Malignaggi on Spence-Garcia: Weight Classes Exist For A Reason

By Keith Idec

Paulie Malignaggi doesn’t think Mikey Garcia will be out-classed in any way when he encounters Errol Spence Jr.

According to Malignaggi, the four-division champion simply will be too small to beat the taller, stronger Spence in their 12-round, 147-pound title fight. The 30-year-old Garcia will move up two weight classes, from lightweight to welterweight, to face Spence in a Showtime Pay-Per-View main event expected to take place March 16 at the Dallas Cowboys’ AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas.

Malignaggi, an analyst for Showtime and Sky Sports, broke down the Spence-Garcia fight during an open workout Wednesday in Manchester, England, to promote the Oleksandr Usyk-Tony Bellew bout Saturday night.


“I think they’re both very good, fundamentally sound fighters,” Malignaggi told “And I think that in their respective weight classes they are dominant forces. But I think weight classes exist for a reason, you know? And Mikey going up to ’47 is not just coming from lightweight or super lightweight. You know, this is a guy who has fought at featherweight.

“So I think it’s a tough fight. And I think Errol Spence is a really, really tough proposition for full-blown welterweights. And his power is a tough proposition for full-blown welterweights. So I think, at the end of the day, that will probably be the difference in a fight between two very good fighters. It’s just weight classes matter.”

Garcia (39-0, 30 KOs) technically was a lightweight (131) when he made his pro debut 12 years ago. He has since won world titles at featherweight (126 pounds), junior lightweight (130), lightweight (135) and junior welterweight (140).

He fought at 140 pounds as recently as March 10 at Freeman Coliseum in San Antonio, where he dropped and out-pointed then-undefeated Sergey Lipinets (14-1, 10 KOs) by unanimous decision to win the IBF junior welterweight title. The Oxnard, California, native moved back down to lightweight for his following fight – another unanimous-decision victory over previously unbeaten IBF lightweight champ Robert Easter Jr. (21-1, 14 KOs) on July 28 at Staples Center in Los Angeles.

The 28-year-old Spence (24-0, 21 KOs), of DeSoto, Texas, has fought at welterweight or slightly above the 147-pound limit throughout his entire six-year pro career.

Keith Idec is a senior writer/columnist for He can be reached on Twitter @Idecboxing.

User Comments and Feedback (Register For Free To Comment) Comment by Topdogggbm on 11-10-2018

This is my first comment here after being a faithful reader for a long time. Anyways, I'm a big Mikey fan. And all these people talking about he's too small, did you watch the weigh in for the Easter fight?…

Comment by -Kev- on 11-09-2018

You can't shrink a man's balls or his belief in his abilities.

Comment by Manic Shot on 11-09-2018

Credit to Garcia, if he win then he's the #1p4p.

Comment by slimPickings on 11-09-2018

Mikey picking on the WRONG opponent to try to be great against! Makes as much sense to me as Rigo facing Loma!! He may not be the same after this!!!

Comment by Laypipe on 11-09-2018

Would rather see Garcia vs Prograis tbh..

Post a Comment - View More User Comments (29)
Top Headlines Tom Little Very Confident of Mentally Breaking David Price Tony Harrison Motivated To Place Detroit Back in The Spotlight SHO's Farhood: To Me, Fury Lost Lineal Title When He Retired Anthony Mundine Finds His Home Ransacked WBC Prez Confident Canelo Would Sell Out Azteca Stadium Adrien Broner: Pacquiao is Definitely My Biggest Career Fight Amir Khan: If Brook is a Real Man - He Should Admit He's Gay! Nasukawa Eyes KO: I Want To Kick Mayweather's Ass! Photos: Adrien Broner Putting in Work For Pacquiao Title Clash MSG Exec: We Want To Do Biggest, Best Canelo Fights Photos: Cecilia Braekhus Opens School in Uganda Warren 'Fighting For Revenge' in Title Clash on Pacquiao-Broner Gausha 'To Punish' Hernandez on Saturday's Charlo Card Korobov's Manager: This Is A Better Fight Than Charlo-Monroe Baysangurov and AmirKhanyan Headline Show in Kazan Hearn: DAZN wants Canelo to Fight Jacobs and GGG Next Year Chisora Vows To Pounce on Whyte, Take Him To War Showtime To Air Whyte-Chisora Rematch Live From London Barthelemy Could See Pacquiao Stopping Broner in Six Rounds Hearn: Deontay Wilder Not a PPV Star; Talks With His Team Better Jacobs: I'll Move Up To 168 To Fight Canelo; Doesn't Matter To Me Whyte Brushes Off Joshua's Prediction of Chisora Victory Warrington: I Don't View Frampton as Elite, Has Weaknesses Martin Murray Does Not Plan To Rebuild Again if He Loses Povetkin Interested in Facing Whyte or Chisora in 2019 De La Hoya: Canelo Must KO Golovkin in Trilogy, No Decision David Price is Desperate To Taste Victory Again Jermell Charlo Preps For Harrison With a Brooklyn State of Mind De La Hoya: Canelo's KO Opens Doors To New Opponents At 168 Referee Having Sleepless Nights Over Stevenson Outcome David Lemieux Will Fight Next at 168-Pounds, Says Estephan Photos: Manny Pacquiao Celebrates, Throws 40th Birthday Bash David Benavidez: I'm Hungrier Than Ever, More Motivated Dana White Reacts To De La Hoya's Challenge To Fight on May 4 Badou Jack vs. Marcus Browne Finalized For Pacquiao-Broner Photos: Pacquiao, Birthday Aside, Putting in Work For Broner Claressa Shields - BWAA's 2018 Female Fighter of the Year Joshua-Miller At MSG Could Bring Khan-Brook To Wembley 4/13 Korobov: Charlo Just Saying It, He Should Prove It In The Ring Anthony Joshua Backs Dereck Chisora To 'Whoop' Dillian Whyte

Latest Active Forum Threads