Advertisement: IBO Boxing

Hearn: Boxing Needs Video Replays, There is No Downside

By Ron Lewis

Eddie Hearn believes the video replays should be used more widely in boxing after Charlie Edwards held on to his WBC flyweight title when Mauricio Sulaiman, the WBC president, unilaterally overturned the result of his title defence against Julio Cesar Martinez.

Martinez floored Edwards in the third round with a barrage of punches, but after Edwards fell to one knee, Martinez walked around him and landed one final, brutal shot to the ribs, that saw Edwards flip over. Incredibly Mark Lyson, the referee who was handling his first world-title fight, did not notice the obvious foul and counted Edwards out.

Martinez was announced the winner, but with the O2 Arena crowd booing and the late punch being played over and over on the big screens above the ring, Sulaiman decided to act, changing the result to a no-contest, ensuring Edwards kept his title.

edwards-martinez-fight (9)

Hearn, Edwards' promoter, agreed with the decision and said that a video assistant referee system could be a huge benefit to the sport to help rid it of miscarriages of justice.

"What's the downside? There is no downside," Hearn said. "It's not as if it is going to slow the game down. That's the problem that people talk about with football and cricket. There's this big controversy. He can't get up. So let’s look at it.

"They look a it very quickly, and they'll rule on it very quickly. And you're given time to recover (if a boxer is fouled). If there's a questionable low blow, for example, and the ref says you're disqualified it allows someone to say, 'hang on, let's just have a look at that.'

"Essentially, it's VAR for boxing, everybody else is doing it. When somebody is fighting for a world title, and it's his livelihood. It is not allowed by the British Boxing Board of Control, but when you've got 12 screens around the ring, you can't ignore it.

"I think Mauricio was great - he said 'I am the president I don’t need to look at this again'. But I've never seen it before.  I think it was completely, 100 per cent, the right thing to do.

"A lot of people said he should have been disqualified. But somebody tweeted me  'Mauricio Sulaiman has gone full Vince McMahon'. "

Having been given his world title back, there is a question about whetjer Edwards will want to defend the title again, having admitted that he "killed himself" making the 112lb limit.

"He's got to look at the weight, anybody who saw him at the weigh-in will know it's getting hard," Hearn said. "It's eight stone, how long can you make eight stone for?

"He's got to decide whether he moves up to super-fly, which is a wonderful division. Martinez is going to be a problem for people, he's a handful. He messed it up for himself, if he'd have been patient, he might have stopped Charlie Edwards legitimately. It was so blatant. It wasn't on the way down, he moved around him to get the shot in."

User Comments and Feedback
Comment by jonnyc420 on 09-02-2019

No thanks, this would solve nothing.

Comment by KillaMane26 on 09-02-2019

[quote=glenn mcrory;20032247]if [b]the situation was reversed hearn would’ve climbed unto the ring and delivered the late shot himself and burned the replay cameras[/b]. Sulaiman wouldnt have checked them anyways. I saw edwards shattered and broken. That last shot wasnt needed…

Comment by Iron Fister on 09-02-2019

[B]"What's the downside? There is no downside," Hearn said[/B] Translation: Replays can get more timeout breaks for AJ to catch his breath when he gases and spits out his mouthpiece.

Comment by steeve steel on 09-02-2019

[QUOTE=factsarenice;20032527]Who are you kidding, you're an Eddie Hearn stalker.[/QUOTE] And you must be a delusional British boxing fan. There is a support group for you guys 1-800-Br-oo-k-is-gre-at. Get help while you still Khan.

Comment by _Rexy_ on 09-02-2019

[QUOTE=el***;20032973]So he got an L but the ABC organization says he gets to keep the belt. You have the ABC organizations now trying to make a ruling on the outcome of the fights. They dont make the call, the ref…

Top Headlines
Makabu vs. Cieslak Back on Course For WBC Title on January 31 McCarter: Claressa Shields Lacks Power, Still Fights in Amateur Style Deontay Wilder Believes He's Far Too Dangerous To Do MMA Billy Joe Saunders Brings Back Ben Davison As Trainer Blair Cobbs vs. Samuel Kotey Set For Garcia-Fonseca DAZN Bill Claressa Shield's Wish-List Includes Headlining PPV, P4P Lists, MMA Kownacki: After Helenius, I Want The Wilder vs. Fury Winner! Shishkin Defeats Sierra On Points In Uneventful Bout Ergashev Knocks Out Estrella With Body Shot In First Round O'Quinn Out-Points Vasquez In 'ShoBox' Opener Spencer vs. Spring, Cota vs. Cornflake, Mielnicki - Weights Chris Colbert, Jezreel Corrales - Set For Showdown Julian Williams, Jeison Rosario - Ready For War in Philly Helenius: I've Fought Guys Like Kownacki - I Can Beat Him! Felix Verdejo, Christopher Diaz, Nova, Anderson - Weights Julian Williams-Jeison Rosario Weigh-In Results From Philadelphia Eleider Alvarez, Michael Seals - Ready For Battle Kownacki vs. Helenius is Official, March 7 at Barclays Center Steve Rolls vs. Shady Gamhour - UFC Fight Pass on Jan. 28 Williams Learned From Hurd's Mistakes In Handling Hometown Fight Michael Seals: They Wrote Me Off After TKO Loss To Rodriguez Joe Joyce May Have Warm-Up Bout Before Dubois Bout in April Jarrett Hurd: No Intention of Going To 160, I Want Williams Canelo Alvarez Is The BWAA 2019 Fighter Of The Year Floyd Mayweather Is The BWAA's Fighter Of The Decade Ja'Rico O'Quinn Vows To Make a Statement in ShoBox Clash James-Dulorme For 3rd WBA Welterweight Title 4/11 In Minneapolis Scott Quigg vs. Jono Carroll on March 7 in Manchester Parker's Trainer Expects Usyk To Perform Much Better in Next Time Tyson Fury: "If I Don't Knock Wilder Out, It Doesn't Count!"'s Television Pick of The Week - January 17 Brandun Lee: I Need This Step Up In Competition Peter Kahn - A Boxing Success Story, 25 Years In The Making Jordan Gill Cleared After Health Scare, Hopes To Return In March Brook's Trainer Hopes Khan Clash Finally Happens - For The Fans Nearly 19 Years, 250 Editions Later, 'ShoBox' Still True To Mission Ja'Rico O'Quinn Aims To Impress in TV Debut on Showtime McGregor Very Interested in Pacquiao Clash at Allegiant Stadium Arum Expects To Sign Tony Yoka, Have Him Return in Spring Munguia's Co-Promoter Views Golovkin as The Ideal Opponent
Latest Forum Threads