Pacquiao-Broner: Aging Legend vs. Elite Gatekeeper

By Peter Lim

Public persona-wise, Pacquiao versus Broner plays out like an ultimate good-versus-evil battle. The personification of sportsmanship, Pacquiao has always been respectful, diplomatic and humble in and out of the ring. Broner, on the other hand, is a profanity-spewing, tantrum-throwing villain in the sport. The quintessential antihero, his schtick has always been to sell more tickets to fans who want to see him lose than win.

One is a lawbreaker and the other a lawmaker. Broner’s bad boy image encompasses much-publicized reports ranging from public intoxication to pubic lice and beyond. His run-ins with the law involved domestic violence, gunfire and bowling alley brawls. Pacquiao was elected as a congressman and senator, and given his immense popularity in the Philippines, many have speculated that the presidency lies in his near or distant future.

But in the ring, Pacquiao (60-7-2, 39 KOs) versus Broner (33-3-1, 24 KOs) is a 50-50 tossup at this juncture in their respective careers.

pacquiao-broner (7)_2

Nobody, not even the most die-hard Pacquiao fan, is kidding himself that he is anywhere near his heyday that spanned roughly from 2002-2012. The question is, at age 40 has he retained enough skills, speed, savvy and fire in his belly still to be a major player in the welterweight division, which just happens to be the most talent-rich division in the sport today?

Broner might be the perfect mettle detector to answer that question.

Broner, 29, might have been an elite fighter in the 130- and 135-pound divisions. But at 140 and 147, he has been relegated to an elite and high-profile gatekeeper. He barely beat Paul Malignaggi, who was already on a downslide, and fellow gatekeeper Adrian Granados.

But Broner faltered against every elite fighter he has faced above 140. He was dropped twice and outslugged by Marcos Maidana in 2013, outhuscled by Shawn Porter in 2015 and outclassed by Mikey Garcia in 2017. He was competitive in spurts in those fights but he clearly lost.

In his last fight, Broner struggled to a draw against Jesse Vargas, a former caretaker titleholder who was decisively dethroned by Pacquiao in 2016. As their common, Vargas might seem like a good gauge as to how Pacquiao-Broner might play out, but Pacquiao appears to be a diminished version of the fighter who handily defeated Vargas three years ago.

In 2017 Pacquiao lost a highly controversial decision to Australian Jeff Horn in Australia. But even if he had won the fight on the scorecards, as most observers thought he did, it was still a struggle against an obscure 16-0 fighter who had little trouble finding his mark on Pacquiao’s previously-elusive head. Horn’s subsequent lopsided stoppage loss to Terrence Crawford suggests that he’s more ordinary than exceptional.

Pacquiao was dominant in stopping Lucas Matthysse in his only fight in 2018 but Matthysse seemed to be just through the motions in a glorified sparring session. Matthysse’s retirement announcement after the bout seemed to confirm the 36-year-old Argentine was simply cashing out on a rock-em, sock-em 14-year career.

Both Pacquiao and Broner are formidable punchers but both are also relatively easy to hit at this point in their careers, so will the outcome hinge on which fighter is first to find his range and capitalize on it?

Pacquiao has reinvented himself several times since turning pro as a malnourished 106-pound 15-year-old, winning world titles in seven divisions from 112-147, but in the fourth decade of his life, can he turn back the clock enough to outmaneuver and/or overpower a cocky, competent adversary 11 years his junior?

Will Broner remain on course as an underachieving fighter who never met his full potential or will he step up and pull out a career-defining victory against an all-time great?

Read prediction of Pac-Broner at:

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Curtis Harper on 01-20-2019

The word ''elite'' got dumped on :(

Comment by hitking on 01-19-2019

This title is perfect for this fight. It still amazes me that Broner is able to generate buzz. Either way, this fight is all about Manny, and where he is at this stage of his career. If he’s able to…

Comment by Roadblock on 01-19-2019

Title is wrong Broner is not elite anything .

Comment by radiotracer on 01-19-2019

[QUOTE=Terrell1555;19443799]Who would have ever thought they would see Manny fighting under a Mayweather promotion banner not against Floyd? And MFs question Floyd’s intelligence. Smart move Money![/QUOTE] I think he’s fighting under Al Haymon.

Comment by R.KHLMS4LIFE on 01-19-2019

Pacquiao clearly beat horn, you can't go to decision in people backyard it was ask fury as well as GGG in the first Canelo fight. Pacquiao beat Bradley the first fight as well. Pacquiao was beating Marquez til Marquez with…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (19)
Top Headlines Brandon Rios Expects Very Tough Fight With Humberto Soto Ergashev: Fox is Tall, Good Boxer - But I'm Knocking Im Out! Mikaela Mayer Continues To Clear Obstacles In The Pro Ranks Weights: Santa Cruz-Rivera Ready, Molina-Figueroa Weight Bump Gilberto Ramirez Wants 175 Debut, Then Sergey Kovalev Fight Rene Alvarado Was Very Surprised That Cancio Stopped Machado Whyte: No Shock if Jarrell Miller Upsets Anthony Joshua Promoter Salita Sees Hard-Hitting Ergashev As The Next Golovkin Photos: Chisora Begins Working Relationship With Dave Coldwell Hekkie Budler Hooks Up With MTK With Aim of World Title Teofimo Lopez, Top Rank in Pursuit of WBC Title in 2019 WBC Prez To Rule On Mikey Garcia's Title After Spence Fight Photos: Chris Eubank Jr. Training in Beast Mode For DeGale Warren Rips Hearn, Says He's To Blame For Joshua's Fallouts News: Adam Lopez, Havnaa Title Shot, Chantelle Cameron Update Mayweather Says Another Exhibition Being Lined Up For July Jarrell Miller Vows To Crush Joshua Like Tyson Did Frank Bruno AIBA Head Urges IOC To End Boxing Freeze For Olympic Games Santa Cruz Sad For Mares; Would Quit For Family If It Were Him Spence: If I Beat Garcia The Way I Plan, I'll Be The Guy in The Sport Jose Ramirez Shoots Down Trash Talk From Regis Prograis Photos: Shohjahon Ergashev vs. Mykal Fox - ShoBox Weights Photos: Rob Brant, Khasan Baysangurov - Ready For Title Battle Photos: Omar Figueroa, John Molina - Face To Face, Final Presser Photos: Leo Santa Cruz, Rafael Rivera - Face To Face, Final Presser Miller Co-Promoter: Joshua is Not The Same Since Klitschko Fight Abel Ramos vs. Francisco Santana Added To Porter-Ugas Card ESPN Weights From Minnesota: Brant 158.6, Baysangurov 158.8 Plant-Lee In Works For This Summer In Chicago Area Or Nashville Badou Jack To Launch Promotional Company Errol Spence vs. Mikey Garcia: Fox Sports Pay-Per-View Information Sergey Kovalev Would Have No Problem With Facing Callum Smith Filip Hrgovic To Make United States Debut In May DAZN's Skipper: Joshua Has Star Potential Of LeBron & Ronaldo Hernandez Aims To Elevate Hometown Like Crawford Did For His Filip Hrgovic, Sauerland Ink Co-Promotional Pact With Hearn Lubin’s Coach Wants Fighter Back in May or June, Then Title Fight Miller: That Punk Joshua Made Mistake; Getting Run The Hell Over! Photos: DeGale Continues To Grind Hard For Eubank Showdown McWilliams Arroyo Set For Return Under Miguel Cotto Banner

Latest Active Forum Threads