Wilder Isn't a Particularly Good Boxer … But He's Good Enough


By Michael Rosenthal

Some people I respect speak of Deontay Wilder as if he violates the sanctity of the sport’s traditional glamour division.

“Worst boxer in history among heavyweight titleholders,” one has said of Wilder, who defends his WBC title against Dominic Breazeale on Saturday in Brooklyn. “Crude boxer at best,” other, more generous observers might say. “All he has is his punching power,” is one more common refrain.

Like most opinions, these are at least slight exaggerations. It’s true that Wilder has limited skills, which is no surprise given that he started boxing at 20 years old. And, yes, his power is his not-so-secret weapon.

That acknowledged, he’s also a good athlete (particularly for his 6-foot-7 frame) who uses whatever boxing acumen he has to set up the shots that have given him 39 knockouts in 40 victories. He must be doing something right. As former Wilder opponent Gerald Washington told me, “You can’t argue with his resume.”

And it’s not as if he has been ducking challenges, such as they are in the heavyweight division these days. Wilder last year took on two of the most-respected active big men, Luis Ortiz and Tyson Fury. He stopped the former in a thrilling brawl that tested his resilience, his finest victory, and he was fortunate to emerge with a draw in the latter fight.

Wilder also has tried to make a fight with his most natural rival, Anthony Joshua. If there is a benevolent boxing god, that fight will happen one day soon.

The critics would cite his performance against Fury as an example of Wilder’s ineptitude. The WBC titleholder was able to knock Fury down in the ninth and 12th rounds – the second time in brutal fashion – but otherwise he was outboxed by a more skillful fighter.

It would be difficult to defend Wilder. He DID struggle against Fury. I remember telling someone in disgust immediately after what I thought was a boring fight until the knockdowns, “Man, Wilder just reinforced everything his critics say about him. That was a really bad look for him.”

deontay-wilder (3)_18

One thing, though: Fury dominated the great (but aging) Wladimir Klitschko more thoroughly than he did Wilder. The point is that Fury, a remarkable athlete and superb boxer for his size, has the ability to make anyone look bad as long as he stays on his feet. That could include Joshua one day.

And Wilder has an explanation, if you will, for his performance: He was trying too hard to knock out Fury. Once he stopped pressing, the knockdowns – and near-knockout – came.

That’s exactly how Eric Molina, another Wilder victim, saw it.

“One thing about Wilder, when he tries too hard to throw the right hand, you can see it coming,” Molina said. “He was desperate to knock Fury out. Fury is too slick for the wide shots (Wilder) was throwing. He saw them coming. To land against Fury you have to throw clean, precise shots that are set up with a different rhythm. Those were the punches that landed in the end.

“I think Wilder knows that now. In the rematch, he knocks out Fury in six to eight rounds.”

The bottom line for Wilder is that he can hurt any heavyweight, even when he struggles. It only takes one punch because of his power. That’s the primary reason he has been successful. It’s also the reason he is fun to watch, at least for most of us.

If you require your biggest punchers to also be special boxers, then Wilder isn’t for you. I get that. I preferred the memorable series between Marco Antonio Barrera and Erik Morales to that of Arturo Gatti and Micky Ward because the Mexicans combined action with a higher level of skill.

But I, like a zillion others, enjoyed the Gatti-Ward battles. I accepted the fact that neither had polished skills and focused on the compelling mayhem they produced, which was something to behold.

That’s more or less how I approach Wilder. I accept the fact that he isn’t a particularly good boxer and focus on what he brings to the ring – crazy knockouts.

I’ll always admire sublime technicians like Floyd Mayweather but a knockout artist like Wilder taps into a more primal desire for all-out war. In other words, fans want knockouts and Wilder delivers them. Simple as that.

Wilder probably will never be considered one of the best heavyweights in history because of his deficiencies but he does two things: He wins and he entertains. That’s something.

Michael Rosenthal was the 2018 winner of the Boxing Writers Association of America’s Nat Fleischer Award for excellence in boxing journalism. He has covered boxing in Los Angeles and beyond for almost three decades. Follow him at @mrosenthal_box.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by JWHardin on 05-19-2019

[QUOTE=bronx7;19751923]George Foreman underrated punishing jab. Used it often and to set up other power punches .[/QUOTE] I watched Foreman many times. His jab was ok, with power behind it, but not great by any means. Larry Holmes had a great…

Comment by Eff Pandas on 05-19-2019

[QUOTE=Brettcappe;19757158]I get the logic. I won some nice dough on the Kentucky Derby but lost on the Preakness. Only bet the horse for win/place and he came in third. I always look for "live" dogs but I didn't think Breazeale…

Comment by Brettcappe on 05-19-2019

[QUOTE=Eff Pandas;19754861]Fortune favors the bold with betting. Scared money & fanboy money don't make money. And while I'm no JimGunn or Jas, I'm profitable & I'm cool with that. Look man you probably don't bet as much as I do…

Comment by jaded on 05-19-2019

[QUOTE=Eff Pandas;19754861]Fortune favors the bold with betting. Scared money & fanboy money don't make money. And while I'm no JimGunn or Jas, I'm profitable & I'm cool with that. Look man you probably don't bet as much as I do…

Comment by Eff Pandas on 05-18-2019

[QUOTE=jaded;19754535]But Breazeale is terrible and very easy to hit. He never had a chance...I wouldn't have put a nickel on him.[/QUOTE] Fortune favors the bold with betting. Scared money & fanboy money don't make money. And while I'm no JimGunn…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (53)
Top Headlines Ohara Davies: My Aim is To KO Miguel Vazquez in Three Rounds Roach Plans To Have Pacquiao Test Thurman in The First Round Hearn: I'll Be Absolutely Sh*ting Myself During Ruiz vs. Joshua II Vergil Ortiz vs. Antonio Orozco in Play For 8/10 in Texas on DAZN Commey Sees Beltran as 'Big Opportunity' To Get His Name Out Golden Boy Prez: Canelo Has Options, GGG is Not Most Deserving! Lara vs. Soro Ordered For WBA Belt, Castano Officially Removed Briedis vs. Dorticos Will Have Vacant WBC Title at Stake Ceja Files Protest With WBC Over Stoppage Loss To Rigondeaux Charlo-Cota Main Event Averaged 1,832,000 Viewers For FOX Lomachenko vs. Campbell Agreement Reached, Says WBC Whyte Reacts To Usyk Being Mandatory: Boxing is Full of Sh*t! Andrade: GGG Beat #81 in The World Rolls, I'm Fighting Real Guys! Miguel Vazquez: I'm Supremely Confident I'll Beat Ohara Davies Kal Yafai: Jimenez First - But Then I Need a Massive Fight Next Shakur Stevenson vs. Franklin Manzanilla Set Down For July 13 Acosta May Have To Wait, Soto Could Get Hit With Mandatory Parker: I Know I Can Beat Ruiz A Lot Clearer If We Have Rematch Photos: Demetrius Andrade, Sulecki - Face To Face at State House Photos: Amir Khan Grinds Hard in Camp For Goyat Clash Wladimir Klitschko Rescued After Yacht Catches Fire in Spain Tony Luis Edges Adrian Estrella With Majority Decisions Win Herring Keeping Options Open While Negotiating Mandatory Mikey Garcia's Coach Believes Lomachenko Fight is Still Possible Pacquiao: Thurman Reminds Me of The Miguel Cotto Fight Photos: Pacquiao Continues To Look Fierce in Camp For Thurman BoxingScene Championship Stats, Records: June 2019 Update Gorman: When I Beat Daniel Dubois, What Will He Say Then? Hearn: Anthony Joshua vs. Andy Ruiz Rematch Will Be Massive Lee Selby's Coach: No Issue Fighting Adrien Broner in The U.S. Dawejko Received Death Threats Over Joshua Sparring Rumors Suddenly Violent Rigondeaux Renews Case For 122 Supremacy Adrien Broner vs. Lee Selby in The Works For Later This Year Rey Vargas Expects Fireworks, Vows To Turn Back Tomoki Kameda Andres Gutierrez Edges Tomas Rojas For WBC Regional Title Juan Manuel Marquez Returns To The Ring - As a Promoter McGregor Was Very Pleased That Lobov Defeated Malignaggi Tramaine Williams vs. Neil John Tabanao on Chad Dawson Card Khan: Hopefully Pacquiao Beats Up Thurman, Then We Can Fight! Warren Fires Back at Hearn, Rolls Eyes at Matchroom DAZN Shows

Latest Active Forum Threads