Top ten welterweights - where do you rank Margarito?

[Bucktown Beast]

147 champ: baldomir

1. Floyd Mayeather Jr.
2. Zab Judah
3. Paul Williams
4. Luis Collazo
5. Antonio Margarito
6. Kermit Cintron
7. Carlos Quintana
8. Joshua Clottey
9. joel Julio
10. Arturo Gatti

Good list. Only thing is that I would put Paul Williams ahead of Judah.

[The Surgeon]

147 champ: baldomir

1. Floyd Mayeather Jr.
2. Zab Judah
3. Paul Williams
4. Luis Collazo
5. Antonio Margarito
6. Kermit Cintron
7. Carlos Quintana
8. Joshua Clottey
9. joel Julio
10. Arturo Gatti

oN THE BUTTON M8!

[TheBlackWallStreet]

how can mayweather be number 1 hes had 2 fights at welterwieght and theyve come against a washed yup 140 mithcel and a unfocussed zab judah
yah p4p hes better but this is a ratings not skills

easy because past experience at a lower or higher weight class factors into rating. Thats why when you see a guy move up who was an ex champ he usually falls within the top ten or 15 even though he has no experience at that weight. Mayweather also won a fight against Sharmba Mitchell who was rated within the top 10 to position himself into a title fight. He fought Zab Judah who fell in the rankings but still held a belt. Mayweather took that belt and since Margarito has yet to face a Champion at the 147lb divison or even hold a belt in another weight class he is rated lower. Does this answer your question?

[DiegoFuego]

1) Baldomir
2) Mayweather
3) Hatton (but he's leaving)
4) Judah
5) Margarito