitely Happen Alejandra Jimenez: I've Never Used Illegal Drugs - It's a Mistake! Ricardo Mayorga Recovering After Severe Beating By Robbers Alejandra Jimenez Tests Positive For Banned Substances Robles: Andy Ruiz's Father Said They'd Be With Me Until The End! Former 10x National Champion Kahshad Elliott Inks With Split-T Sampson: Josh Taylor-Khongsong Will Land in Great Britain or Scotland Stephen Fulton, Arnold Khegai - Ready For Scrap Jarrett Hurd, Francisco Santana - Set For Battle Danny Garcia, Ivan Redkach - Ready For War at Barclays Fury Trainer Steward: Davison Was Supposed To Be Part of Team Josh Taylor vs. Khonsong: Sampson Boxing Outbids Top Rank Alexis Rocha- Brad Solomon Added To Garcia-Fonseca Card Kell Brook: My Dream Fight? An Errol Spence Rematch! Anthony Fowler Joins Shane McGuigan After Coldwell Split Teixeira vs. Castano: WBO Orders Purse Bid, Jan. 29 In Miami Jason Quigley Calls Out Jaime Munguia For Next Fight Ryan Garcia: I Was Fragile Back In the Day, Now I'm Physically Stronger Fury: Andy Ruiz Should Train With Me If He Wants Titles Back Parker's Trainer Breaks Down The Wilder vs. Fury Rematch Chantelle Cameron Eyes Katie Taylor, Jessica McCaskill in 2020 Jumah Mandatory For Riakporhe After Hyde Win In Wythenshawe Scott Quigg Returns To Trainer Joe Gallagher Ahead Of Carroll Clash
Latest Forum Threads