Grade a fighter day 8: What grade do you give Miguel Cotto?

[HitmanTommy]

Disclaimer: These threads will be MAILED in a envelope and sent to each individual fighter. The cutoff for these votes will be 24 hours. After that, the poll closes and the thread along with the poll results gets mailed off to the fighters address.

How the voting process works: Whichever grade has the most votes will be the fighters majority grade.

Day 1: Frank Bruno 21 votes: majority grade = B
Day 2: Deontay Wilder 30 votes: majority grade = C+
Day 3: Antonio Margarito 27 votes: majority grade = B
Day 4: Michael Spinks 28 votes: majority grade = A+
Day 5: Adrien Broner 33 votes: majority grade = B
Day 6: Shannon Briggs 41 votes: majority grade = C
Day 7: Paulie Malignaggi 38 votes: majority grade =C/C+

What grade do you give Miguel Cotto?

[Dodger07]

Hes a B+ , borderline A fighter imo. Very good career with memorable fights and wins. Good power and good boxing ability.

[daggum]

wait you are going to mail paulie something that says he was a C fighter?

i wish i could see his little face when he reads that, but these rankings are pretty silly. margarito and broner are both B level? how is that possible? margarito beat an undefeated cotto and sergio martinez and has twice as many top 10 wins as broner. doesnt really add up so these grades are more like who do fanboys like more and most people seem to like paulie and he's still a C lol, that means his career really did suck mah balls

[Spray_resistant]

He is an A level fighter, good thudding jab, when he used it more vicious left hook to the body, overall good power, decent speed, has won titles in 4 weight classes, and has some notable wins.

[daggum]

He is an A level fighter, good thudding jab, when he used it more vicious left hook to the body, overall good power, decent speed, has won titles in 4 weight classes, and has some notable wins.

broner did that too! can we change his grade to A+? is it too late!!!

[Spray_resistant]

broner did that too! can we change his grade to A+? is it too late!!!

C'mon forget the belts then Miguel has beaten some good fighters and you can clearly see he is much better than AB who I rate lower because he had the potential and natural talent to do better but squandered it being a goof.

[HitmanTommy]

wait you are going to mail paulie something that says he was a C fighter?

i wish i could see his little face when he reads that, but these rankings are pretty silly. margarito and broner are both B level? how is that possible? margarito beat an undefeated cotto and sergio martinez and has twice as many top 10 wins as broner. doesnt really add up so these grades are more like who do fanboys like more and most people seem to like paulie and he's still a C lol, that means his career really did suck mah balls

Broner was 1 vote away from becoming a C+.

These results will be mailed out to the fighters addresses all at one time in a big giant envelope, so they can't miss it!

Once 15 fighters have been graded, the entire batch will be mailed out.

If the fighters want a chance to respond to the critics, they will get their chance to do so by signing up on this site.

All of the fighters threads are open, so they are free to reply at anytime.

[powershots]

Who knows how far Cotto would have gone if he didnt take that beating from Margarito. But still a Hall of Famer, 4 weight class champion, millions in the bank. One of the best fighters ever out of Puerto Rico. Ill give him an A.

[djtmal]

Solid B........

[ippo]

B to B+ level fighter. He is above average in speed,stamina,power,IQ. He struggles when facing the truly elite fighters like pacquiao,mayweather,canelo. He could possible hang with A- to A level fighters, but will break down as the rounds go by.