Shawn Porter-Danny Garcia: Afterthoughts

by Cliff Rold

It wasn’t a classic but every good fight doesn’t have to be.

Sometimes good is good enough.

That’s what we got Saturday night in Shawn Porter’s win over Danny Garcia. It wasn’t always pretty but it was competitive throughout and demanded attention from anyone viewing from the first bell to the last.

porter-garcia-fight (67)

It was the sort of fight where swing rounds were plenty. Porter threw a lot, and landed a little bit, more. Garcia showed his uncanny ability to slip home left hook counters but had to endure a nasty body attack that at times was some of the sharpest work Porter has done in recent memory. Round four in particular, where Porter really started to come on, was some of the best work of his career.

In the end, activity and consistency of attack carried the day. Now Porter looks ahead to what could be the toughest night of his career.

Let’s get into it.

The Future for Porter: For Porter, the future may come down to one name: Errol Spence. He said it would be the easiest negotiation ever after the fight. Time will tell on that one. The new WBC champ at welterweight, and the reigning IBF titlist, fight under the same PBC umbrella so want to fight should be enough. Porter’s record really reads now like a who’s who at welterweight over the last five or so years and Spence is well in line with his willingness to take on anyone he can. Spence is bigger, fresher, and more athletic than anyone Porter has faced to date. Porter would be the second best opponent of Spence’s still developing career. Can Porter’s awkward approach and body work undo the aspirations of Spence? We’ll probably find out by the first quarter of 2019.      

The Future for Garcia: Garcia felt he did enough to win and that’s fine but he doesn’t have much room to complain about scores. He’s benefited from close calls, sometimes with controversy, and the tight ones won’t always go your way. Garcia is in a tough spot with Porter-Spence likely. Where does he go from here? A Yordenis Ugas, victorious on the undercard, is a high risk/lower reward calculus than he’s been used to. Andre Berto seems to get the call fairly often for in-between action from the PBC and may make sense. Garcia can also hope for a rematch with Keith Thurman sometime after Thurman returns to action as he may be the biggest name available for “One Time.” Garcia is far from low on options but defeat changes what they are. 

Cliff’s Notes

Superfly 3 was the least of the HBO cards in the division so far but it had it’s moments…Kazuto Ioka looked as good as he has in his career and wears 115 lbs. well. He doesn’t replace Naoya Inoue in the class but he adds back some of the depth Inoue’s exit took away. This is still one of boxing’s deepest divisions…Donnie Nietes probably deserved the win over Aston Palicte but he looked older, slower, and small in the new class. Nietes may be a case of a fighter who waited too long to make a move at a lasting impression on the global stage…Juan Francisco Estrada won going away against Felipe Orucuta but it was his most flat outing since Jobert Alvarez. Was it a hangover from two hard fights in a row or was his eye a little off the ball against a lesser foe? His next fight will tell us more.

Rold Picks 2018: 30-12 (Including SuperFly 3 Picks)

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at [email protected]

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by JcLazyX210 on 09-11-2018

[QUOTE=dibzvincent143;19088968]Trout should be able to box him using his size, range and length. Garcia ain’t big at welter and more so at 154. Trout’s losses are against full blown powerful 154lbers yet he still hasn’t been laid flat by any…

Comment by dibzvincent143 on 09-11-2018

[QUOTE=JcLazyX210;19088878]The only way Garcia can make little TWEAKS is for him to drop his daddy and get a real trainer. At 30 years old he should had done this a long time ago. I don't see him improving anymore under…

Comment by JcLazyX210 on 09-11-2018

[QUOTE=dibzvincent143;19088859]He hasn’t really outgrown welter yet so it really make no sense. Maybe if they’re struggling then they’re just saying they’re open for that move. What would you rather be? Be relevant in top level fights at welter? Or fighting…

Comment by dibzvincent143 on 09-11-2018

[QUOTE=JcLazyX210;19088826]I mean his dad says they are considering moving up so it's not really up to us. I personally think he can fight select people at 154 not at world level. Like maybe trout. At 147 I think it's a…

Comment by JcLazyX210 on 09-11-2018

[QUOTE=dibzvincent143;19087624]Nah if he can’t be effective at 147, what business will he do at 154. Guys would just walk to him and break that chin without worrying much in return. Add the fact that he’s not exactly a mover. I…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (23)
Top Headlines Pacquiao: I Think Fans Are Excited For Rematch With Mayweather Adonis Stevenson Hopes Pascal Wins, Not Impressed By Bivol David Lemieux: I Want Canelo Because I Know I Can Beat Him! Ellerbe: Broner Will Look To Defy The Odds, Shut Everyone Up Vijender Singh Inks Promotional Pact With Top Rank News: Christopher Diaz, Bryant Perrella, Tori Nelson, Luis Lebron Hearn: Hooker is The Standout at 140, I Want Defense in Dallas Broner: F*** The Money, I'm Not Just Coming To Get a Check Photos: Manny Pacquiao, Adrien Broner - Face To Face in NYC Broner: Pacquiao Ain't Fighting Floyd, I'm Gonna Beat His Ass! Photos: Canelo Grinding Hard For Rocky Fielding Title Clash Pacquiao Confirms He'll Work With Roach Again For Broner Bout Pacquiao Warns Broner: I've Learned To 'Problem Solve' in Politics Canelo on GGG Win: Nicest Feeling To Shut Mouths With Facts! Claressa Shields vs. Femke Hermans Set, December 8 on HBO Ganigan Lopez Tops Telemundo Card in Mexico City Yves Ngabu vs. Micki Nielsen Finalized For February 16, Belgium Nathan Gorman vs. Alex Leapai Set For Warrington-Frampton LIVE STREAM: Pacquiao vs. Broner - NYC Press Conference Bivol: Alvarez KO Of Kovalev Surprised Me, Favor Him In Rematch Ugas Confident of Winning WBC Belt - Surprising Porter, Critics Hurd: I Would Beat Both Charlos, Canelo and Golovkin! Joseph Parker: After Flores, Hopefully I'll Be Fighting in The UK's Television Pick of The Week - Nov. 19 Photos: Manny Pacquiao Hits New York For Broner Presser Kieran Smith Ready For Step Up in Class With Peter McDonagh WBC Prez: I Hope Golovkin vs. Charlo Eliminator Will Happen Frampton: Warrington is Made For Me - I'll Prove I'm Better Canelo Says His Coach Felt Fielding Was Perfect Foe at 168 Juan Francisco Estrada Year-End Ring Return Ruled Out Pascal Can Take Legacy To A New Level With Win Over Bivol De La Hoya: If I Train For 3 Months - I Can Get in With The Best! Claressa Shields: I'm The Greatest Woman of All-Time! Photos: David Lemieux, Yves Ulysse Presser For Canelo-Fielding Thomas Valdez Shocks Luis Coria With Split Decision Win Chavez Jr. Admits To Abusing Drugs, Alcohol After Martinez Loss Brandon Rios: If Hearn Presents a Title Shot Next - I'm There! Photos: Jean Pascal in Top Form, Grinds For Dmitry Bivol Clash Anvar Yunusov Stops Jose Salinas in Seventh Round Jarrell Miller: If No Joshua - I'd Fight Whyte, Chisora, Allen or Price!

Latest Active Forum Threads