Best Director: Kubrick, Nolan, Tarantino, Cameron?

[savorduhflavor]

Directors working today:

Nolan
Scorsese
Mann
Aronofsky
Coen Bros
Lynch
McQueen
Refn
Campbell
Scott
Van Sant
Herzog
















Dog *****






Cameron

PTA>>>>>>>>>>>>>>That entire list.

[rorymac]

PTA>>>>>>>>>>>>>>That entire list.

Oh yeah I would put him in my list, not at the top though

[res]

Agree with Scorsese and Kubrik, can't pick one.

[savorduhflavor]

Oh yeah I would put him in my list, not at the top though

What current writer/director do you put above PTA?

[rorymac]

What current writer/director do you put above PTA?

Michael Mann, Steve McQueen, Christopher Nolan..

I like PTA, looking forward to The Master

[NEETzsche]

slightly prefer scosese to kubrick. the other three are hacks.

[The Tase]

Scoresese
Kubrick
Tarantino
NOlan
Cameron

The best in the biz at the moment right now in my eyes is David Fincher.

[NEETzsche]

Directors working today:

Nolan
Scorsese
Mann
Aronofsky
Coen Bros
Lynch
McQueen
Refn
Campbell
Scott
Van Sant
Herzog

hollywood-centric as fuck. kiarostami, wong kar wai and almodovar, to name but three, piss all over almost all of them.

[rorymac]

hollywood-centric as fuck. kiarostami, wong kar wai and almodovar, to name but three, piss all over almost all of them.

I like Almodovar but I don't think he pisses on any of them.

Have I really offended you so much that you need to try and slate my opinion?

[talip bin osman]

dont forget lolita...

anyway, two guys i consider up there in the higher strata of filmmaking are alfred h i t c h c o c k and akira kurosawa...

i would like to add mr. billy wilder to these aforementioned ATGs...

his films aint that cinematic or picturesque, but its full of witty dialogue and a very tight script... its oranges and mangoes if u compare him to hitch but he was really a top-notch storyteller in the medium of film...