Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Not Pound for Pound...Champ for Champ 2020, Pt. 2


With so many belts around, the idea of champions can get watered down and not just by the WBA. It’s almost certainly one of the reasons pound-for-pound ratings gained so much more heft in the marketplace in the last two generations.

It was a way to cut through the chaff.

That doesn’t mean there still aren’t men who exemplify what a champion should be. They are the men who face the best available in their class more often than others who share their place as beltholders. In anticipation of the return of all the men who call themselves champions, let’s take a look at each of the seventeen weight classes in the game, identifying the most impressive champion in each division, ending with the top ten title reigns in the sport. 

For the purpose of comparison (and with a full disclosure of personal involvement), this comparison will use the current and archived Transnational Boxing Rankings Board ratings as a reasonable gauge to identify the rated contenders defeated during each current title reign for the primary titlist of each sanctioning body or, where applicable, reigning lineal kings. WBA sub-titlists can be found on the BoxingScene Championship stats page but won’t be included for this evaluation.

Last week featured a look at the champions and titlists from heavyweight to light heavyweight. Let’s continue in this installment with...

Super Middleweight

WBA (Super): Callum Smith (27-0, 19 KO, 2 Defenses); won 09/28/2018, KO7 G. Groves

WBC: David Benavidez (22-0, 19 KO, 0 Defenses); won 09/28/2019, KO9 A. Dirrell

IBF: Caleb Plant (20-0, 12 KO, 2 Defenses); won 01/13/2019. UD12 J. Uzcategui

WBO: Billy Joe Saunders (29-0, 13 KO, 1 Defense); won vacant 05/18/2019, UD12 S. Isufi

168 lbs. is a division really searching for someone to break from the pack. The best win to be found in any of the current title reigns belongs to Smith by way of his stoppage of George Groves in the World Boxing Super Series. The problem with Smith is the baggage of a highly debatable win against rated contender John Ryder. Benevidez might have had more to his credit by now but was set back by a positive drug test in his first go with a strap. Plant and Saunders are both interesting, crafty boxers but it’s hard to find a truly notable reign here at this juncture.



Lineal Champion: Saul Alvarez (53-1-2, 36 KO, 4 Defenses)

WBA (Super): S. Alvarez (1 Defense); won 09/15/2018, MD12 G. Golovkin

WBC: Jermall Charlo (30-0, 23 KO, 3 Defenses – 2 full, 1 interim); won interim 04/21/2018, KO2 H. Centeno; elevated when WBC designated S. Alvarez “Franchise”

IBF/IBO: Gennady Golovkin (40-1-1, 35 KO, 0 Defenses); won vacant 10/05/2019, UD12 S. Dereveyanchenko

WBO: Demetrius Andrade (29-0, 18 KO, 3 Defenses); won vacant 10/20/2018, UD12 W. Kautondokwa

The leader at middleweight has done his share of scale hopping in recent vintage with fights from 154 to 175 lbs. since capturing history’s crown from Cotto. Agree or disagree with the verdicts in his contests with Golovkin, Alvarez at 160 lbs. has taken the fights a champion should. Golovkin twice, and then Jacobs, marked the most deserving threats when he faced them. In addition to those lineal defenses, he also added a defense against rated welterweight Amir Khan. Alvarez’s win over Golovkin doesn’t lend much value to Golovkin’s alphabet straps though Golovkin did secure victory over a highly rated foe to add to his trophy case. Charlo has yet to face a TBRB rated middleweight in his title contests at middleweight while Andrade has defeated only one in the four title fights of his current reign (a then-tenth rated Walter Kautondokwa).

Jr. Middleweight

WBA (Super): Jeison Rosario (20-1-1, 14 KO, 0 Defenses); won 01/18/2020, TKO5 J. Williams

WBC: Jermell Charlo (33-1, 17 KO, 0 Defenses); won 12/21/2019, KO11 T. Harrison

IBF: J. Rosario (0 Defenses); won 01/18/2020, TKO5 J. Williams

WBO: Patrick Teixeira (31-1, 22 KO, 0 Defenses); won interim 11/30/2019, UD12 C. Adames; since elevated to full recognition

Easily one of the most compelling divisions in the sport the last few years, Jr. middleweight is also one of the harder to predict. Upsets of Jarrett Hurd, Jermell Charlo (now avenged), and then Julian Williams have left this talented field without a single major titlist with a defense to their credit. Both Rosario and Charlo compete under the PBC umbrella. At 154 lbs., and the next class down, the PBC has shown a willingness to put their beltholders together. A unification match between Rosario and Charlo would make a compelling case to fill the lineal throne left vacant since the retirement of Floyd Mayweather and illustrate which man is the best example of a champion. For now, Rosario’s title win came against the higher rated foe in Williams for the edge. 


WBA (Super): Manny Pacquiao (62-7-2, 38 KO, 0 Defenses); won 07/20/2019, SD12 K. Thurman

WBC: Errol Spence (26-0, 21 KO, 0 Defense); won 09/28/2019, SD12 S. Porter

IBF: E. Spence (4 Defenses); won 05/27/2018, KO11 Brook

WBO (Super): Terrence Crawford (36-0, 27 KO, 2 Defenses); won 06/09/2018, TKO9 J. Horn

IBO: Sebastian Formella (22-0, 10 KO, 1 Defense); won 07/06/2019, UD12 T. Mbenge   

When Pacquiao lost a hotly debated decision to Jeff Horn, how many would have wagered he’d still be right near the top of the class heading in 2020? Before winning the outright WBA crown from Thurman, he’d already picked up the organization’s sub-title and defended it as well. While the living legend continues on, his work will be cut out for him to climb all the way to the top. Most, fairly, see the debate about the world’s best welterweight as resting between Spence and Crawford. Crawford, an exemplary champion at lightweight and Jr. welterweight, ran Horn out of the ring to win his belt and added a TBRB-rated contender in Egidijus Kavaliauskas to his reign last out. Based on overall title results, and quality of competition, it is Spence who stands out as welterweight’s best example of a champion at the moment. Brook was rated third by TBRB when Spence beat him to start his titled time and he has added two more solid contenders in Lamont Peterson (then rated #8) and Porter (then #4). The Porter win also gave him partial unification. His other defense came against the then-TBRB World champion at Jr. welterweight and #2 lightweight Mikey Garcia. With a loaded cupboard at welterweight on the PBC side, Spence will have no shortage of quality contenders, along with a further unification possibility against Pacquiao, to enhance his reign as one of the best on the current boxing landscape on the road to the likely inevitable showdown with Crawford.

Jr. Welterweight

WBA: J. Taylor (0 Defenses); won 10/26/2019, MD12 R. Prograis

WBC: Jose Ramirez (25-0, 17 KO, 3 Defenses); won vacant 03/17/2018, UD12 A. Imam

IBF: J. Taylor (1 Defense); won 05/18/2019, UD12 I. Baranchyk

WBO: J. Ramirez (0 Defenses); won 07/27/2019, TKO6 M. Hooker

IBO: Jeremiaz Nicolas Ponce (25-0, 16 KO, 0 Defenses); won vacant 09/14/2009, MD12 R. Mueller 

This division is perfectly divided as far as the title belts from the most recognized organizations go. Taylor also has the Ring Magazine belt to his credit after his WBSS tournament final victory over Regis Porgrais. While Ramirez has more wins in title fights, both men have the same number of wins over TBRB-rated men in their title affairs. For Taylor, Baranchyk was rated #7 and Prograis was rated #1. Ramirez has defenses against a then-fourth rated Antonio Orozco and his unification win over a fifth-rated Hooker. Prograis gives Taylor the edge for now but it’s enough to say both men have behaved as champions so far. The sooner they fight to clear up the matter of the true king at Jr. welterweight, the better.

To Be Continued with Lightweight and below

Cliff Rold is the Managing Editor of BoxingScene, a founding member of the Transnational Boxing Rankings Board, and a member of the Boxing Writers Association of America.  He can be reached at

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by Dasmius Shinobi on 05-29-2020

This help as a reminder of the current status of Champions Pre-Pandemic. :boxing:

Comment by Monty Fisto on 05-22-2020

[QUOTE=1hourRun;20572632]Tyson Fury and Billy Joe Saunders have been banned for similar infractions, Josh Taylor needs to go![/QUOTE] He needs to go for the crown accepting his plea of not guilty to possession? As Taylor pointed out, he is regularly tested…

Comment by Fire4231 on 05-22-2020

Lol... So Cliff Rold, now we have to depend on the Transnational Boxing Ranking Board you founded And chair to legitimize your biased selections for pound for pound? Cliff GTFOH with this BS.

Comment by JP Marra on 05-22-2020

GGG clearly beat a 28 year old prime Canelo in 2017 at 36 years old, same age Joe Louis was when he fought Marciano. Only corruption interfered, as everyone agreed GGG won 9-3 or 8-4. Rematch against a PED induced…

Comment by The D3vil on 05-21-2020

Who the hell is Sebastian Formella?

Top Headlines
Arum: Mayer's Gonna Be A Great 'Champeen' And A Great Credit To Women's Boxing Mario Barrios: I Gassed Out Against Akhmedov; I'd Gladly Give Him A Rematch Santa Cruz: I'll Probably Wanna Go Out There & Brawl With Davis, Make It A War Inoue: Casimero Has One-Punch Knockout Power, But He Has A Lot Of Weaknesses Moloney: I Will KO Inoue, Come Out As The Next Superstar In The Sport Daily Bread Mailbag: Lopez, Loma's Loss, Shields, Wilder, More Gervonta Davis Will Be A PPV Attraction Moving Forward, Ellerbe Says Prograis: Me & Teofimo Lopez Would Be A Very Explosive Fight; Let's Do It! Chisora: I Have To Go To Usyk, I'm Going To Go To War! Savannah Marshall: The Lockdown Has Been Brilliant For Females Michel Rivera Believes His Speed, Power, Pressure Will Get Him Past Miller Jason Moloney: A Year That Could've Been Devastating Has Been Exact Opposite For Me Regis Prograis on His Comeback Against Juan Heraldez Inoue: A Lot of Expectations Of Me, I Want To Be Able To Live Up To Them Heavyweight Avalanche Starts With Usyk-Chisora Michel Rivera Believes Davis' Abilities Will Be Too Much For Santa Cruz Haye: You Saw Lopez-Loma? Chisora Will Do Same To Usyk! Jaime Munguia Fights Through Fire, Stops Johnson in Six Due To Severe Cut Dave Allen Gutted Over Fight Falling Out, To Return in Coming Months Jaime Munguia vs. Tureano Johnson - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard Rashidi Ellis Stays Unbeaten, Decisions Alexis Rocha Elwin Soto Boxes Past Carlos Buitrago To Retain Title Devin Haney: I Have a Goal To Be The First Billionaire Boxer! Marlen Esparza Decisions Sulem Urbina Over Eight Rashid Kodzoev Takes Out Tamas Lodi in Five Rounds in Minsk Naoya Inoue, Jason Moloney - Set For Las Vegas Showdown Barrios vs. Karl, Magdaleno vs. Cruz - Weights Ewa Brodnicka Misses Weight, Title Only At Stake For Mikaela Mayer Regis Prograis, Juan Heraldez - Set For Battle Gervonta Davis, Leo Santa Cruz - Ready For War in Texas Inoue-Moloney ESPN+ Weigh-In Report From Las Vegas Weights: Murat Gassiev 230.6-Pounds, Nuri Seferi 225.1 Ryan Garcia vs. Luke Campbell - Undercard Information Gervonta Davis-Leo Santa Cruz Weigh-In Results From San Antonio LIVE STREAM: Gervonta Davis vs. Leo Santa Cruz - Weigh-In Gervonta Davis: My Arms Are Open If Floyd Wants To Work Corner Saturday Night Lee Selby, George Kambosos - Ready For Eliminator Savannah Marshall, Hannah Rankin - Set For Title Clash Michael Conlan Suffers ATFL Tear, Out For 8-12 Weeks's Television Pick of The Week - October 30
Latest Forum Threads