You know the drill, how did your personal scorecards look for Toney-Peter?

[Kid Achilles]

I laughed out loud when Peter did that, and I was pulling for him. I likened it to a gorilla as well, a pissed off silverback. Toney is lucky Peter had gloves on or he might have cracked his head like a ripe melon.

[Piggu]

Toney---Peter
1. 9-10
2. 9-10
3. 9-10
4. 9-10
5. 8-10
6. 7-10
7. 6-40
8. 5-3
9. 9-12
10. 6-3
11. 6-3
12. 1-9
TOTAL
84 Toney 130 Peter

[Vanilla Gorilla]

the same thing Botha did to Tyson

except Botha was slick enough to get away with it.

[Burzum_666]

10-10 even, feeling out round of sorts
10-9: Toney
10-9: Toney
10-9: Toney (close round)
10-9: Peter
10-9: Toney
10-9: Toney
10-9: Toney
10-8: Toney
10-9: Peter
10-9: Toney
10-9: Toney ( Close round)

My final score is 118-110 for Toney. And for the record. I'm a big Peter fan, and I absolutely despise James Toney. But regardless, there is no denying he won that fight.

[Crazy Dude]

Round 01 - 10-9 Peter
Round 02 - 10-9 Toney
Round 03 - 10-9 Peter
Round 04 - 10-9 Peter
Round 05 - 10-9 Peter
Round 06 - 10-9 Toney
Round 07 - 10-9 Toney
Round 08 - 10-9 Toney
Round 09 - 10-8 Toney
Round 10 - 10-9 Peter
Round 11 - 10-9 Peter
Round 12 - 10-9 Peter

total 114-113 Peter

[Atnan]

this fight wasnt at all a hard decision to make...toney won this fight 116-111, peters got beat, this is the worst deicision in the decade

[Lights0ut]

Toney 116-111. Kid Achilles must be crying every night after he realizes he knows nothing about the sport of boxing.

[fluent2332]

my original scorecard

toney peter
1 10 9
2 10 9
3 9 10
4 10 9
5 9 10
6 10 9
7 10 10
8 9 10
9 10 8
10 9 10
11 10 9
12 9 10

115 112

i watched the fight again and paid more attention to what samuel peter was doing. heres the card for the 2nd time thru

toney peter
1 9 10
2 10 9
3 9 10
4 10 9
5 9 10
6 10 9
7 10 10
8 9 10
9 9 9
10 9 10
11 10 9
12 10 9

114 114

it was really tough to score this fight. i am gonna watch it again soon. the 2nd time thru i gave toney rounds 4 and 12 which both could have went to peter

[Steak]

Toney Peter
1 10-10 10-10
2 10-9 20-19
3 9-10 29-29
4 9-10 38-39
5 9-10 47-49
6 10-9 57-58
7 10-9 67-67
8 10-9 77-76
9 9-9 86-85
10 9-10 95-95
11 10-9 105-104
12 9-10 114-114
Draw

such a hard fight to score. instead of a back and forth fight, almost every round was hard to score. but what do you expect though...the styles are so different!
________
Ivan Capelli

[Lights0ut]

I re-scored the fight giving EVERY close round to Peter (round 3 and 5), and Toney still won the fight 114-113 with the point deduction. Whoever scored this fight for Peter is a damn fool.