Peak Mike Tyson vs Peak James Toney (Who had better defense and head movement at HW)?

[SplitSecond]

James Toney couldn't even beat Sam Peter and you think he has a chance against a prime Mike Tyson?

Thought Toney had won the first fight. He was pretty old then too.

[IronDanHamza]

Thought Toney had won the first fight. He was pretty old then too.

You might have done but the fact is he didn't beat him.

And yeah obviously he was old but that's the version the TS is referring to.

[IronDanHamza]

Tyson by a mile. Toney was never close to prime at HW and everything about him was diminished. That's what made his success there impressive.

I would use the term "success" somewhat loosely.

[mick1303]

James Toney couldn't even beat Sam Peter and you think he has a chance against a prime Mike Tyson?

TS did not ask who wins a fight between Tyson and Toney. He asked who had better head movement.

[IronDanHamza]

TS did not ask who wins a fight between Tyson and Toney. He asked who had better head movement.

My mistake.