Simply amazing.. here's the master scorecard for Toney-Peter

[restless_438]

In shear disbelief....

[IMG]http://www.*********.com/1photos/peter_toney_scorecard.gif[/IMG]

Two of the three judges preferred Samuel Peter's powerful shots over James Toney's more accurate and frequent punching Saturday night at Staples Center in Los Angeles. Peter won four of the first five rounds plus the last four rounds on the cards of both judges Alejandro Rochin and **** Flaherty, who each scored the bout 116-111 in favor of Peter. Toney was credited with winning only three rounds on both those cards. By contrast, judge Gale Van Hoy had Toney winning seven of the twelve rounds en route to a 115-112 score for Toney. Only Van Hoy gave Toney a 10-8 round in the ninth, the round Peter was penalized a point by referee Raul Caiz, Sr.

[Memorex]

The judges should be shot in the head.

[Truth]

Terrible.....

[restless_438]

Toney won the 11th, thats rediculous

yeah, i gave Peter the 10th, gave Toney the 11th, and really gave Peter the 12th out of sympathy..

[Boxing Analyst]

I agree to the judges that Peter won 4 of first 5 rounds. Thats exactly how I scored the fight.

[restless_438]

I agree to the judges that Peter won 4 of first 5 rounds. Thats exactly how I scored the fight.

If you honestly gave Peter the all three of the last rounds, scored it 9-9 in the 9th, not to mention gave Peter awhole lot of rounds midway through, i have to seriously question whether your scoring out of favoritism, cause i know i don't.

If you say your scorecard is like the two, that means you gave Toney 3 rounds total, which is plain ridiculous.

[Kball15]

I agree to the judges that Peter won 4 of first 5 rounds. Thats exactly how I scored the fight.

thats completely wrong. THATS A SHAME!!! thats why boxing is a dying sport. thats ur reason right there.

toney won 2 of the first 4.

i had it going back and forth until the 6th round, where toney won 4 straight from then on (with one 10-10 and one 10-8 round)

and two judges had it 9-9 for peter on that point deduction! how? the round has to be clearly won by peter for that to happen, and it wasnt, not even close

[Katz]

my scorecard is the same on the first 5 rounds, Which i have Peter won the 4 out 5. My scorecard is close, i have Peter won 8 rounds to 4.

115-112 including the deduction.

[maxorido]

no, my scorecard is the same on the first 5 rounds, Which i have Peter won the 4 out 5. My scorecard is close, i have Peter won 8 rounds to 4.

115-112 including the deduction.

****ing amazing.

[Enayze]

If you honestly gave Peter the all three of the last rounds, scored it 9-9 in the 9th, not to mention gave Peter awhole lot of rounds midway through, i have to seriously question whether your scoring out of favoritism, cause i know i don't.

If you say your scorecard is like the two, that means you gave Toney 3 rounds total, which is plain ridiculous.

I scored it 9-9 in the 9th Peter won that round.