NYSAC Doctor Explains Controversial Benavidez-Ntetu Stoppage

by David P. Greisman

The end of Saturday night’s fight between super middleweight prospects David Benavidez and Francy Ntetu ended controversially, with referee Shada Murdaugh stepping in and waving things off when Ntetu did not appear to be badly hurt.

Ntetu had been hit by a right hand and grabbed ahold of Benavidez when the fight was halted in the seventh round. The crowd booed loudly at the time, then amped up their volume as replays were shown.

Murdaugh rushed back to a dressing room, but he said he stopped the fight “at the recommendation of the doctor.” He said Barry Jordan, who is the chief medical officer for the New York State Athletic Commission, had made the recommendation.

006_David_Benavidez (720x480)_1

“He was taking a lot of punishment to the eye. It was on the recommendation of the doctor. I don’t really want to say that on camera,” Murdaugh said, before turning to this reporter’s video camera to speak. When told by the other reporter in the room, Showtime Jim’s Gray, that he needed to say that to the network’s cameras, Murdaugh apologized and walked away. Commission inspectors then asked Gray and this reporter to leave the room.

Tom Hoover, the commission’s chairman, also refused to speak to reporters at the time as he walked into the room.

Jordan, via a commission member, declined to speak with He did speak with Gray, however. Gray told that Jordan confirmed he had recommended the fight be stopped [or perhaps that the referee think of stopping it soon] because Ntetu was taking too much punishment.

Jordan and the referee did speak after the sixth round, according to Tom Gerbasi of

“I don’t get it,” said promoter Lou DiBella, who has Ntetu in his stable. “To be honest, it looked like Benavidez was running out of gas. Ntetu hurt him in that round. He was outlanding him. He had the best round of that fight.”

After six rounds, one judge had it 59-55 for Benavidez while the other two had it 58-56. The bout was scheduled for eight rounds.

Benavidez moves to 15-0 with 14 KOs. Ntetu falls to 16-1 with 3 KOs.

Pick up a copy of David’s book, “Fighting Words: The Heart and Heartbreak of Boxing,” at or internationally at Send questions/comments via email at [email protected]

Tags: David Benavidez image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by nycsmooth on 06-27-2016

NSAC right behind DC & NV as the worst in US....

Comment by tostao on 06-26-2016

Smb has to hold corrupt commissions and refs and judges accountable , boxing is supposed to be a sport , not a fraud . They have to report to smb after each show , every suspicious fight has to be…

Comment by ShoulderRoll on 06-26-2016

There's a disturbing pattern of commissions and other people in positions of power acting like they don't have to talk to the press or answer to the public. They don't want transparency, it's a bother to them.

Comment by glenn mcrory on 06-26-2016


Post a Comment - View More User Comments (4)
Top Headlines Cano in Line For a Big Fight, Linares Heading Back To 135 Curtis Stevens Heading To 154: Eyes Hurd, Lara, Harrison, Munguia Pulev vs. Helenius Clash Still Be Worked Out For Crawford-Khan Broner: I'll Be Back; All You Motherf***ers Will Still Tune In! Manny Pacquiao vs. Adrien Broner: CompuBox By The Numbers Gvozdyk To Take Voluntary Before Mandatory Versus Browne Pacquiao To Have Scratched Cornea Re-Examined Monday In L.A. Andrade: I Want Golovkin Next, To Prove I'm #1 at Middleweight Hearn: Don't Be Surprised if Joshua is on DAZN in the US in June Broner: Ain’t Got Mark On Me; They Thought They’d F*** Me Up Pacquiao: I Was Surprised Broner Didn't Throw Lot Of Punches Manny Pacquiao-Adrien Broner: Afterthoughts Broner Falls Very Short on Promised 'New Beginning' For Career Luis Coria Win Big in First Garcia Brothers Promoted Card Badou Jack Gets Stitched Up, Has No Excuses Over Loss Manny Pacquiao Says Injury To His Left Eye is Not Serious Manny Pacquiao Dishes Out Adrien Broner's Comeuppance Pacquiao's LA Home is Burglarized a Day After Broner Win Claressa Shields: Anybody Who Thinks Broner Won is Crazy! Video: Shawn Porter Reacts To Pacquiao Defeating Broner Video: Buboy Reacts To Pacquiao Defeating Adrien Broner Video: Mayweather Sr. Throws Shade at Adrien Broner For Loss Pacquiao: We Can't Blame Broner For Thinking He Won Fight Former Champ Gamache Assaulted on Street By Mystery Man Video: Roy Jones Jr. Reacts To Pacquiao Defeating Broner Video: Devin Haney Reacts To Pacquiao Defeating Broner Video: Daniel Jacobs Discusses Canelo Alvarez Fight WBO To Review Saunders Suspension, Could Be in Line For Andrade Video: Adrien Broner Explains Why He Beat Manny Pacquiao Video: Mikey Garcia Reacts To Pacquio's Win Over Broner Video: Pacquiao Reacts To Win Over Broner, Wanting Mayweather Gervonta Davis Embraces Challenge of Fight in Mares' Backyard Ellerbe: Mayweather’s Retired; 'No Interest' In Pacquiao Rematch Wilder-Fury Rematch Could Land on April 27 or May, Says Warren Kell Book Looks at Jeff Horn, Jessie Vargas, Smith as Options Marcus Browne Dares Teddy Atlas: Bring Me Oleksandr Gvozdyk! Pacquiao Open To Rematch, Mayweather Remains Noncommital Photos: Manny Pacquiao Dominates Broner - MONSTER Gallery Photos: Marcus Browne Decisions a Bloody Badou Jack Photos: Nordine Oubaali Beats Rau'shee Warren, Wins WBC Belt

Latest Active Forum Threads