How can anyone seriously believe Floyd is greater than Manny P4P?

[Kagami Taiga]

Both great fighters. Floyd is considered by everyone to be the BEST fighter of his era. Some consider Manny to be the GREATEST. Others say its Floyd. I think Floyd is greater but there are arguments for both sides. I guess we will have to see when it is all said and done where history falls down.

[just the facts]

Both great fighters. Floyd is considered by everyone to be the BEST fighter of his era. Some consider Manny to be the GREATEST. Others say its Floyd. I think Floyd is greater but there are arguments for both sides. I guess we will have to see when it is all said and done where history falls down.

Level headed, intelligent comments in a Floyd/Pac thread? Where's the fun in that?

Just kidding. Totally agree, good post.

[pasawayako]

The same Max Kellerman who scored Floyd/Pac wide for Floyd?

Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that.

On May 2nd of 2015, Floyd ruined your life.

So u think max kellerman is wrong? So u think pac won the fight? Which one is it?

[pasawayako]

This the difference.

Floyd fans said that floyd is greater than pac.

On the other side

Boxing legends, trainers, analyst said that pac is greater than floyd.

[Bandman]

floydruinslives

[RuleOfTheSpear]

How accomplished the fighters Pac & Floyd beat (on paper) at the time they fought them by number of world title scalps on their opponents resume:


Pac:
Dela Hoya - 24
Morales II and III - 17, 17
Barrera I and II - 16, 21
Mosley - 15
Cotto - 9
Margarito - 10
Bradley II and III - 9, 11
Larios - 8
Marquez II and III - 6, 9
Ledwaba - 6
Broner - 6
Thurman - 3
Hatton - 3
Sasakul - 3
Julio - 3
Diaz - 1
Clottey - 1
Algieri - 1
Vargas - 1

Floyd:
Dela Hoya - 24
Pacquiao - 15
Mosley - 15
Cotto - 11
Judah - 9
Marquez - 7
Canelo - 7
Berto - 7
Gatti - 6
Guerrero - 5
Hernandez - 4
Corrales - 4
Castillo I and II - 3, 3
Hatton - 3
Corley - 3
Maidana I and II - 2, 2
Baldomir - 2
Vargas - 1
Mitchell - 1
Ortiz - 1


Pac > Floyd

[just the facts]

So u think max kellerman is wrong? So u think pac won the fight? Which one is it?

You and I both know Floyd EASILY beat your hero and your undying man love will never change that.

I just find it hilarious that you want to pass off Kellermans opinion as expert when you swear that Manny beat Floyd but Kellerman doesn't agree.

Basically you want us to accept Kellermans opinion when it supports your agenda but not when it doesn't.

On May 2nd of 2015, Floyd ruined your life.

[just the facts]

How accomplished the fighters Pac & Floyd beat (on paper) at the time they fought them by number of world title scalps on their opponents resume:


Pac:
Dela Hoya - 24
Morales II and III - 17, 17
Barrera I and II - 16, 21
Mosley - 15
Cotto - 9
Margarito - 10
Bradley II and III - 9, 11
Larios - 8
Marquez II and III - 6, 9
Ledwaba - 6
Broner - 6
Thurman - 3
Hatton - 3
Sasakul - 3
Julio - 3
Diaz - 1
Clottey - 1
Algieri - 1
Vargas - 1

Floyd:
Dela Hoya - 24
Pacquiao - 15
Mosley - 15
Cotto - 11
Judah - 9
Marquez - 7
Canelo - 7
Berto - 7
Gatti - 6
Guerrero - 5
Hernandez - 4
Corrales - 4
Castillo I and II - 3, 3
Hatton - 3
Corley - 3
Maidana I and II - 2, 2
Baldomir - 2
Vargas - 1
Mitchell - 1
Ortiz - 1


Pac > Floyd

Figure in the 7 losses, one of them H2H.

[RuleOfTheSpear]

Figure in the 7 losses, one of them H2H.

Sugar Ray Robinson has 19 losses. What's your point?

The greatest of champions is not measured by losses. But how they transcend their losses and continue fighting.

[just the facts]

Sugar Ray Robinson has 19 losses. What's your point?

The greatest of champions is not measured by losses. But how they transcend their losses and continue fighting.

So losses count for nothing?