Manny Pacquiao - One of The Greatest


By Michael Rosenthal

When Manny Pacquiao was in his prime, the accolades landed at the same rate as his impossibly quick punches.

The years that stand out most are 2008 and 2009, when he sensationally knocked out in succession Oscar De La Hoya, Ricky Hatton and Miguel Cotto to become a worldwide superstar and stake his claim as one of the best fighters in the world.

Some knowledgeable observers swept up in the Pac-mania – including myself – compared him to the great Henry Armstrong, who many believe is among the best two or three greatest boxers of all time.

Those years are long gone as Pacquiao, now 39, prepares to fight fellow geezer Lucas Matthysse on Saturday in Kuala Lampur, Malaysia, but no one who witnessed that powerful, ball-of-energy version of Pacman will ever forget what they saw.

But was Pacquiao really that good? Was he an all-time great? Or was the perception of him clouded by the excitement he generated?

Reality falls somewhere in the middle. Pacquiao was no Henry Armstrong, who once held three of the eight undisputed championships at the same time and almost won a fourth, but he was without question a special fighter.

Pacquiao’s accomplishments are well documented. Here are just some of them:

• He’s 59-7-2, with 38 knockouts.

• He won major titles in six weight divisions, eight if you count The Ring Magazine/Lineal titles, from flyweight to junior middleweight – a weight difference of 42 pounds.

• He had a record of 6-2-1 against the great Mexico trio of Marco Antonio Barrera, Erik Morales and Juan Manuel Marquez, each of whom is or will be in the International Boxing Hall of Fame.

• He has a record of 20-4-2 in title fights, including The Ring / lineal versions. And remember: He fought one high-profile opponent after another.

• He won title fights in five divisions in a span of only 2 years and 8 months, the dizzying period in which he was compared to Armstrong.

• He took part in a remarkable 17 fights against opponents who are in or likely to enter the Hall of Fame, going 12-4-1 those bouts. They are Tim Bradley (2-1), Floyd Mayweather (0-1), Marquez (2-1-1), Mosley (1-0), Cotto (1-0), De La Hoya (1-0), Hatton (1-0), Barrera (2-0) and Morales (2-1).

• He fought at 106 pounds for his pro debut yet outpointed rugged Antonio Margarito to win a 154-pound title in 2010, although they fought at a 150-pound catch weight.

• And he was wildly popular because he also was one of the most entertaining fighters of his time, which in itself can lead a boxer into the Hall of Fame. That’s how Arturo Gatti got in.

No fighter of his era comes close to matching that sparkling resume except perhaps Mayweather, who never lost a fight but didn’t face as many elite opponents as Pacquiao did. For example, Mayweather faced eight opponents in or likely to enter the Hall of Fame (Pacquiao, Canelo Alvarez, Cotto, Mosley, Marquez, Hatton, De La Hoya and Gatti).

manny-pacquiao (2)_13

In an era when boxers fight less often, we might never see a list of accomplishments like Pacquiao’s again.

Of course, that doesn’t mean we can’t quibble with some aspects of his resume. Here are examples:

• Pacquiao went 2-1-1 against his greatest rival, Marquez, but some believe the master counterpuncher from Mexico won all four fights or at least should’ve had a 3-0-1 advantage.

• The fight that launched Pacquiao into superstardom was his dominating eighth-round stoppage of De La Hoya, which at the time was stunning given De La Hoya’s accomplishments and natural size advantage. However, in retrospect, we know that De La Hoya was a shell of the fighter he had been.

•  Between losses to Morales in 2005 and Bradley in 2012 – Pacquiao’s prime – he went 15-0 (with eight knockouts) against some of the best fighters in the world. However, one could argue that a number of them were flawed. Examples: Morales was in decline by their third fight, some believe Hatton was overrated, Cotto was forced to fight at a catch weight of 145 pounds and Mosley was well past his prime.

Notice I used the word “quibble,” which is what I did in the three examples above. I could go through Armstrong’s resume and do the same thing.

The fact is Pacquiao won his epic series against Marquez. He was a prohibitive underdog going into the De La Hoya fight yet scored a spectacular knockout. And Morales, Hatton, Cotto and Mosley were all legitimate threats in those fights.

And the fact is Pacquiao took the boxing world on an extraordinary ride inside the ring, one that included the stiffest opposition possible (who didn’t he fight?), an unusually long string of memorable victories and more thrills than all the roller coaster parks on the planet combined.

Was he as good or better than Armstrong? No. That would place Pacquiao among the handful of best fighters who ever lived.

I don’t believe he was even the best of his era; Mayweather was. Pacquiao overwhelmed most of his opponents with his speed (hand and foot), power and volume punching but he was vulnerable at times. The Marquez fights are the best examples. Mayweather, a defensive wizard, was more or less untouchable.

But there’s no shame in being second best to Mayweather or the likes of Armstrong, Joe Louis, Ray Robinson, Muhammad Ali and Ray Leonard, who were as close to perfect as any boxer could be.

When all is said and done, Pacquiao can legitimately claim to be one of the greatest fighters in history. That’s saying something.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by ruedboy on 07-15-2018

JMM was the best counter puncher of his era and had the perfect style to go against Pac. Manny still gave Marquez 4 shots at the apple. Can anyone even imagine Floyd doing something like that? Floyd was the best…

Comment by aboutfkntime on 07-15-2018

[QUOTE=Spoon23;18940639]And yet to this day [B]PAC has no smoking gun[/B], while Floyd has shady TE RATIOS, caught Ivs sticking in him etc etc.. Well said.[/QUOTE] I would prefer to leave this, and not get involved but I hate the way…

Comment by Spoon23 on 07-15-2018

[QUOTE=Boxknowledge75;18936916]If a high profile athlete like pac was ever on peds it would've came to light by now. Just like Lance Armstrong. B samples are saved and retested for future use to test for illegal substances that weren't tested for…

Comment by Spoon23 on 07-15-2018

[QUOTE=Low_Blows_420;18936959]Pac faced 17 Hofs mayweather faced 8...floyd cherry pickin ducked atleast 9 times including manny LOL...floyd made sure in history he still #1 coward in boxing[/QUOTE] Wow, harsh, but true.

Comment by rmd22360 on 07-15-2018

[QUOTE=The Big Dunn;18937816]Can’t get caught if you don’t test.[/QUOTE]Guilty until proven innocent??? No you're wrong, Manny was tested by VADA, USADA and the boxing jurisdiction and found nothing. Canelo, Mayweather, Morales and others were....Simply said, Manny Pacquiao was one of…

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (91)
Top Headlines Lomachenko's Manager Gives Update on Rehabilitation, Return Hearn: Wilder Has To Ask - 'Do I Really Believe I Can Beat Joshua?' Eduardo Hernandez Targets Francisco Vargas Eliminator Arum Will Speak With Pacquiao About Crawford, Lomachenko Usyk, Gassiev Arrive in Moscow - Ready For WBSS Final Nelson: Povetkin is a Serious, Serious Threat For Anthony Joshua Floyd Mayweather Tops Forbes Richest Celebrities List Hearn: Povetkin Extremely Dangerous, AJ Will Make a Statement Fabian Maidana vs. Andrey Klimov Lands on Garcia-Easter News: Mykquan Williams, Roney Hines, Frank Galarza, More Carl Frampton vs. Luke Jackson - Undercard Update - 2 Team Lomachenko: Pacquiao Must Go To 135 - No Catch-Weight! Manny Pacquiao: I Still Have Two or Three Fights Left in Me Photos: Manny Pacquiao Arrives Home To a Hero's Welcome Andrew Moloney vs. Luis Concepcion on September 8 Joshua-Povetkin Officially Announced; 9/22 at Wembley Stadium Trainer: I Guarantee Mikey Garcia Will Regret Facing Easter! Pacquiao 'Thinking About' Working With Freddie Roach Again Pacquiao: Khan, Crawford, Lomachenko All Potential Opponents Callum Johnson Warns: Beterbiev Will Know He's Been in a Fight! Liam Smith Confident of Shocking Jaime Munguia, Explains Why British and English Title News: Askin vs. Okolie Sent To Bids Pacquiao Wants Next Fight In U.S.; Arum Says Tax Debt Not $20M Horn's Promoter: Pacquiao's Win Proves He's Not Past It! Pacquiao: If Mayweather Comes Back - Let's Do a Second One! Pacquiao's Win Over Matthysse A Blessing And A Curse Atlas: Pacquiao Beat a Heavy Bag; Diminished Matthysse Quit! Pacquiao: Matthysse Was Hurt From The Punches, Looked Scared Pacquiao Says Buboy Warned Him To Avoid 'Marquez' Mistakes Jose Pedraza Expects a Very Tough Outing With Ray Beltran Manny Pacquiao: Do I Look Old? I'm Back! Lucas Matthysse is Not Sure About The Future of His Career Usyk: I Have No Fear of Fighting Murat Gassiev in Russia Jeff Horn Calls Out Manny Pacquiao For a Rematch Pacquiao: From Round 1, I Knew He Couldn't Handle My Power! Brandon Cook: Brook Fight is Off, Brook Has Ankle Injury Pacquiao Gives High Praise To Buboy as New Head Trainer RBF Exec: We Secured QF/SF Fights For The WBSS Season 2 Pacquiao: Like I Said - I'm Not Gone From Boxing, I'm Still Here! Photos: Pacquiao Crushes Matthysse For First KO Win Since 09

Latest Active Forum Threads