This rubbed me the wrong way a bit.
The first case was in the Kongo fight when Kongo caught Buentello with a knee when he was down. After informing Buentello that he doesn't get 5 minutes for an illegal head strike, he proceeded to "I'll give you a second though." Now while I don't necessarily agree with the rule that illegal head strikes are not afforded recovery time, rules are rules and their is nothing in the rules which give referrers authority to allow a discretionary time out.
It was at this point that he walked over to Kongo's corner and then stood there, apparently watching the reply on the big screen, before deciding to deduct a point. Now one could certainly make a good argument that instant replays should be included in MMA. However they are not. This was another case of Dean straying outside of the official rules.
Another example accord in the Jones-Vera fight after Vera landed the illegal upkick. He stopped the action and actually deducted a point from Vera. At that point the fight should have restarted on the feet. Instead, Dean gave Jones the option of being restarted on the ground, something which I have never seen in the UFC or in the US (and something which in my judgment the point deduction should've precluded irregardless).
Herb Dean seems like a good guy and is certainly a capable ref, but when referees start straying outside of the rules and playing by their own rulebook it is a serious problem imo. And while each case could be defended on the merit that the rules are incomplete/mistaken/etc., rules are rules and it is the job of the officials to enforce the rules to a T to the furthest degree possible.
The first case was in the Kongo fight when Kongo caught Buentello with a knee when he was down. After informing Buentello that he doesn't get 5 minutes for an illegal head strike, he proceeded to "I'll give you a second though." Now while I don't necessarily agree with the rule that illegal head strikes are not afforded recovery time, rules are rules and their is nothing in the rules which give referrers authority to allow a discretionary time out.
It was at this point that he walked over to Kongo's corner and then stood there, apparently watching the reply on the big screen, before deciding to deduct a point. Now one could certainly make a good argument that instant replays should be included in MMA. However they are not. This was another case of Dean straying outside of the official rules.
Another example accord in the Jones-Vera fight after Vera landed the illegal upkick. He stopped the action and actually deducted a point from Vera. At that point the fight should have restarted on the feet. Instead, Dean gave Jones the option of being restarted on the ground, something which I have never seen in the UFC or in the US (and something which in my judgment the point deduction should've precluded irregardless).
Herb Dean seems like a good guy and is certainly a capable ref, but when referees start straying outside of the rules and playing by their own rulebook it is a serious problem imo. And while each case could be defended on the merit that the rules are incomplete/mistaken/etc., rules are rules and it is the job of the officials to enforce the rules to a T to the furthest degree possible.
Comment