A Draw

[GreatestIam]

I just watched the fight and scored it round 4 round and to my surprise came out with a draw! i had Peter winning rds 1,4,5,10 and 12, i had Toney winning rds 2,6,8,9 and 11: rds 3 and 7 where even and rd 9 i scored 9-8 for Toney... My final score was 114-114 but if i had to choose a winner at gunpoint i would defintley say Toney won, his jab was there all night, and he landed some semi-effective shots and counters, however Peter's jab while not as effective as Toneys did back him up when it landed, Peter wobbled Toney about 2-3 times i guess and countered nicely ever time Toney threw his left hook, but thats to be expected from a bigger guy! Toney only rocked Peter once and that was for a second, but Toney just seemed to be doing the most work towards the begining of the rounds and Peter later which i dont think was as much work as Toney but enough to keep him in a VERY close fight!

The judge who scored the fight 116-111 was smoking crack, 115-112 for Toney reasonable, and again 116-111 from judge 3 is absurd!

[Tong Po]

Peter wobbled Toney

Pun intended?

[Mishra100]

I called it a draw.

[enadeus]

Did you guys take the point away for the foul Peter commited?

[Mishra100]

Did you guys take the point away for the foul Peter commited?

Yes.

Peter was countering Toney with a huge right everytime Toney would hit him with an accurate left. Peter always hit him with the stronger shot so he gets the nod on all those exchanges... Peter was also using a pretty sharp jab but Toney's was definitely better. But because Peter was hitting him harder and was countering pretty well is the reason he was able to get a draw in my eyes. If I had to chose between the 2 I would say Toney won.

[GreatestIam]

Did you guys take the point away for the foul Peter commited?

ya i did but i scored the round a 9-8 rd for toney

[tracylee]

I called it a draw.

Same here...so in no way a robbery.

[THE REAL NINJA]

ya i did but i scored the round a 9-8 rd for toney

9-8 ????? ok then

[fluent2332]

the first time watching it i had it 115-112 for toney. i scored it again and it came out 114-114 with one or 2 rounds (rounds 4 and 12) that i gave toney that i thought could have went to peter . its a hard ass fight to judge. 2nd time around i focused on peter more and he was landing some serious shots. james would start the round fast but slow down and let peter land right hands later in the round. to my surprise peter landed a high % of power shots that i didnt catch as much the first time watching. i would suggest everyone rewatch the fight again

[GreatestIam]

9-8 ????? ok then

ya becuz i had the round goin to peter, but then the point deduction and well the point deduction i just didnt feel toney did enough to get a 10 that round so i gave him a 9 and peter got an 8 is that 2 hard to understand\?