Jake Lamotta or Manny Pacquiao?

[Southpaw16BF]

Who do you feel should be remembered as the greater fighter and why?

[sonnyboyx2]

Pacquiao is to be remembered as one of the Top 3 greatest fighters of all times, LaMotta is remembered for The St.Valentines Day Massacre.

[Fiasco]

Pacquiao is to be remembered as one of the Top 3 greatest fighters of all times, LaMotta is remembered for The St.Valentines Day Massacre.

Top 3? Oh, boy..

[Southpaw Stinger]

Top 3? Oh, boy..

Made a turn into **** city.

Time to leave.

[*RAZOR RUIZ*]

top 3 is way too high

[gran campeon]

well lets see....a all around skilled guy who continues to rise weight classes vs a crude fighter whose biggest win is because he weighted more than the other guy....then he lost 4 more times to him...

[Wukillabeez78]

If Manny and Floyd fight and Manny beats him then I'd have to rank him pretty high on the All-Time Pound for Pound Best List... Floyd is the most talented fighter of this generation and if Manny beats him he might go down in the top 5 ever. Even if he and Mayweather never fight his resume is impressive enough right now to merit consideration as an ATG...

Overall, I'd say Pacquiao's body of work is > Lamotta's.

[tanibanana]

my acount says it all...

[mickey malone]

I'd put Pac somewhere in the top 30.. If he does a job on Mayweather, that would elevate him into the top 10..
I'd place LaMotta somewhere between 30 and 50.. Pacquiao is the better boxer..

[them_apples]

Pacquiao by 50 miles.