NYSAC Doctor Explains Controversial Benavidez-Ntetu Stoppage

by David P. Greisman

The end of Saturday night’s fight between super middleweight prospects David Benavidez and Francy Ntetu ended controversially, with referee Shada Murdaugh stepping in and waving things off when Ntetu did not appear to be badly hurt.

Ntetu had been hit by a right hand and grabbed ahold of Benavidez when the fight was halted in the seventh round. The crowd booed loudly at the time, then amped up their volume as replays were shown.

Murdaugh rushed back to a dressing room, but he said he stopped the fight “at the recommendation of the doctor.” He said Barry Jordan, who is the chief medical officer for the New York State Athletic Commission, had made the recommendation.

006_David_Benavidez (720x480)_1

“He was taking a lot of punishment to the eye. It was on the recommendation of the doctor. I don’t really want to say that on camera,” Murdaugh said, before turning to this reporter’s video camera to speak. When told by the other reporter in the room, Showtime Jim’s Gray, that he needed to say that to the network’s cameras, Murdaugh apologized and walked away. Commission inspectors then asked Gray and this reporter to leave the room.

Tom Hoover, the commission’s chairman, also refused to speak to reporters at the time as he walked into the room.

Jordan, via a commission member, declined to speak with He did speak with Gray, however. Gray told that Jordan confirmed he had recommended the fight be stopped [or perhaps that the referee think of stopping it soon] because Ntetu was taking too much punishment.

Jordan and the referee did speak after the sixth round, according to Tom Gerbasi of

“I don’t get it,” said promoter Lou DiBella, who has Ntetu in his stable. “To be honest, it looked like Benavidez was running out of gas. Ntetu hurt him in that round. He was outlanding him. He had the best round of that fight.”

After six rounds, one judge had it 59-55 for Benavidez while the other two had it 58-56. The bout was scheduled for eight rounds.

Benavidez moves to 15-0 with 14 KOs. Ntetu falls to 16-1 with 3 KOs.

Pick up a copy of David’s book, “Fighting Words: The Heart and Heartbreak of Boxing,” at or internationally at Send questions/comments via email at [email protected]

Tags: David Benavidez image  
User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by nycsmooth on 06-27-2016

NSAC right behind DC & NV as the worst in US....

Comment by tostao on 06-26-2016

Smb has to hold corrupt commissions and refs and judges accountable , boxing is supposed to be a sport , not a fraud . They have to report to smb after each show , every suspicious fight has to be…

Comment by ShoulderRoll on 06-26-2016

There's a disturbing pattern of commissions and other people in positions of power acting like they don't have to talk to the press or answer to the public. They don't want transparency, it's a bother to them.

Comment by glenn mcrory on 06-26-2016


Post a Comment - View More User Comments (4)
Top Headlines Arias Vows To Beat Down and Bloody Rosado For "Bitch" Claim Karl Dargan Returns To Action on Bivol vs. Pascal Card Tyson Fury Secures Freddie Roach To Be in Corner For Wilder Mark Heffron vs. Liam Williams on Warrington-Frampton Card WBA Won't Strip Charr; Miller-Dinu Unlikely To Be Title Fight Bivol: I'm Confident That I'll Make a Statement With Pascal Filip Hrgovic vs. Ytalo Perea on December 8t in Zagreb Santa Cruz: To Prove I'm The Best at 126 - I Have To Beat Russell Danny Garcia Backs Adrien Broner To Upset Manny Pacquiao Errol Spence: I Don't Think Keith Thurman Will Ever Fight Me Frampton: If I Beat Warrington - I Want Another Champion Next Charlo Brothers Promise Fireworks, Explosive Wins in Barclays Warrington-Frampton: Nathan Gorman, Arthur, Wright Added Darren Tetley Looks To Bigger Things After Warburton Win Fielding Motivated By Fear, Doubters To Topple Canelo Hosea Burton: I'd Love To Punch Anthony Yarde's Face In! Canelo Feels Mikey Garcia Has a Very Tough Task With Spence Josh Warrington Sees Flaws To Exploit in Oscar Valdez Hooker Warns: I Can Do Some Real Damage To Saucedo's Career! Spence: People Think Garcia is Crazy - This is a Legacy Fight Photos: Danny Garcia, Figueroa-Molina, Uzcategui-Plant - Presser Photos: Porter-Ugas, Santa Cruz-Flores, Dirrell-Yildirim - Presser Photos: Spence-Garcia, Thurman-Lopez, Quillin-Truax - Presser Mikey Garcia on Spence: This Time Little Guy Beats Bigger Man! Keith Thurman: I'm Back, I Plan on Reclaiming My WBC Belt! Premier Boxing Champions, FOX Sports Reveal 2019 Schedule Peterson-Lipinets, Quillin-Truax To Headline FS1 Shows News: Antonio Vargas, Anvar Yunusov, Jean Carlos Torres Jarrell Miller is Interested in Facing Whyte-Chisora 2 Winner Gilberto Ramirez, Jesse Hart Promise a War on December 14 Spence-Garcia To Be Announced As FOX PPV March 16 Gennady Golovkin is 'No. 1 Choice' For Callum Smith, Says Hearn Pacquiao-Broner Press Conferences Set For Monday, Tuesday Claressa Shields: I Can Go as Low as 154 For Cecilia Braekhus Thurman-Lopez, Garcia-Granados, Santa Cruz-Flores Are Set Boy Jones Jr. vs. Craig Evans For Vacant WBO Euro, Nov. 19 Shawn Porter-Yordenis Ugas Set For March 9 In Las Vegas Joe Smith: If I Land on Beterbiev Like Johnson Did - I'll Finish Him! Kownacki-Washington Set For 1/26 FOX Show From Barclays Holyfield: Two Different Eras, Usyk is The Best of His Time

Latest Active Forum Threads